MARGINAL SLAVERY

We Were Slaves in Lithuania. Lithuania Calls It Marginal.

By Grant Gochin

Next spring, at Seder tables around the world, a child will ask why this night is different from all other nights. The family will answer with the sentence at the heart of the Haggadah: Avadim hayinu le-Pharaoh be-Mitzrayim. We were slaves to Pharaoh in Egypt.

For generations, Jews have retold an enslavement more than three thousand years old. The Mishnah requires each of us, in every generation, to see himself as though he personally came out of Egypt. We eat the bitter herb so that the slavery stays in the mouth and does not retreat into a textbook.

That leaves a question I cannot put down. We keep Pharaoh’s whip alive across three millennia. We do not keep the Lithuanian county head’s labor order, the Lithuanian policeman’s rifle or the hands a Lithuanian farmer tied, though all of them belong to the lifetime of people still alive.

In 1941, Jews were enslaved in Lithuania. Lithuanian officials listed them, Lithuanian police guarded them and Lithuanian farmers worked them, under rules the German occupier wrote. Most of them were then murdered.

Lithuania’s state Genocide and Resistance Research Centre published, on page 40 of its 2020 Holocaust volume, a description of Lithuanian participation as “essentially marginal.” The passage gets there by pointing up the German chain of command. I asked the Centre to correct or annotate it. On 3 November 2026, it refused.

My earlier articles in this series I set that one sentence beside the murders, the rapes, the murdered children and the plunder. Now I set it beside the slavery.

A note on sources. Nothing here depends on the Centre’s authority. Where I quote the Centre, I treat its words as claims about itself, not as proof. The facts come from wartime documents, from historians working outside the Centre, and, where it cuts deepest, from the Centre’s own pages.

Jewish women return to the Kovno ghetto after forced labor on the outside. They line up to be searched by German and Lithuanian guards. Kovno, Lithuania, between 1941 and 1944.

AVADIM HAYINU: WE WERE SLAVES IN LITHUANIA

The occupier did not hide what the system was. On 13 August 1941, Reich Commissioner Hinrich Lohse ordered that Jews fit for work be drafted for forced labor. The historian Joachim Tauber, in Arbeit als Hoffnung, shows that their pay was to cover bare subsistence and was not to match the work done. In April 1942, Franz Murer told Vilnius employers in writing that the assignment of Jews to work “ist Zwangsarbeit” – forced labor. The money for that labor went into the Reich Commissioner’s budget.

The orders came from the Germans. The lists were made by Lithuanians.

The next day, the Lithuanian head of Alytus County reported to the Lithuanian Labor Organization Department, sorting the Jews of his county into age groups for work. On 20 July 1941, the Lithuanian Activist Front staff in Joniškis recorded that 30 to 40 Jews were used every day on roads and bridges. Under the Lithuanian General Council for Internal Affairs sat an Inspectorate of Forced Labor Camps, which supervised the camps and regulated their finances. The historian Christoph Dieckmann found its camp statutes, issued on 1 October 1941. When the German Security Police complained in 1943 about conditions in the camps of the state peat trust, the Generalkommissar replied that the camps had to use “freely recruited Lithuanians” as guards.

The Centre calls this marginal.

Jewish forced laborers at work making shoes in a ghetto workshop. Kovno, Lithuania, December 1943.

MA NISHTANA: FOUR QUESTIONS FOR THE CENTER

Pravieniškės was a forced-labor camp east of Kaunas. Dieckmann describes it in 1941 as mainly a labor camp for Jews. The Centre’s own journal records that the prisoners who worked its peat bog and forest “už darbą negaudavo jokio atlygio” – they received no payment for their work.

The same article records about 280 Jews shot at Pravieniškės in August 1941 and 253 more in September. It says the guards carried out the executions. For the killings of 1941, it names no one. The Yahad map of killing sites attributes the September shooting to members of a Lithuanian self-defense battalion, together with German troops.

Yakob Vizgordiski works at a machine in a factory in the Kovno ghetto in German-occupied Kaunas, Lithuania, between 1941 and 1943.

Forced labor without wages is slavery. The Centre wrote down the missing wages itself.

So, here are four questions for the Centre, in the form every Jewish child knows.

• Why is an order that reached down to boys of twelve marginal?

• Why is a peat bog where prisoners worked for nothing, and where about 533 Jews were shot, marginal?

• Why are farmers who bound women’s hands and feet and drove them to the pits marginal?

• Why are policemen who marched women and children to a labor camp, and then shot them, marginal?

The Centre’s answer rests on rank. The Germans gave the orders, so the Lithuanian part was secondary. Rank tells you who signed the directive. It does not tell you what happened to the boy on the list, the prisoner on the bog or the woman whose hands were tied. For each of them, the Lithuanian official, guard and farmer were the slavery. They were the ones in the room.

A group of children in the Kovno ghetto in Lithuania. This photograph was taken by George Kadish between 1941 and 1943.

MAROR: THE WOMEN OF TELŠIAI

The bitter herb at the Seder is meant to make the eyes water. Let it be Telšiai.

In the summer of 1941, the Jewish women of Telšiai were held at Geruliai. Their husbands, fathers and sons had already been shot. Yad Vashem’s record of the site preserves a survivor’s words: farmers would come to the camp and forcefully take the girls to work in the fields.

Khane Pelts survived to testify, and I set out her account in an earlier article. Some peasants, she said, kept the women to spare themselves the cost of servants, and “exploited the women with hard work.” Before Christmas, the women were ordered back, supposedly for health examinations. “Many peasants bound the hands and feet of their Jewish women and took them back.” Those who were a little late “brought the bound women directly to the pits near the Rainiai compound.”

Tauber records that the farmers paid the occupation authority three rubles a day for each Jewish woman. The farmer paid the German. Tauber’s account records nothing paid to her. She was taken by force from a camp where her family’s killers stood guard. She could not refuse and could not leave. When the farmers had no more use for her, they tied her hands and feet and delivered her to be shot.

The farmer paid three rubles for her day’s labor. What power did she have to refuse?

WORK, THEN THE PIT

At the Seder we sing Dayenu, “it would have been enough,” and count the gifts one by one.

The Centre’s word deserves its own count. Had the record held only the murders, it would have been enough to strike the word. Only the rapes – and it would have been enough. Only the murdered children. Only the plunder. Now add the slavery.

How much more does the Centre need?

“WE WERE SLAVES TO HITLER IN GERMANY”

Lithuanian collaborators guard Jews before their execution. Ponary, Lithuania, June–July, 1941.

The survivors did not wait for anyone’s permission to put their own slavery into the Seder. In April 1946, they gathered in Munich for the first Passover after liberation, led by the U.S. Army chaplain Abraham Klausner. The Haggadah they used was written by a Lithuanian Jew, Yosef Dov Sheinson, a Hebrew teacher from Kovno who had survived slave-labor camps in the Dachau complex. Klausner’s preamble said it plainly: Pharaoh and Egypt had given way to Hitler and Germany. Sheinson rewrote the opening line: “We were slaves to Hitler in Germany.”

Then came the moment that belongs to the youngest child. At every Seder table in the world, a small voice asks why this night is different. In Munich there was no small voice. The children had been murdered, and the Center for Jewish History calls their absence the first and most painful difference of that night. A survivor who was there later recalled that when the time came for the Four Questions, the room began to weep. Grown men, who had carried stones and dug graves, sat at the table and could not begin. Then one man asked the child’s question himself, and the others joined him, as JTA reported.

Next spring, a child will ask that question again. Somewhere in that room should be the memory of the children who could not ask it in Munich, and of the women in Telšiai who were never asked anything at all before their hands were tied.

On August 30, 1941, Jewish women from the towns of Telšiai, Alsedziai, Varniai, Zarenai, Laukuva, Luoke and Nevarenai were transported by Lithuanian policemen from the Geruliai camp, located ten kilometers from Telšiai, to pits dug in a forest a short distance away where they were shot by the pits, and buried. According to testimonies, Jewish children were thrown alive into the pits and then killed. Seen here after the war are two women at the site of a mass grave at Geruliai. (Photo Collection, 503/13777)

That is the precedent. Survivors who had been slaves months earlier made their own enslavement part of Passover. Sheinson’s opening line named the German master. He was writing in Germany, among the ruins of his own family, and owed no one a complete indictment.

Lithuania owes one, and it has had eighty years. A 2011 Centre study says provincial Jews were most likely “not regarded as a serious labor force.” Not serious enough to be kept alive. Serious enough to be listed by trade, guarded on the bog, rented to farmers and returned bound to the pits.

The IHRA working definition of Holocaust denial and distortion lists, as distortion, intentional efforts to excuse or minimize the impact of the Holocaust or its principal elements, including collaborators and allies of Nazi Germany. Lithuania is a member of IHRA. IHRA has not ruled on page 40. The Centre, however, was shown the record and expressly kept the word. Measure that conduct against the definition its own state adopted.

SAY IT ABOUT AMERICA

Try the word on another history. Suppose an institution of the American government called the overseers, the slave patrols and the slave traders “essentially marginal,” because the laws were made elsewhere, and refused to correct it. No museum, university or official would stand beside it, and no Black American would be asked to prove that the overseer mattered to the man under his whip. American slavery was a crime of whips, rape, stolen children and auction blocks, but it ran on a cold arithmetic: an enslaved man was capital, and a dead slave was a loss on the books, so his owner kept him alive to work. In Lithuania, no one carried a Jew on the books. The Jew was a body waiting for a pit, and when the work ran out there was no sale and no inheritance, only bound hands and a trench. That was not a labor system that happened to kill. It was a killing system that paused for labor. So why do we Jews accept the word? Lithuanian officials are welcomed by Jewish organizations and photographed at Jewish events while the state’s Genocide Centre keeps “marginal” in print. No Black community in America would sit for that photograph.

