Forming a governing coalition in Israel is akin to “squaring the circle” as it requires combining mutually exclusive ideological demands to reach a 61-seat parliamentary majority. Can it be done?
By Peter Bailey
Philosopher George Santayana (1863 -1952) said “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.”
Aligning with this astute sentiment, Winston Churchill in a House of Commons speech expressed:
“Those that fail to learn from history are doomed to repeat it.”

The importance of what can be learnt from Israel’s political history so as not to repeat the same mistakes cannot be understated. In order to examine the state of play in the negotiations currently taking place to form a governing coalition, it’s important to start with a short history lesson. But first, a short synopsis of the political realities in Israel.
Israel is unique in the world of global politics. Israeli politics, to use an old Jewish expression, is like a matzo pudding, containing a little bit of everything to suit all tastes. While the rest of the democratic world has a left, a right and a center, in Israel not only is there a left, right and center, there is also a religious left, right and center, as well as religious parties that do not accept the Zionist ideal. For good measure there are extreme right religious parties and mainstream right religious parties added to the mix. Supplementary to that are the Arab based parties, an important factor, particularly with their much-increased presence in the current Knesset. The Arab parties similarly have their left, right and center, with an extreme religious element thrown in for good measure. Forming a workable coalition is thus obviously a herculean task that encompasses everything from delicate negotiations to hardball brinkmanship, accompanied by nebulous undertakings together with unrealistic commitments.

The conundrum in forming a coalition is built into the electoral system, and that has been prevalent since Israel’s very first election. The first Knesset was voted in on 25 January 1949, setting the tone for the future, with 12 parties being elected. The first government cobbled together by David Ben Gurion, was established on the back of the coalition of 5 parties, with the extreme left Mapam and Maki lists as well as the extreme right Herut and LEHI lists excluded. The parties to the coalition were Mapai, predecessor to Labor, United Religious Front, composed of the Ashkenazi Ultra-Orthodox and the Religious Zionists, Sephardim and Oriental Communities, forerunner to the modern Shas, and the Progressives, a centrist liberal-socialist party. The final member of the coalition was the Democratic List of Nazareth, an Arab party sponsored by Mapai, which had won 2 seats in the Knesset, and this at a time when the war between Israel and the surrounding Arab States was still raging.
Festus Mogae, an economist and former president of Botswana widely acknowledged as being one of Africa’s most stable and enduring democracies said:
“I think one of the problems in Africa has been bad leaders and good leaders spoiling what they have done by overstaying their welcome and then beginning to stay in power by force or all sorts of trickery.”
There are increasing signs that the quote by Mogae can be applied to Israel and its current Prime Minister.

The result of the election held on 27 October 2026, presented the leaders of the two most successful parties, the Likud, led by Benjamin Netanyahu, and Yashar, led by Gadi Eisenkot, with few choices to cobble together a coalition. Neither party, together with its allies, could attain the magical 61 seats required to attain a majority in the 120-seat Knesset. The Arab List and Ra’am, the two Arab groupings in the Knesset, joined what is referred as the Change Bloc led by Eisenkot, to ensure that President Herzog gave the poisoned chalice of the first opportunity of forming a government to Eisenkot. This gave him 28 days, plus the option of requesting a further 14 days, in which to square the circle of Israeli politics.
The current Prime Minister, now in a caretaker capacity, has a huge personal motivation to thwart Eisenkot’s efforts to form a viable coalition. Besides the current charges of bribery, fraud, and breach of trust which he faces, the potential for criminal charges with regard to the Meron Disaster and the Submarine Affair also hang over his head. Israel Police has recently reopened the investigation into the Meron Tragedy in terms of the findings of the State Commission of Inquiry into the disaster which cost 45 lives. With regard to the Submarine Affair, the investigation by the State Commission of Enquiry is still ongoing. Netanyahu further faces the establishment of a State Commission of Inquiry into the events surrounding the Hamas attack on 7 October 2023, which his government has spent the last three years doing everything possible to avoid, which might suggest that he has much to fear from such an inquiry.
Political realities in Israel clearly define that any coalition has to include like-minded parties, together with some widely divergent parties, in order to make up the numbers. The two Ashkenazi Ultra-Orthodox parties in the current coalition, appear to be unconcerned with the national interest, focused instead on their own narrow needs, the foremost of which is:
– avoiding military conscription followed by
– funding for religious schools and Yeshivas,
– housing and
– health care.
While the funding is vital for the daily needs of their followers, the failure to provide a secular education for their children, condemns them to menial jobs and no possibility of tertiary education. The result is that there are very few Haredi or Ultra-Orthodox doctors, and no likelihood of the situation changing. Despite these shortcomings, the Ultra-Orthodox parties wield enormous political power, as they are in demand to establish a workable coalition, while answering the ever-increasing funding needs of their followers. The result translates their financial demands akin to bribery upon those seeking their support for a coalition.
The previous government made funding readily available, while not pursuing greater levels of military conscription, which has become a major bone of contention as a result of the need for greater numbers of soldiers since the Hamas attack on 7 October 2023. Keeping the ultra-Orthodox parties onside while legislating for greater conscription, has become a major stumbling block in forming a coalition. The result of the election left the Likud-anchored right-wing bloc, including their previous ultra-Orthodox partners, 8 seats short of the magical 61 seats to form a government.
A further option open to Netanyahu is to convince individual Knesset Members from the Change Bloc parties to join one of the right-wing parties, with promises of cabinet or important committee positions on offer. The other choice is to turn to the Arab parties for support in some form or other. While there are reports that numerous overtures have been made to two Arab parties, these have been vigorously denied by the Likud. Despite the denials, prior to the establishment of the Bennet/Lapid Change Government in June 2021, there were reports that Netanyahu had approached Ra’am to join his coalition. Both the Times of Israel (25/03/21 and 20/12/2025) and The Jerusalem Post (22/10/2026) have published articles stating that Religious Zionist Party leader Bezalel Smotrich repeatedly claimed to have personally prevented Netanyahu from accepting Ra’am as a partner in the right-wing coalition, after which Ra’am joined the Bennet/Lapid Change Government.