BE-KHOL DOR VA-DOR: IN EVERY GENERATION

The Haggadah says that in every generation they rise up to destroy us. It also says that in every generation we must see ourselves as though we left Egypt. The two sentences belong together. Memory is how Jews answer those who would erase them.

Pharaoh is not distorting anything. A European Union member state is, today, with a state budget behind it.

The Centre can still act. It can correct or annotate page 40. It can answer the forced-labor record, document by document. The Seimas, to which the Centre answers, can ask why it refused.

Until then, I ask every rabbi, every community and every family that will sit at a Seder table this Passover to add one more remembrance to the night:

We were slaves in Lithuania. We were listed by Lithuanian officials, guarded by Lithuanian police and worked on Lithuanian farms, within the lives of our parents and grandparents. Lithuania’s Genocide Centre calls their part marginal. Tonight we remember them, and we refuse the word.

Let the youngest child ask a fifth question: Why on this night do we remember Telšiai, Dimitravas, Pravieniškės and Aleksotas? Let the answer be: Because the state that holds their records calls the Lithuanian part marginal, and we will not let that word stand.

What was marginal about binding a woman’s hands and feet and delivering her to the slaughter pits?



About the writer:

Grant Arthur Gochin currently serves as the Honorary Consul for the Republic of Togo. He is the Emeritus Special Envoy for Diaspora Affairs for the African Union, which represents the fifty-five African nations, and Emeritus Vice Dean of the Los Angeles Consular Corps, the second largest Consular Corps in the world. Gochin is actively involved in Jewish affairs, focusing on historical justice. He has spent the past twenty five years documenting and restoring signs of Jewish life in Lithuania. He has served as the Chair of the Maceva Project in Lithuania, which mapped / inventoried / documented / restored over fifty abandoned and neglected Jewish cemeteries. Gochin is the author of “Malice, Murder and Manipulation”, published in 2013. His book documents his family history of oppression in Lithuania. He is presently working on a project to expose the current Holocaust revisionism within the Lithuanian government. Professionally, Gochin is a Certified Financial Planner and practices as a Wealth Advisor in California, where he lives with his family.





RECOVERY AND RESTORATION

My mission is to rebuild what my motherland – the Islamic  Republic – has destroyed and erased.

By Marziyeh Amirizadeh

As the founder and president of NewPersia.org, I come to Israel for my fifth visit in three years with a clear mission: to restore what the Islamic Republic regime has destroyed, to rebuild the friendship between the Iranian and Israeli people, and to help create a future founded on truth, dignity, mutual respect, and peace. In Israel I am not only physically closer to Iran, the country of my birth, since I fled in 2010, I also feel a similar culture that makes me feel at home. While Iran is the country of my birth, Israel is my spiritual home.

Helping Hand.  The writer (r) in January 2026 with Jonathan Feldstein (l) harvesting olives in Israel as part of the Root & Branch partnership, the proceeds of which will help Israelis impacted by the war.

I established NewPersia.org to give voice to persecuted Christians and oppressed women under Islam, exposes the regime’s lies, and works to restore relationships between Persians, Jews, and Christians. The Islamic regime does not represent the heart, history, or true identity of the Iranian people. Our past includes friendship, protection, and respect for Jews dating back to King Cyrus. Before 1979, Israel and Iran enjoyed warm relations. The ayatollahs hijacked and destroyed all that. I believe it will be restored once the Islamic regime falls.

I am not alone among Iranians who are committed to restoring that historic friendship, a bond that existed long before the 1979 Islamic Revolution. We will rebuild the cultural, historical, diplomatic, and human connections the regime has spent decades trying to erase. I bring a message of solidarity from countless Iranians who love Israel, admire its people, and stand with Israelis against the regime’s terrorism, hatred, and hostility all rooted in evil, extremist Islam.

Massacre Message. The writer broadcasting in Farsi to her fellow Iranians from the Nova Festival Memorial Site in southern Israel.

One way to do this is through Root & Branch which I co-founded with my friend and orthodox Jewish partner, Jonathan Feldstein. We are bringing Chrisitans to harvest olives in Israel as a symbol of love and unity, and have the vision to establish a memorial that honors the lives and shared history of Israelis and Iranians who have suffered and been murdered at the hands of the Islamic Republic. This will stand as a lasting symbol of remembrance, reconciliation, and the restoration of our historic bond. I pray it will be the cornerstone for Iranians to establish meaningful memorials like the ones I have seen in Israel.  We can learn from Israel, and heal from five decades of suffering with which they have been afflicted.

Reminding her fellow Iranians. Explains the writer, “Each one of these Israelis brutally murdered by Hamas were supported by the brutal regime of the Islamic Republic.”
 

In the spirit of that reconciliation, we will strengthen the growing unity between our peoples and turn our shared values, history, aspirations – and enemies – into a lasting partnership. This includes recovering, preserving, and telling the historical truth the Islamic regime has distorted, suppressed, and attempted to erase. We will educate fellow Iranians about the suffering, trauma, and challenges the Israeli people have endured, encouraging understanding, compassion, and solidarity through videos like this in Farsi, speaking directly to the Iranian people. We will hold the terrorist regime accountable for forcing the Iranian nation to repeat slogans such as “Death to Israel” for its own propaganda and political interests, using our country’s name, history, reputation, and resources to promote hatred and wage war against Israel and the West.

We also much expose and undermine the regime’s false narrative that Iranians are enemies of Israel. Many Iranians see Israel as a nation that has heard their cries after decades of oppression. They admire the Israeli people, its soldiers, and its leadership. I seek to deliver a warm message of friendship, respect, and affection to the Israeli people from the kindhearted people of Iran, many of whom dream of visiting Israel and reconnecting with a nation they consider a historic friend. Visiting the Gaza border last month, I was privileged to meet and speak with high school students who were encouraged to hear that the Iranian people love Israel, and that we – Israelis and Iranians – share the common enemy of the Islamists.

We must also express our sincere sympathy and apologies to the Israeli people who have been targets of the terrorist ideology rooted in our birthplace. We recognize the suffering, fear, trauma, and loss that Israeli families and children have endured through years of terrorism, conflict, and hatred. My dear Israeli brothers and sisters: the Iranian people are not your enemies. Even when the regime attempts to turn the world against Israel by spreading antisemitism, hatred, and misinformation, we will not remain silent. We stand with Israel, defend their dignity, and speak the truth.

We honor the legacy of King Cyrus by supporting the Jewish people’s right to preserve their religious heritage and historical connection to Jerusalem. Cyrus did not merely permit the Jewish people to return and rebuild their Temple; he also provided financial support through the royal treasury. As recorded in Ezra 6:3-5, a memorandum of his decree, later reaffirmed under King Darius, specified that the Temple was to be rebuilt with royal funding, including construction expenses, and that the sacred vessels taken from Jerusalem were to be returned.

King Cyrus the Great supported the Jewish people by issuing the Edict of Restoration in 538–539 BCE, allowing exiles to return to Jerusalem and rebuild the Second Temple.

Cyrus’s legacy represents something extraordinary: a Persian king who recognized the importance of religious freedom, honored the Jewish people, and actively supported the restoration of their sacred heritage. We aspire to carry that model and spirit of friendship, generosity, and respect into our own generation. We honor, respect, and embrace the people of Israel and recognize the importance of their faith, heritage, and relationship with the God of Israel and the centrality of Jerusalem to all the Jewish people. Respect for one another’s history and spiritual identity is essential to genuine friendship.

When the Islamic regime falls and Iran is free again, we will welcome Israelis to our homeland with open arms and the highest honor. We want Israelis and Jews in general to visit our cities, explore our historic sites, experience our hospitality, and rediscover the friendship that once connected our nations. We will serve kosher kebab, kotlet, and Ghormeh sabzi. Future generations of Iranians and Israelis should grow up knowing that they were never destined to be enemies.

Reconstruction & Redemption – Model for Today. Cyrus the Great, who founded the Achaemenid Empire in 550 BC is the subject of much praise in the Hebrew Bible. Here is a depiction of the reconstruction of Jerusalem under Cyrus, Darius and Xerxes. (Picture from the Book of Ezra, 1921.)

We are not here to create another division. We are here to heal one imposed by the ayatollahs. We want to reclaim the legacy of Cyrus, replacing propaganda with truth, hatred with friendship, destruction with restoration, and fear with hope. What the Islamic regime has tried to destroy, we are determined to rebuild. What it has tried to divide, we are determined to unite.

Long live the friendship between the Iranian and Israeli people. May a free Iran and Israel become friends once again, not only for our generation, but for generations to come just as in generations past.



About the writer:

Marziyeh (Marzi) Amirizadeh is an Iranian American author, public speaker, human rights advocate, and President of Newpersia.org. She has written two books “Captive in Iran,” and “A Love Journey with God” which are available on www.marzisjourney.com. She is an Iranian American who immigrated to the US after being sentenced to death by hanging in Iran for the crime of converting to Christianity. She endured months of mental and physical hardships and intense interrogation in Evin prison- one of the most brutal prisons in the world. 








MANDY PATINKIN AND ME

While an acclaimed actor, as a Jew he fails as a leading man

By Jonathan Feldstein

You don’t know this about me, but award-winning actor Mandy Patinkin, and I go way back even though we’ve never met. In 1988 following being named ABC News Person of the Week, I spent most of the rest of the year negotiating a TV movie contract about my life that led ABC News to select me with this distinction. There’s a lot more to the five-minute ABC News story, enough to have a LA producer call me the following Monday in my office.

The movie never materialized as a consequence of a changing mood in Hollywood. Movie producers clearly decided  following Soviet Premier Mikhail Gorbachev introducing glasnost and perestroika, and emerging as “the darling of the West”, such a movie would likely be perceived of as being anti-Soviet and hence financially too risky.

Poster of Patinkin.  An imagined poster of Patinkin playing the writer who supported during the 1980s Soviet Jewish refuseniks.

I reminded the producer that my story was about liberty, how one individual could help another achieve freedom. Even still, I was not ashamed with it being branded anti-Soviet because the Soviet Union literally represented nothing good globally, or specifically vis-à-vis the Jewish people about which my story was focused. I was fine leaving the contract.

What did all of this have to do with Chicago-native Mandy Patinkin?

At the time, the conversation about the movie had progressed that even though we never signed the contract, we were talking about who would be the lead actor playing me. Mandy Patinkin was the frontrunner for consideration  and although he was 10 years older than me at the time –  and still is – people believed he could be made to look younger. He had a beard, as I did at the time. He was Jewish and my story was a very Jewish story about freedom. So for the preference being for a Jewish actor to play me,  his name was being seriously floated.

I was thinking about Patinkin recently following comments he made regarding Jewish support for the Senate candidacy of Abdul El-Sayed for Senate in Michigan. Despite his relative fame as an actor, his misguided comments expose ignorance.

Mandy’s Misguided Messaging. Jewish ‘Homeland’ star, Mandy Patinkin posts that Jewish safety in the US is best served by voting for Michigan Democratic U.S. Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed who advocates an end to U.S. military aid to Israel including defensive systems like the Iron Dome.

Patinkin has posted videos urging Jewish voters to support Abdul El-Sayed citing concern for their “safety” in the US.

Patinkin asserts:

 “Jewish safety depends on a real multiracial democracy, and Abdul is the one fighting to protect it.”

The contradiction of Jews electing an Islamist for their safety, is profoundly astounding.

In addition to my five minutes on ABC News, I have acted in one movie, and done some TV commercials and promos. I have done hundreds of live and recorded interviews. While I do know how to deliver a line, none of these make me an actor.

By the same token, that Patinkin has lived through and experienced modern Jewish history, neither makes him an historian, or an eligible qualified speaker on Jewish history. In fact, his uniquely diaspora perspective influenced by Buddhism is void of modern Jewish and Israeli history through which he has lived, much less not-so-ancient discrimination against Jews under Islam going back to Mohammed.

Saying that “Jewish safety depends on a real multiracial democracy,” views Jewish history through the prism of being outside Israel, with no awareness of Jewish life in Israel. It’s from the perspective of a tolerated second-class citizen protected by others. If that’s Patinkin’s view, no wonder he supports (and has been fooled by) the anti-Zionist antisemitic candidate in Michigan. Hooking his cart to El-Sayed’s Islamist horse, it doesn’t faze Patinkin that the candidate will not even call out antisemitic ads supporting his candidacy. Patinkin places himself solidly in the timeless role of Jews and Chrisitans under Islam as dhimmi – the second-class citizen who is either tolerated because of paying the Islamic jizya tax required of infidels, or being forcefully converted. It makes one wonder if Patinkin is trying out for the role of King of the Dhimmi.

Fiend not Friend. Michigan Democratic U.S. Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed (above), who Mandy Patinkin supports has publicly stated that Israel “should not be considered an American ally.”

Embracing El-Sayed, much less the narrow diaspora-based mentality that Jewish security can only be granted by others, Patinkin has written himself out of any role in the Jewish future. Forget a leading role, he’s not even an understudy.

Patinkin does however embrace the role of “useless idiot” to the point he should be nominated for an Oscar! Sadly, too many Jews throughout history in shifting to the radical Left paid a heavy price some of whom in the process became puppets to the Islamists. It reminds me of the parents of another Chicago-born Jewish friend, Abe Stolar.

Born in Chicago in 1912 to Russian emigree parents who fled Czarist pogroms, Abe’s parents were homesick for the motherland. They were also  inspired by communism and imbibing the communist Kool-Aid, as a teen, Abe’s parents took him to Moscow to see firsthand the worker’s paradise. Five years later under Stalin’s purges, Abe’s father was arrested and never seen again.

In 1975, Abe, his wife Gita and their son applied to leave the USSR. That’s right, Communism offered no freedom just to leave the socialist utopia. They received permission to leave, selling all their belongings yet at the last moment – before boarding the plane – their permission was revoked. The Stolars were forced to return to their empty Moscow apartment, hopeless.

I met Abe a decade later.  He was an American citizen detained in Moscow, frustrated and desperate to leave, but he was jovial, friendly, and welcoming. Two years later, I went back to Moscow and visited Abe again. He was more hopeful as he saw signs that things in the USSR were changing, but he was still an American citizen forcefully detained in Moscow. Eventually, in 1989, at 77 years old, Abe and his family were able to leave and settle in Israel. Abe understood that the Jewish future, even at 77, was in Israel, not based on the whims of others.

Rescuing Refuseniks. ABC News Person of the Week segment from March 25, 1988, recounting the story of Jonathan Feldstein’s adoption of the Stein Family from Moscow, Soviet Jewish refusenicks, and his activities and activism which resulted in their freedom.

Mandy Patinkin’s ignorance of history is a shanda, an embarrassment. Unlike Abe Stolar’s parents, he has decades of seeing the horrible and dangerous consequence of the Red-Green (Communist-Islamist) alliance which he plays into now, Islamists using leftists to advance their ideology with the leftists gladly playing their role with glee.

Abe Stolar’s parents had not yet witnessed or experienced the Red-Green alliance, much less suffered under it. Perhaps they could be forgiven for their communist fervor given how badly Jews had been treated under the Czars. Patinkin should know better. There is not a single surviving and thriving Jewish community under Islam. To suggest that Jews in America – or anywhere for that matter – should outsource their future and safety to others, much less Islamists like El-Sayeed, is more than foolish. It is dangerous.

Saving Souls in the USSR. The writer (left),  Kate, and her father Victorin in July 1985, the day he met them and proposed marriage in order to get her US citizenship and bring her family to America. (courtesy)

Closer to Abe Stolar’s age now than he was to my age in 1988, perhaps one day there will be a movie about Abe Stolar in which Mandy Patinkin can play the lead. Or maybe there will one day be movies about the Jewish communities purged under Islam with a role for Mandy Patinkin as one of the Jews dismembered by their Muslim neighbors. Until then, he has defined himself in such a fringe role among the Jewish people that he has essentially written himself out of the Jewish people. So, for him, of all people, to preach to the Jewish people, is inane at best.

I have other words, but then I might lose my PG-13 rating!



About the writer:

Jonathan Feldstein was born and educated in the U.S. and immigrated to Israel in 2004. He is married and the father of six. Throughout his life and career, he has become a respected bridge between Jews and Christians and serves as president of the Genesis 123 Foundation. He writes regularly on major Christian websites about Israel and shares experiences of living as an Orthodox Jew in Israel. He is host of the popular Inspiration from Zion podcast. He can be reached at firstpersonisrael@gmail.com.







REST IN PEACE, NOBEL PEACE PRIZE

With the UN and the Norwegian Nobel Committee handing jurist Navi Pillay a megaphone on a platter, little wonder Hamas has welcomed her as its poster girl.

By Marika Sboros

(A shorter version of this article appeared in the Daily Friend on October 18, 2026.)

South African jurist Navanethem “Navi” Pillay was at a conference in Courtroom 600 at Nuremberg’s Palace of Justice on October 9 when the news broke that she had won the 2026 Nobel Peace Prize.

Pillay (85) told journalists that the last thing she did before hearing the news was to “deliver the report on Gaza, naming what’s happening there as genocide”.

In the room where Nazi war criminals stood trial after World War II, a jurist declared the worst possible allegation against the Jewish state a guilty verdict. The Norwegian Nobel Committee has given it a seal of approval.

The timing was, by all accounts, coincidental. There was nothing coincidental in her choice of words, nor anything about peace.

Hamas has embraced her as its poster girl. Senior Hamas official Bassem Naim called Pillay’s prize a “message of hope.” Given the terror group’s explicitly genocidal charter against Israel, I don’t dare imagine what he actually hopes for.

Australian political cartoonist John Spooner was similarly cynical.

Pillay the Parot. John Spooner’s cartoon in an Australian newspaper captures Navi Pillay’s track record of a persistent bias against Israel much appreciated by Hamas that perpetrated the worst mass execution of civilian Jews since the Nazi Holocaust.

AN ‘IMPORTANT PART’….

Norwegian Nobel Committee chair Jørgen Watne Frydnes told reporters that Pillay’s “work on Gaza” was “an important part” of the committee’s reasoning. That work is her report as chair of a United Nations (UN) Commission of Inquiry, which in September 2025 concluded that Israel had committed genocide in Gaza.

Frydnes told Agence France-Presse that his committee has taken no stand on genocide, as the International Court of Justice (ICJ) must still rule on it. That’s disingenuous. A committee that makes a genocide finding a key reason for its most cherished prize doesn’t get to claim it says nothing about genocide.

Governments, legal experts and organisations have vigorously disputed the commission’s methodology, handling of genocidal intent and the impartiality of all three commissioners.

Even admirers of Pillay’s record find the report hard to defend. The report’s account of the war begins on October 7, 2023, the day, it says, that “Israel launched its military offensive in Gaza”. The report is silent on why.

Hamas’s massacre of around 1,200 people and the taking of 251 hostages on October 7, 2023, appear nowhere in that account. The first mention of Hamas surfaces 13 paragraphs later, as one of Israel’s “terror targets”.

For a finding that rests on inferring Israel’s intent, that is no small omission.

South African historian Peter Swanepoel, writing in the Daily Friend, concedes that the commission documented Hamas’s atrocities in an earlier report – but in a report assessing genocidal intent, he says, “such a selective opening chronology is difficult to defend.”

I’d call it indefensible.