Let us return to 2026 and the 36th Knesset. The Change Bloc leader Gadi Eisenkot can potentially form a majority government with either the United Torah List, or the Arab parties. Netanyahu, on the other hand, is left with the Arab parties as his only potential partners to establish a majority government. We are now in the limbo period of wait and see, as Eisenkot and his Change Bloc partners juggle the possibilities open to them. Despite reports that the Likud has made approaches to the Arab majority parties, there has been no shortage of vile invective directed at the Arab community as a whole, and the Arab Knesset members in particular. The objective of the vilification of Ra’am and the Joint List is to delegitimise a potential coalition of the Change Bloc and the Arab parties in the court of public opinion, making it difficult for Eisenkot to build a coalition in the current Knesset, and thus force another election. For the Change Bloc, bringing the Arabs into a governing coalition is not without immense risk, while the potential for a realignment of Israeli politics and a normalization of democracy in society, holds great promise, and could have far reaching effects.
Despite the continual anti-Arab rhetoric from Netanyahu and his right-wing allies, the evidence points to him having given a “hechsher”, or stamp of approval to the inclusion of Arab parties in government, some 70 years after Ben Gurion did the same in forming the first government of the reborn State of Israel in 1949. Netanyahu regularly refers to his great respect for Torah values, while also making numerous racist statements about Israeli Arabs, comments which were described by Eisenkot as “a violent and racist campaign against Arab citizens.” (Times of Israel, 12/11/2026)
A number of religious commentators contend Netanyahu’s comments as being contrary to what is taught in the Torah regarding the treatment of others, bringing into question his statements regarding respect for Torah values.
It is also at variance with Israel’s Declaration of Independence
that enshrines “will ensure complete equality of social and political rights to all its citizens irrespective of religion, race or sex…”
With neither Netanyahu nor the opposition having yet a clear path to forming a government amid ongoing disputes and complex coalition arithmetic, a troubled and traumatized people wait the impossible of “squaring the circle”. That being said, however unwelcome the coalition chaos, far less unwelcome is a leader in the words of Festus Mogae of “overstaying their welcome.”
Should Netanyahu heed the African leader’s advice, it would most certainly make the impossible of “squaring the circle” a lot more possible!
About the writer:

Peter Bailey made Aliyah from South Africa with his wife Jeanne in 2013 in order to join their three sons and families who were already in Israel. He spent 35 years in the glass industry in South Africa while also being active in military veterans affairs, being National Chairman of The South African Jewish Ex Service League prior to making Aliyah. He completed his compulsory military training in South Africa in 1964 and was commissioned as an officer in 1965, retiring with the rank of major, after 19 years service in the SADF Citizen Force. While on active service on the Namibian Angolan border in 1976 he commanded 101 Task Force’s Counter Insurgency Operations Training Centre. He has enjoyed a lifelong interest in military history and has conducted intensive research into the Jewish contribution to South Africa’s military history, writing many papers on the subject and giving relevant lectures across South Africa. He is the author of two published books, Street Names in Israel and Men of Valor, Israel’s Latter Day Heroes.
While the mission of Lay of the Land (LotL) is to provide a wide and diverse perspective of affairs in Israel, the Middle East and the Jewish world, the opinions, beliefs and viewpoints expressed by its various writers are not necessarily ones of the owners and management of LOTL but of the writers themselves. LotL endeavours to the best of its ability to credit the use of all known photographs to the photographer and/or owner of such photographs (0&EO).