Criticism of the prize comes not only from Israel’s supporters in South Africa. Financial journalist Tim Cohen, (who is not Jewish, despite his name) whose sympathies, he says, “have largely been with the Palestinians,” respects Pillay. Yet he too believes that the committee “made a mistake.”

Frydnes saw all the political landmines and handed Pillay the prize anyway.

WHERE’S THE COURAGE?

His committee has commended Pillay’s “exceptional courage.” She professed surprise. “Why would you need courage to speak the truth?” she asked. “You interpret the law, you look at all the facts, so it’s impartial decision-making.”

She was oblivious to the ironies drenching that statement.

The UN’s own Declaration on Fact-finding says that fact-finding should be “comprehensive, objective, impartial and timely.”

As a jurist and former judge of international tribunals, Pillay knows that.

In June 2020, she signed a petition by South Africa’s Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) Coalition urging governments to “Sanction Apartheid Israel”. A year later, she was chairing a UN inquiry into the very state she had condemned.

When fellow commissioner Miloon Kothari complained in July 2022 that social media were controlled largely by the “Jewish lobby,” she brushed it off, insisting he’d been “deliberately misquoted.”

Pillay defends Antisemite. Following Miloon Kothari (above), a member of the United Nations Human Rights Council’s special commission into Israel and the Palestinian territories questioning in an interview “why [Israel is] even a member of the United Nations,” and complaining that social media was controlled by “the Jewish lobby”,  Navi Pillay came to his defense saying he was “deliberately misquoted.” (Photo: Bertrand Guay/AFP via Getty Images)

A month later, attorney Sara Gon, writing in the Daily Friend, set out Pillay’s long, unedifying record of demonising Israel, including accusations of deliberately murdering Palestinian children in conflict zones.

Gon called for Pillay’s removal as chair. Pillay stayed in the post. So much for her courage and impartiality.

CREDIT WHERE IT IS DUE

Pillay’s early record is commendable. She defended opponents of apartheid and won rights for Robben Island prisoners, Nelson Mandela among them, including to see lawyers.

As a judge at the UN’s Rwanda tribunal, she sat on the bench that delivered the first conviction for genocide by an international court, and helped establish that rape can be an act of genocide.

That alone means that she understands the legal meaning of genocide. How she could equate Rwanda with Israel’s military response to Hamas, whose charter is explicitly genocidal against Israel, is astonishing to many legal and military experts.

Pillay’s defenders like to claim there’s no evidence that Israel has not committed genocide in Gaza, even that the ICJ has already ruled Israel plausibly guilty of genocide in Gaza.

That’s simply false, as ICJ judge president at the time, Joan Donaghue, has publicly confirmed. It turns the law on its head. The burden of proof lies with accusers.

A jurist, of all people, knows that.

A jurist also knows that pictures of flattened buildings do not prove genocide. Mosul lay in ruins after the battle to drive out Islamic State in 2017. The US-led coalition faced accusations of war crimes, not genocide. Destruction is evidence of war.

So, why does the word genocide matter so much?

Polish-Jewish lawyer Raphael Lemkin coined it in 1944 to name what the Nazis were doing to Europe’s Jews. Turning it wrongly against the Jewish state casts descendants of the Nazis’ victims as the new Nazis.

That is Holocaust inversion of the worst order. It’s why so many Jews call the genocide claim a “blood libel”.

In Nuremberg, Pillay reminded world leaders of their “legal obligation to protect human rights and refrain from war.” Three weeks after Hamas launched its war against Israel on October 7, 2023, she told Al Jazeera that Palestinians were “actually forced to resort to armed struggle.”

The obligation to refrain from war, through her lens, binds some more than others.

‘PEACE REQUIRES JUSTICE’

Alfred Nobel set the bar. His will reserved the prize for work towards “fraternity between nations”, disarmament and peace congresses. He knew that judges generally don’t make peace.

Negotiators, ceasefire brokers and reconcilers do.

In squeezing Pillay to fit Nobel’s will, the committee recasts international law as “peace conferences in their modern form.” Its claim that she “strengthens fraternity between nations” rests shakily on three words from Frydnes: “Peace requires justice.”

That presents a heavily contested philosophical contention as settled truth.

Scholars of international law and history have long warned that justice crusades can wreck the very order that keeps the peace. They pose the question the committee ducks. Whose justice?

Pillay’s own country chose truth and amnesty over prosecution to move beyond apartheid. Even the Nuremberg trials began only after Germany’s unconditional surrender.

Peace came first; victors decided later what justice looked like.

Whichever way Frydnes spins it, the Nobel Peace Prize to Pillay is a deliberate, significant propaganda coup for the anti-Israel lobby. Pillay cannot ply her pro-Palestinian trade in a vacuum. The UN and the Norwegian Nobel Committee have handed her a megaphone on a platter.

Former Soviet dissident Natan Sharansky says Pillay’s award “appears to be the greatest possible legitimization of the now-established consensus about Israel’s war in Gaza.” He warns that “just because the entire world believes something does not make it true.”

Former world chess champion Garry Kasparov posted on X that “maybe next year they will award the Chemistry prize to a Hamas bomb maker.”

MISSED OPORTUNITY

South Africans are entitled to celebrate their first female Nobel Peace laureate.

Equally, they’re entitled to ask why she is feted by terrorists who mass-raped women, children and some men, tortured and slaughtered children in front of parents, parents in front of children, burned families alive and took civilians, including children and babies, to Gaza as hostages on October 7.

Among the hostages was 84-year-old Ditza Heiman, held for 53 days, 48 in the attic of a UN Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) teacher. At the UN Human Rights Council on September 15, her daughter, peace activist Neta Heiman Mina, asked:

“How could you place the education of Gaza’s next generation with someone involved in holding an elderly woman hostage?”

Exposing UNRWA. Addressing the 63rd session of the UN Human Rights Council in Geneva on the conditions her mother Ditza Heiman endured after being abducted during the Hamas-led attack on Israel on October 7, 2023 and being confined to the attic of a an UNRWA teacher, Neta Heiman Mina (above) appealed to the United Nations to reconsider its continued funding of UNRWA. (Photo: Courtesy)

The Nobel Committee missed a golden opportunity to show that people can hold the pain of innocent Palestinians and Israelis together, in their hands, hearts and heads.

That’s what real peacemakers do. And real peacemakers know who is and is not a terrorist.

Pillay does not fit that bill.

Her Nobel Prize, aimed at strengthening peace through international law, is already hardening battle lines against peace. It will likely make the world less peaceful and more dangerous for Jews.

As the Wall Street Journal’s editorial writers put it, “It’s possible that the Nobel Committee will someday bestow its peace prize on a less worthy recipient than Navanethem ‘Navi’ Pillay, but we doubt it.”

“The last thing this prize will do is promote the cause of peace,” they say.

Amen to that, I say.



About the writer:

Marika Sboros is a South African freelance investigative journalist with decades of experience writing fulltime for the country’s top media titles on a wide range of topics. She started her career as a hard-news reporter in the newsroom of the now defunct Rand Daily Mail, a campaigning anti-government newspaper during the worst excesses of the apartheid era. She commutes between South Africa and the UK.

Marika Sboros is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Follow Marika Sboros on:  @MarikaSboros
Subscribe on Substack: Marika Sboros 





Feature photo:  Courtroom 600 at Nuremberg’s Palace of Justice, where Nazi war-crimes trials were held. The backdrop to the Nobel Peace Prize 2026 award. (Photo: JensKunstfreund, via Wikimedia Commons. Illustration: Niklas Elmehed. Composite by Marika Sboros.)






THE CHILDREN HAD NAMES

Israel’s failure in the information war

By Andrew Fox

On 26th February 2025, tens of thousands of Israelis lined the roads for the funeral procession of Shiri Bibas and her sons, Ariel and Kfir. Orange balloons, the colour of the boys’ hair, marked the route. Men dressed as Batman, Ariel’s favourite superhero, saluted as the coffins passed. Ariel had been four when he was abducted; Kfir was nine months old. Through family photographs and a desperate campaign to bring them home, strangers worldwide came to know these two little boys, who were brutally killed by Hamas in Gaza.

The Color Orange. The world could relate to the tragic unfolding horror of the Bibas family – the brutally kidnapped mother and her two kids – easily recognizable by their ginger hair.

Israel’s government should have understood why their story reached people who would never read an IDF briefing. The families had kept their children recognisable through months of arguing about a war in which they had no say. Doing so deserved sustained government support from the start. Leaving so much of it to people already enduring the unimaginable was a failure of both compassion and, if we are being brutally cold about it, strategy.

Psychologists call the tendency to respond more readily to a named person than to anonymous suffering the ‘identifiable victim effect’. In a 2007 study, Deborah Small, George Loewenstein and Paul Slovic compared an appeal about deprivation across Africa with one about Rokia, a seven-year-old girl in Mali. Among participants who received no prior explanation of the effect, those reading about Rokia donated an average of $2.83, compared with $1.17 from those given the statistics.

That said, for balance, later research has been less conclusive: a 2016 meta-analysis found a small average effect, and a subsequent replication using hypothetical donations failed to reproduce it. We cannot turn a charitable-giving experiment into a measure of how many people changed their minds about Gaza. It does, however, give us a useful starting point for understanding why an individual’s suffering can command attention that casualty figures struggle to hold.

There is much less uncertainty about Yahya Sinwar’s calculation. In June 2024, the Wall Street Journal reported on messages in which he treated Palestinian civilian deaths as an advantage in the war. Citing the losses suffered in other conflicts, he called them “necessary sacrifices”. More deaths meant more pressure on Israel. Sinwar believed he could outlast the Israeli offensive whilst the people of Gaza paid for it. The suffering itself needed no invention. In November 2023, footage of Khaled Nabhan kissing his dead granddaughter, Reem, travelled around the world. She was three. In CNN’s account, he remembered the game in which she pulled his beard, and he pulled her pigtails; he spoke about the fruit the children had wanted and the tangerines he had managed to find. Anyone with a child or grandchild could recognise the affection in those small exchanges, and something of the agony of losing them. This is the key to the information war: making the suffering of innocents feel personal to those observing the physical war from abroad.

The Young and the Dead. These are just some of the faces of the children violently impacted by Hamas’s attacks against Israel on October 7th. 2023.

The opportunity for Hamas arose when that grief provided the sole explanation for the war. The viewer saw a dead child and the consequences of an Israeli strike, with all context stripped away. The men who had launched the massacre on 7th October and who continued to hold hostages could disappear from the account. Whenever sympathy for Palestinians became pressure on Israel to stop fighting, without equivalent pressure on Hamas to release their captives and surrender power, their strategy benefited. Foreign audiences did not have to like Hamas for this to work.

They used Israeli suffering with the same ruthlessness. On 16th October 2023, Hamas released footage of Mia Schem, wounded and captive. Her mother, Keren, recognised her daughter’s fear and believed she could see Mia repeating what her captors had told her to say. Hamas had abducted her; now they controlled what her family could see of her. A Palestinian family’s bereavement could be used to generate pressure against the offensive, whilst an Israeli family’s desperation could be used to press for a deal on Hamas’s terms. Their control over the hostages gave them a way to prolong that desperation.

The bitter irony is that Israel had their own human stories from the first morning, and yet was unwilling, and many will argue, rightly so, to use those stories as an information war opportunity. Shani Louk was a 22-year-old German-Israeli tattoo artist who went to Nova to dance. Much of the world first encountered her through the footage of her body in a pickup truck, subjected to the humiliation her killers chose for her. Her family’s memorial website shows her drawings and offers her tattoo designs for others to use. There is work there which she made before anyone knew her name, and which people can still choose to carry on their skin. Her family have given strangers a way to know her beyond the manner of her death.

Killing Kids. The child’s stroller and personal belongings seen here seen on the road next to a car near Kibbutz Kfar Aza reveals the horrendous horror of an orgy of butchering young families while traveling on a country road. (Photo: Ronen Zvulun/Reuters)

The families of the observers at Nahal Oz have done something similar. Roni Eshel was 19 and loved Taylor Swift. Her parents planted fruit trees in her memorial park because she loved them. Her father, Eyal, has also spoken about the warnings she gave before the attack and the army’s failure to listen. Remembering Roni properly means making room for all of this. Her youth and enthusiasms belong alongside the responsibility she carried at the border, and her father’s anger at the people who were supposed to protect her.

These efforts by ordinary Israelis and their friends worldwide began early. The “Kidnapped” posters created by Nitzan Mintz, Dede Bandaid and Tal Huber put names and photographs on streets around the world within weeks of the massacre. Israeli officials spoke about the hostages too, including Kfir Bibas. The Israeli government failed to turn those scattered efforts into a coherent campaign, with the resources and continuity a prolonged information war required.

“No one will dare to tear down a poster of a dog, but of Jews? No problem”. Street artists Dede Bandaid and Nitzan Mintz (above), who together with Tal Huber started the viral hostage poster campaign, expressed shock at videos showing individuals tearing down the posters, viewing it as a blatant expression of antisemitism. (Photo: BFA)

In October 2025, former IDF spokesman Nachman Shai wrote that Israel still lacked a unified public advocacy structure that brought government and civil society together. He was right. Two years into the war, this was an extraordinary indictment of the government’s priorities. I would go further than Shai’s criticism of the machinery. Explaining why the IDF had struck a tunnel was necessary, but the explanation also needed to reach people who had no understanding of what it meant to live within reach of Hamas or the way in which they weaponised the suffering of their own people. The victims’ families could make that danger comprehensible in ways a military briefing could not.

The Nova exhibition shows what was possible. It opened in Tel Aviv in December 2023 and reached London in May 2026, bringing belongings recovered from the festival together with testimony from survivors and bereaved relatives. A friend of mine went multiple times with a variety of people from different backgrounds, and they all came away with a different perspective on 7 October and the subsequent war in Gaza. The organisers had been doing this work for years. Their achievement makes the Israeli government’s failure harder to excuse: people outside the state had already demonstrated how to give foreign audiences a sustained encounter with the lives destroyed on 7th October. Israel should have helped such work reach far beyond those already inclined to listen.

The audience is more hostile now. Pew’s June 2026 findings showed that 69% of British adults viewed Israel unfavourably, up from 61% a year earlier. Let us be real: anger at Israeli policy and the destruction in Gaza cannot simply be attributed to manipulation, and no poll tells us what a better Israeli campaign would have achieved. It does show how difficult it is to secure a hearing for Israel today.

Israel ceded the initiative while much of the world was forming its understanding of the war. Testimony can still change minds, but a family speaking now may first have to persuade an audience that their loss deserves a hearing at all. The opportunity to shape those first impressions has gone. Recovering ground will take more than belatedly discovering that the dead had names. The government should pay for translation and help willing families take their testimony abroad, without making support conditional on what they say. If ministers want the world to hear Roni Eshel’s story, they must accept that her father will also tell the world who ignored her warnings. They cannot ask for the authority of his grief and then edit out his accusation.

Butchering Babies. What Israelis fail to recover from and what most the world hardly saw and remain uninterested or are subsequently interested in seeing are images such as this of toys and personal items lying on a bloodstained floor of a Jewish child’s bedroom in kibbutz Beeri following the massacring by Hamas gunman. (Photo: Ronen Zvulu/Reuters)

No bereaved family should have to owe the state a PR campaign. Those willing to speak deserve its support, with the freedom to say things ministers would rather the world did not hear. Israel’s government should have understood this when families were putting up posters and pleading for help. By the time people lined the roads with orange balloons, those families had spent months asking the world to care. They should never have had to shoulder so much of that work themselves.



About the writer:

A veteran of three grueling tours of Afghanistan, Major Andrew Fox holds a Batchelor’s degree in Law & Politics, a Master’s in Military History & War Studies, Msc in Psychology and is currently studying for a PhD in History.







ON THE WAY TO GAZA

Repeated visits reveal fresh insights, revelations and questions.

By Jonathan Feldstein

On the way to the Gaza border, my friend asked how many times I had been there since the October 7, 2023 Hamas attack and massacre.

I had to think about it.

I remember the first trip vividly. Several other trips were outstanding whether visiting soldiers and bringing supplies or preparing and providing food, one on one like the time with my friend Marziyeh (Marzi) Amirizadeh and seeing the devastation through the eyes of a woman who suffered the evil hatred of radical Islam growing up and living in Iran and identifying the evil we faced with the evil that she lived under for most of her life, or planning for and implementing our incredible Root & Branch program bringing Christian volunteers to harvest olives in Israel and along the Gaza border.

There were other trips with friends and donors, as well as relatives, media and more. In the car, I estimated that I had visited the Gaza border at least 30 times. In retrospect it’s probably more. Surely averaging once a month. Considering my travels, that’s a lot.

Some trips blur together. Some are memorable for different reasons. All are emotionally draining. Yesterday was no different. It had been a while since the last time.

Horrific Legacy. High school students from across Israel were visiting the sights where the massacre and killings took place three years earlier. (Photo: Jonathan Feldstein)

Along the roads from Routes 34, 232, 25 and more, I noticed the increased number of memorials along the side of the road. From once piles of stones with flags and photographs these have been “developed” to permanent and thoughtful memorials. In America and other countries, you see similar respectful homage where people have died in car accidents. The roads here have been repaved and show no signs of what happened that day anymore. But I remember the countless points where one would drive and see large dark spots on the road with a slight bump as you drove over them, burn marks from the high temperature flames where cars were set on fire. Torched with people inside.

Graveyard of Vehicles. A young school student engages at the Car Wall memorial near moshav Tkuma in Israel’s Gaza Envelope where over 1,500 burned, twisted, and bullet-riddled vehicles are stacked into the shape of a wall.  With each damaged ‘shell’ representing lives lost, the memorial functions as an educational and remembrance site for visitors, families, and delegations. (Photo: Jonathan Feldstein)

The roads no longer have the scars but the memorials along the side of the roads show the points where hundreds of people were shot and burned to death, their bodies and their cars littering the roads.

I looked at the piles of the shot up and burnt remains of the vehicles from that day. More than 1000 cars, many of which became death traps for their passengers. As we visited the site that also has been built up as a permanent memorial, first I noticed dozens of tour buses. Most were for Israelis for whom the site has become a pilgrimage. People wanting to see, understand, bear witness to the horrors of that day.

Murderers on Motorbikes. A piled heap of burnt motorcycles used by Hamas terrorists during the assault is displayed alongside the victims’ vehicles as physical testimony of the attack. (Photo: Jonathan Feldstein)

There are few tourists in Israel now so most of the guides and survivors telling stories of what happened that day were speaking Hebrew. What broke my heart, other than the memorial itself, was the prevalence of young people. It’s terrible that we must educate our children about this all and it’s part of the legacy we leave them. It’s not new but it is still sad. Many high school students. Some of whom got to practice their English in a spontaneous conversation with Marzi about her life and imprisonment in Iran. She connected the dots of the Islamic Republic and Hamas as the same evil. That we have the same enemy. That the Iranian people are not the regime that hijacked Iran 47 years ago and that the people support Israel.

Three years ago, they were early adolescence and three years from now they will all be serving in the army defending their country. I wondered if in 7 or 10 or 15 years, my own grandson’s will be part of this pilgrimage.

I saw a group of soldiers. Three years earlier they were the age of the high school students we encountered. They stood there with weapons over their shoulders, against the backdrop of piles of dozens of burnt remains of just some of the cars. Their weapons are used to defend us against the evil that perpetrated the crimes that we witnessed with the cars just as one reminder, listening to things they surely remember from three years ago when they were just students and Israel was at its most vulnerable.

Burden of Defense. Responsible for protecting Israel today, young IDF male and female soldiers at the Car Wall memorial, who were school students when the massacre occurred in October, 2023. (Photo: Jonathan Feldstein)

At the site of the Nova Music Festival where some 25% of the 1200 people killed that day were slaughtered, the memorials have become uniform and standardized, albeit with personal touches from the loved ones of those who were killed and mutilated there that day. I always describe it as a cross between Woodstock and Auschwitz. We spent nearly an hour there, but what’s really needed to understand the enormity and the scope of the loss is much more, even if you’ve been there multiple times before as I have.

Dance to Death. The site of the dance floor at the Nova Music Festival massacre where, Hamas terrorists raped, mutilated, beheaded, burnt, slaughtered and shot 364 of the attendees, party staff, police security, and medical service personnel. (Photo: Jonathan Feldstein)

In Sderot, we visited the powerful memorial at the site of the former police station in which all the police on duty that morning were killed and many others on the street. As hard as it is to think, amid the slaughter there was incredible heroism and it was a miracle that more people were not killed there that day. Of course, that’s no comfort for the survivors whose loved ones are no longer with us.

Poignant Pillars. ‘Pillars of Eternity’, the memorial built on the ruins of the original Sderot police station destroyed by heavily armed killer Hamas squads. The memorial features 18 tall, eleven-to-twelve-meter columns representing the fallen police officers and defenders, integrated with Hebrew letters symbolizing hope and energy. (Photo: Jonathan Feldstein)

I told the story of the Suisa family, the young parents, Odaya and Dolev, who were trying to flee Sderot in their car and were caught in an ambush and murdered in front of their two young daughters, leaving them orphans. It must be noted that the person who sacrificed his life trying to save the family was a Bedouin Arab, Amer Odeh Abu Sabila. A construction worker who was in Sderot early that fateful Saturday morning, Amer heard Odaya screaming after Dolev had been killed and got into the driver’s seat to try and bring Odaya and her two young daughters to safety at the Sderot police station. Not knowing that the police station had already been overrun by the terrorists, both Abu Sabila and Odaya were murdered, while the two kids, Romi, 6, and Lia, 3, lay on the floor of the car unscathed. There is harrowing video footage from that day that shows the two young girls screaming for help as police officers arrived.

Brutally Murdered. Odaya (33) and Dolev Swissa (34) who were murdered in front of their two daughters. The family tried to leave Sderot as sirens sounded but were attacked by Hamas terrorists and killed in their car.

Amer Odeh Abu Sabila’s story is not unique as many Israeli Arabs were killed that day, including a police officer inside the police station, but is important to recount as it reveals the reality of life in Israel of Arabs who tragically died alongside their fellow Jewish citizens.

Sacrificed his Life. Bedouin construction worker, Amer Abu Sabila (25), lost his life as he bravely attempted to rescue Dolev and Odaya Swisa’s two daughters near the police station in Sderot.

As the sun was setting, we made our way to one of the lookout points from which Gaza is visible. Despite international claims to the contrary, even with the naked eye one can see entire cities still standing. And even three years and a week after the inhuman Hamas attack and massacre, there was a jarring audible punctuation of the reality as we heard gunfire in the distance coming from inside Gaza, indicating that if these killers are not fought and pushed back, they will rise and try to attack us again and again.

The numbers alone do not sufficiently represent the enormity of the day. Each of the 1200 people, including Jewish and Arab Moslem and Druze Israelis, as well as many foreigners including Christians, is the loss of an entire universe for them and their loved ones. But there’s a national story as well, timeless in the sense that it’s an unfortunate part of the reality of Jewish history and the foreseeable future.

“The Day the Music Died”. Photo memorials of each of the murdered party-goers at the Nova Music Festival. (Photo: Jonathan Feldstein)

However many times I have gone to visit these sites, each time thinking that there’s nothing particularly new in doing so other than bringing people who have not yet witnessed it, I am sadly shocked at how there’s still so much to absorb and process and how such experiences are necessary.



About the writer:

Jonathan Feldstein was born and educated in the U.S. and immigrated to Israel in 2004. He is married and the father of six. Throughout his life and career, he has become a respected bridge between Jews and Christians and serves as president of the Genesis 123 Foundation. He writes regularly on major Christian websites about Israel and shares experiences of living as an Orthodox Jew in Israel. He is host of the popular Inspiration from Zion podcast. He can be reached at firstpersonisrael@gmail.com.







NAVI PILLAY AND THE HEDGEHOG TRAP

Why the Nobel Peace Prize sacrificed genuine peacebuilding for ideological reductionism and anti-Israel bias.

By Yoram Blumstein

By rewarding a rabid anti-Israel activist-jurist and chief peddler of baseless “genocide” and “apartheid” claims against the Jewish state with the prestigious Peace Prize, the Oslo Committee did not recognise peace – but weaponised lawfare and institutional bias against the Jewish people and Israel. The Nobel Committee, which lacks a moral compass, forms part of a coterie of ignoble institutions that espouse systematic animus towards the Jewish state and provide a fertile ecosystem for the normalisation of antisemitism.  Israel and the United States (U.S.) rightfully rejected the decision to award the coveted Peace Prize to Navi Pillay, a South African ad hoc judge at the compromised International Court of Justice (ICJ) and former jurist on the International Criminal Court (ICC), as it is an affront to the Jewish people and rewards Hamas and Israel’s enemies. Conversely, the feckless South African President Cyril Ramaphosa, France, Iran, United Nations (UN) Secretary-General Antonio Guterres, and Hamas praised the award as a victory for international justice.

Hands-on Hatred. Navi Pillay addressing the Nuremberg Forum in Nuremberg on 9 October 2026 following the announcement that she will be awarded the 2026 Nobel Peace Prize has kept her hands on the ball on promoting anti-Israel bias. (Photo: Daniel Karmann/ Getty Images)

Fundamentally, the Oslo Committee (which bears sole responsibility for awarding the Peace Prize) betrayed Alfred Nobel’s (a genius, polyglot, and inventor of dynamite) stated conditions (as enshrined in his last will), which required the recipient to meet specific criteria for advancing international diplomacy, peace, and dialogue. Pillaydid not meet Alfred Nobel’s essential requirements to be elevated to the pantheon of great peacemakers such as Nelson Mandela, Desmond Tutu, F.W. De Klerk, Henry Kissinger, Shimon Peres, Yitzhak Rabin, Menachem Begin, Anwar Sadat and Elie Wiesel, amongst others, and is an affront to the Jewish people.

ANALYTICAL FRAMEWORK

In his 1953 essay, “The Hedgehog and the Fox”, the British Jewish philosopher Sir Isaiah Berlin asserted that:

 “…the fox knows many things, while the hedgehog knows one big thing.”

Berlin borrowed the line from the ancient Greek poet, Archilochus. Berlin’s dichotomy can serve as a heuristic tool to expose confirmation bias and as a stark warning against singular, dogmatic thinking.  Metaphorically, hedgehogs are monists who reduce reality to a single, central vision or organising principle. By contrast, foxes are pluralists who relentlessly pursue different avenues, nuances, variety, and complexity without forcing everything into a rigid, singular vision. Berlin used the distinction to analyse Leo Tolstoy’s inherent personal contradictions, whom the British philosopher diagnosed as a “fox by nature”, but a “hedgehog by conviction”. Tolstoy, a cerebral writer, foresaw the infinite complexity of life, but he desperately tried to force it into a “grand singular theory of life.” In Berlin’s philosophical dichotomy, a hedgehog-like approach is not inherently bad, but political scientists like Philip E. Tetlock have repurposed the “fox-and-hedgehog” framework to warn analysts and policymakers against overconfidence, single-cause grand perspectives, and confirmation bias in expert forecasting.

THE NOBEL PEACE COMMITT’S HEDGEHOG TRAP

The Nobel Peace Committee’s diabolical decision fits the hedgehog diagnosis. The decision is inextricably linked to the current torrent of violent antisemitism and anti-Israel bias. It carefully reduced the criteria for the prize to a singular grand vision (as a purported fact), while filtering out complex realities about:

– the Israel-Palestine conflict

– the normalisation of antisemitism, and

– the role of terror networks such as Hamas and Lebanese Hezbollah.

Politicizing a Prize. Would Alfred Nobel view the 2026 Nobel Peace prize to South African jurist Navi Pillay as a faithful fulfillment of his will or a weaponization of the award to legitimize anti-Israel hatred and prejudice?

Before the prize announcement, Pillay prodigiously used the label “genocide” and “apartheid state” to describe Israel’s treatment of Palestinians. She supports the Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions (BDS) movement and endorsed the UN Durban Anti-Racism Process, which set the tone for a notable uptick in modern antisemitism and institutional bias. In addition, she failed the neutrality test as an international jurist when she signed a joint letter accusing Israel of “domination and oppression” before heading the UN Commission of Inquiry into the Occupied Palestinian Territories. In September 2025, the UN Independent Commission of Inquiry, chaired by Pillay, released a report concluding that Israel had committed “genocide” in Gaza. However, the ICJ has yet to rule on South Africa’s baseless accusations. The report took statements from individual Israeli senior officials out of context and recommended criminal prosecution for senior Israeli officials at the ICC. Pillay and the bodies she represents are structurally biased against Israel and the Jewish people. Even when the Oslo Committee notified her of the award, she continued to accuse Israel of “genocide”:

“The last thing I did was the report on Gaza naming what’s happening in there as genocide…Why would you need courage to speak the truth? You interpret the law. You look at all the facts, so it’s an impartial decision.”

Check your facts at the door, Pillay:

Your reporting shows no impartiality; your statements and opinions are steeped in tendentiousness. You are an ingloriously useful idiot!

Pillay was visibly surprised when she was announced as the 2026 recipient, as other deserving nominees, such as U.S. President Donald Trump, played a pivotal role in negotiating a ceasefire in Gaza, spearheaded peace talks between Israel and Lebanon, and agitated for a modus vivendi between Israel and Syria. Geopolitical optics do matter. Francesca Albanese, UN Special Rapporteur on the Occupied Palestinian Territories, continues to use her office to frame Israel’s actions in Gaza and Judea and Samaria (the West Bank) as “genocidal” while failing to acknowledge Israel’s defensive policies against a genocidal terrorist entity.  The September 2026 United Nations General Assembly debates focused almost exclusively on Israel. The United Kingdom’s recent import ban on “settlement” goods, sanctions frameworks, and arms export restrictions align with European and Western nations (such as Ireland, Spain, the Netherlands, and France) in restricting trade with Israel following meritless advisory opinions from international legal institutions like the ICJ. In a different, yet crucial context, on October 4th, the Green Party of England and Wales adopted a preposterous policy at its annual conference, formally equating Zionism with racism. While the Green Party is a fringe party with a few parliamentary seats, the decision carries significant political and diplomatic weight. It will further galvanise the normalisation of antisemitism in Europe and beyond. On October 17th, during a local elections campaign rally in Rylands (Cape Town), a predominantly Muslim and Hamas-loving suburb, Ramaphosa emphasised South Africa’s ongoing genocide case against Israel and the African National Congress’ (ANC) steadfast support for the Palestinian cause. It is perplexing why a head of state would use a misguided foreign policy issue to attract Muslim voters when the focus should be on fixing service delivery failures in ANC-led municipalities.

Based on the above, the Nobel Committee fits the hedgehog framework with a singular, misguided vision. By betraying Alfred Nobel’s explicit wishes, the Oslo Committee has succumbed to the prevailing cosmos (which is dominated by narratives munificently bandied about by the “New Antisemites” – a violent neophyte species of state and non-state actors) that demonises and delegitimises the State of Israel. Hence, the said Committee has failed to uphold impartiality in awarding the peace prize to an individual whose career has been fixated on spreading disinformation about Israel. Regrettably, the Oslo Committee is afflicted with a growing pathology of institutional bias, as highlighted by incessant anti-Israel resolutions and declarations by the UN and its allied institutions.

Institutionalizing Antisemitism. Far from promoting peace and international law, the Committee’s selection of Navi Pillay exposes the double standards and deep-rooted hostility toward the Jewish state within international institutions.

A FOXLIKE COUNTERARGUMENT

Lamentably, the Nobel Committee exposed its bias in awarding the prestigious prize to Pillay by failing to consider:

– the prevailing facts on the ground

– alternative or contrarian perspectives

– Israel’s right to self-defense, and

– Pillay’s track record of vehement anti-Israel rhetoric.

These factors are inconsistent with the qualities of a peacemaker, which Pillay lacks. The facts speak for themselves. A fox would have determined that Israel did not commit genocide or war crimes, cause mass starvation in Gaza, or deliberately kill babies and civilians. In fact, Israel took reasonable measures, which are well-documented, to comply with laws of armed conflict and international humanitarian conventions.

The real danger lies in ideological monism, when international institutions (like the Oslo Nobel Committee) gravitate toward “hedgehog thinking” and compromise their role as neutral arbiters. By awarding the Peace Prize to Pillay, the Nobel Committee acted as the sole, supreme arbiter of peace, and the decision was biased, predetermined and influenced by the anti-Israel zeitgeist and extremist voices. The Nobel Committee’s decision is consequently alarming, as it facilitates the normalisation of antisemitism, which is disturbing to Jews as violent antisemitism sweeps across Western capitals.

Pillay is not a peacemaker and unworthy of the Nobel Peace Prize. She should have declined the award as she had not done enough to comply with Alfred Nobel’s wishes. The key state instigator of unfounded genocide allegations against Israel, South Africa, was the first to congratulate Pillay on her undeserved prize. Yet, the ANC’s reckless decision to take Israel to the ICJ provided the building blocks for antisemitism to thrive. Ambassador Rabbi Yehuda Kaploun, the U.S. Special Envoy to Monitor and Combat Antisemitism, remarked in early October that South Africa’s ICJ genocide case against Israel led to an exponential increase in antisemitism and anti-Israel hostility.

Under the Shadow of Nobel. Ambassador Rabbi Yehuda Kaploun, the US Special Envoy to Monitor and Combat Antisemitism asserts that South Africa’s decision to make its ICJ case against Israel a centerpiece of its foreign policy is contributing to global antisemitism.



About the writer:
Editor’s Note: Yoram Blumstein is a nom de plume the author uses to protect their identity because of previous security threats.





THE NOBEL PEACE PRIZE OFFENSIVE

Hardly in pursuance of “peace” when an Islamist death cult applauds the announcement of the 2026 South African winner.

By Craig Snoyman

On 9 October 2026, the Norwegian Nobel Committee (“the committee”) awarded the Nobel Peace Prize to Navanethem (Navi) Pillay for:

– her efforts to promote peace and international law”,

and announced that:

– “Peace requires justice”.

Humanitarian or Political? The decision to award the 2026 Nobel Peace Prize to former U.N. human rights chief Navi Pillay sparked fierce backlash from U.N. watchdogs for her longstanding anti-Israel bias and defending antisemitic rhetoric. (Photo: Fabrice Coffrini/AFP via Getty Image)

In Nuremberg, ironically, Pillay told a crowd celebrating her award: “The last thing I did is the delivery of the report on Gaza, naming what’s happening there as genocide.” In Oslo the committee said that it was “not taking a stance” on genocide, as “it’s her report”. Perhaps the committee should have made its announcement on 7 October, the day of the worst genocide of Jews since the Second World War, rather than two days later.

On 9 October 2009, seventeen years earlier to the day, the committee awarded the Nobel Peace Prize to President Barack Obama “for his extraordinary efforts to strengthen international diplomacy and cooperation between peoples”. Obama’s response, as his memoir records, was a question: “For what?” In 2015 the committee’s secretary disclosed that the committee chose Obama because it believed the prize would help him achieve his goals.

The will of Alfred Nobel’s will is quite clear what the requirements for the Peace Prize are. It is for those who, “during the preceding year”, have “conferred the greatest benefit to mankind”. It is for the person who has done “the most or the best work for fraternity between nations, for the abolition or reduction of standing armies and for the holding and promotion of peace congresses”.

The records of the favoured candidates were clear. Vanessa Nakate campaigned for the vulnerable communities affected by climate change. The volunteers of Sudan’s Emergency Response Rooms were bringing food, medical help and evacuation to civilians in Sudan’s civil war. Yulia Navalnaya became the political voice of her husband, Alexei Navalny, who died in a Russian Arctic prison colony.

Pillay’s record was not as impressive. Having signed South African  BDS petition to “Sanction Apartheid Israel” she had no qualms in chairing the singularly inappropriately named “Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, and Israel”  She proceeded to conduct an investigation in which Israel refused the commission entry and the commission acquired its information from second-hand sources.

Ten weeks after she tendered her resignation, the commission published its results and conclusions, finding that the State of Israel was responsible for committing genocide, for failing to prevent it and for failing to punish it. In September 2024, it had recorded that  Hamas was  guilty of war crimes and crimes against humanity. In its 2025 report to the General Assembly it absolved Hamas, mentioning it once, in a quotation from an Israeli minister. It declared that Israel had the intent to destroy the Palestinians of Gaza, as this was “the only reasonable inference”. It traced that intent back to “decades of unlawful occupation and unlawful settlement, with racial segregation or apartheid”. When asked whether the states that still supplied arms to Israel were complicit in genocide, Pillay answered: “Yes.”

Jaundiced Judgment. And how did judge Navi Pilay (center) react when fellow UN Human Rights Council’s Commission of Inquiry into the Israeli-Palestinian conflict member, Miloon Kothari  (right) expressed that social media was “controlled largely by the Jewish lobby,” she defended him saying he had been “deliberately decontextualized.” (Photo: Luke Tress/Times of Israel)

Her record as a judge at the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda (“the tribunal”) is equally chequered. When the defence in the Media case applied for Pillay’s recusal, because she had already expressly pronounced on the guilt of the radio station RTLM in an earlier case, the chamber in which she sat dismissed the application. When a press report accused three judges of the tribunal of laughing while defence counsel cross-examined a rape survivor about how her attackers had undressed her, Pillay, as president of the tribunal, called the report “a mischaracterisation of the scene”, and in the same statement declared that it would not be appropriate for her to discuss the conduct of other judges in an ongoing trial. The survivors’ organisations Ibuka and Avega suspended their cooperation with the tribunal.

Her attitude has remained constant. When her fellow commissioner, Miloon Kothari, told an interviewer that the “Jewish lobby” largely controlled social media, Pillay stated that he had been “deliberately misquoted”, without saying how. Kothari subsequently apologised and wrote that it had been “completely wrong” for him to describe social media in that way. Pillay was not as forthcoming.

In the Rwanda tribunal, the Appeals Chamber annulled and replaced various decisions over which Pillay presided, because of her misdirection concerning conduct outside the tribunal’s temporal jurisdiction. In the Palestine commission matter it was easier. Her commission was to investigate violations “leading up to and since 13 April 2021” and was not limited by time issues. During the investigation, Pillay stated: “The occupation is as non-ending as our mandate.” This followed earlier prejudicial remarks, when Pillay told the General Assembly that “Israel’s occupation is now unlawful”. The evidence of her bias, and her (lack of) regard for natural justice, did not prevent her from sitting on either the tribunal or the commission.

The Appeals Chamber in the Rwanda tribunal reversed Pillay’s Media case decision on the basis that a reasonable trier of fact could not find conspiracy to commit genocide to be “the only reasonable inference” from the evidence. Pillay, not a great historian, repeated her conclusion when deciding on Israel’s conduct, with a greater paucity of evidence. But then, a report to the UN General Assembly has no Appeals Chamber above it that can set aside such a legal conclusion.

In September 2022, when the United Nations Association of Germany proposed to present her with its Otto Hahn Peace Medal, Ron Prosor, Israel’s ambassador in Berlin said:

“To have Navi Pillay investigate Israel is like asking Putin to chair a commission of inquiry into Ukraine.”

Proser on Pilay. “To have Navi Pillay investigate Israel is like asking Putin to chair a commission of inquiry into Ukraine,” said Ron Prosor, Israel’s Ambassador to Germany Ron Prosor. as Ambassador to the UN (courtesy)

The ceremony did not take place. In November 2025, when Sydney gave her its peace prize, the Premier of New South Wales declined to attend, and the Executive Council of Australian Jewry had said that the prize went to recipients “for having the ‘correct’ opinions, rather than for making a real contribution to peace.”

The Nobel committee wanted Obama to achieve in 2009, and it paid him in advance. In 2026 it wants Pillay’s report to achieve the definition of Gaza as genocide before any court has ruled, and it has paid her in advance as well. She is well positioned to pay it back, as she sits as an ad hoc judge in the Gambia v Myanmar genocide case and will no doubt work hard to change the definition of genocide.

The function of the Nobel Peace Prize committee was to ask what Pillay did in the preceding year for fraternity between nations, and what she did for fewer standing armies and for peace congresses. She ticks none of those boxes. She incites friction and animosity. She accused one nation of genocide and called the nations that arm it complicit. Nobody punished the committee for the Obama Peace Prize, and now the committee has taken another step further. It is no longer an award for anticipated fraternity; it is now an advance to persuade political opinion. Again, the committee goes unpunished. But this time the sin is more egregious. A political finding on genocide lets the committee ignore its own principles, and lets its members’ antipathy toward Israel translate the big lie of Israeli genocide into a Nobel medal.

Pilay’s Prize. By awarding to a recipient with an agenda of endangering Jews worldwide, has the Nobel Peace Prize -one of the five original Nobel Prizes established by the will of Alfred Nobel – been irreparably tarnished?

So, to you Ms Nakate, to you, the volunteers of Sudan’s Emergency Response Rooms, and to you Ms Navalnaya: speaking for the vulnerable, feeding civilians under fire or defying the Kremlin will not win you this prize. Better luck next year. President Obama asked “For what?”

The committee has now answered: the correct opinion, not peace.



About the writer:

Craig Snoyman is a practicing Advocate in Johannesburg.





While the mission of Lay of the Land (LotL) is to provide a wide and diverse perspective of affairs in Israel, the Middle East and the Jewish world, the opinions, beliefs and viewpoints expressed by its various writers are not necessarily ones of the owners and management of LOTL but of the writers themselves.  LotL endeavours to the best of its ability to credit the use of all known photographs to the photographer and/or owner of such photographs (0&EO).

REMEMBERING RAB

Jewish survivors of the Rab concentration camp form battalion to fight the Nazi German forces occupying Yugoslavia.

By Michel Levine

At the beginning of the WWII, without firing a single shot, the Jewish inmates of a detention camp located in Yugoslavia revolted and took control of the site. They then formed themselves into a battalion and took part in the partisan struggle for the liberation of the country. This curious and probably unique episode deserves to be better known.

In April 1941, the Axis forces seized the Kingdom of Yugoslavia.

In their occupation zone, German troops carried out mass killings and deportations to extermination camps. In the zone controlled by their Bulgarian allies, Jews were handed over to the Germans and likewise sent to Auschwitz. In the Hungarian occupation zone, after the Novi Sad pogrom, which claimed 4,000 victims, the surviving Jews experienced a certain respite until the German occupation of Hungary in the spring of 1944, which in turn led to their deportation to the gas chambers. At the same time, the Germans created in Croatia a puppet state, the Independent State of Croatia (Nezavisna Država Hrvatska, NDH), led by the fascist Ante Pavelić, whose program was expressed in three fundamental points: kill one third of the Serbs living on its territory, expel another third, and assimilate the surviving third. To achieve this, concentration camps were opened in which thousands of Serbians, Jewish, Roma, and Croatian prisoners — opponents of the regime or merely suspects — perished. Its troops, the Ustaše, fought both the Communist partisans and the Serbian royalist Chetniks while carrying out numerous pogroms along the way. It is estimated that between 1941 and 1945, out of a Jewish population of 80,000 persons, more than 67,000 were murdered, one of the highest destruction rates in Europe.

Things unfolded differently in the occupation zones held by the Italian army (Albania, Kosovo, Montenegro, southern Slovenia, and the Dalmatian coast), as well as in the territories directly annexed by Rome (Slovenia and Croatia).

Although living conditions for the populations subjected to this armed occupation were made extremely difficult by hunger and mistreatment, Italian occupation officers, supported in this by senior officials of their foreign ministry, refused to commit the mass crimes carried out by their German, Bulgarian, or Ustaše allies. The Italian army even went so far as to establish “protective camps” for Jews in order to shield them from Nazi fury, at Crikvenica, Kraljevica, Selce, Novi Vinodol, and on the islands of Lopud, Brač, Hvar, and Korčula, among others.

Seen here in July 1942, are prisoners under the control of an Italian official at the Rab concentration camp, one of several Italian concentration camps established during WWII on the Italian-annexed island of Rab.

Thus, in July 1942, 2,500 Jews captured during operations conducted by the Italian army against the Yugoslav partisans were transferred to the island of Rab (Arbe in Italian), located along the Dalmatian coast. There they discovered a vast complex of barracks and tents situated near the village of Kampor. The Arbe civilian internment camp (Campo di concentramento per internati civili di Guerra – Arbe) already held between 10,000 and 15,000 detainees, mainly Slovenes, Croats, and Jews. Although conditions there were dreadful for all inmates, with cold, famine, dysentery, scurvy, beriberi, and scabies rampant in these makeshift lodgings, Jewish prisoners enjoyed certain concessions, such as exemption from forced labor and a certain freedom of movement. A former Slovenian detainee, Anton Vratuša — who after the war would become Yugoslavia’s ambassador to the United Nations — summarized the situation as follows:

“We were all prisoners, but they were protected.”

He added: “We used their help.” What did he mean by this?

Among the Jewish prisoners, there was far from complete trust with respect to the Italian military authorities. Certainly, they had disobeyed orders by shielding them from the Nazis, but this trial of strength could at any moment turn disastrous: several examples were already known of camps where Italian soldiers had been forced by their German allies to hand over their Jewish prisoners.

It therefore became urgent to leave the island as quickly as possible.

A small group among them, including Viktor Hajon, a member of the Yugoslav Communist Party (and a famous polo player before the war), who had just failed in an escape attempt, established contact with a clandestine committee formed before their arrival. This committee included members of the People’s Liberation Movement founded by Josip Broz — soon to become known under his nickname Tito. Its armed branch, the People’s Liberation Army of Yugoslavia (Narodnooslobodilačka vojska, or N.O.V.), fought the occupiers. Unlike General Mihailović’s royalist Chetniks, Tito, a seasoned Communist apparatchik accustomed to clandestine work since 1934, had built a structured, hierarchical army highly suited to guerrilla warfare, whose headquarters constantly moved through the mountains of Bosnia and Montenegro. Its strength also lay in uniting within its ranks, on equal terms, Jews, Muslims, Orthodox Christians, and Roman Catholics, in a country where wars of religion were compounded by ethnic conflicts. At its height, his army numbered 800,000 fighters.

Failing in his attempted escapes, famed Jewish Yugoslav water polo player before WWII, Viktor Hajon made contact outside the camp with the People’s Liberation Movement founded by Tito.

Representatives of the Jewish group proposed supplying intelligence to the clandestine committee, taking advantage of their relative freedom of movement within the camp. Their information concerned guard schedules, contacts with the Italian headquarters on the mainland coast, and so forth. The clandestine committee decided to make use of this cooperation. The ultimate goal was to organize an uprising in the camp, but a serious problem confronted everyone: the lack of weapons. While waiting to acquire some, the two groups organized special courses given by doctors and nurses on emergency medical care for the wounded. These would prove extremely valuable in the events that followed.

History itself would come to the aid of the internees.

On 8 September 1943, news of Italy’s capitulation spread through the camp, giving the signal for action. The prisoners disarmed their guards without encountering any real resistance — it must be said that the guards themselves had only one desire: to return home as quickly as possible. This remains the only example of the liberation of a concentration camp during WWII that caused not a single casualty. But the Italian soldiers, aware that they themselves now risked capture and execution by their former German allies if taken prisoner, often chose instead to join the insurgents.

The Italian flag hangs over the Rab concentration camp on the island of Rab in the Adriatic Sea which was occupied by Italy and is now a part of Croatia. (Public domain via Wikimedia Commons)

Two days later, a large gathering took place in the camp’s “Square of Hunger”, during which the “Rab Partisan Brigade” was created. Numbering around 1,700 future fighters, it was incorporated into the 24th Division of Tito’s People’s Liberation Army of Yugoslavia. For the Jewish internees, integration into this force posed no problem: they knew that within this partisan army — then the strongest and best organized in Europe — a number of leaders were themselves Jewish, such as Moša Pijade. They would therefore be recognized as Jewish fighters “in their own right.”

The Jewish Rab Battalion (also known as the 5th Rab Battalion), formed on the Adriatic island of Rab after the September 1943 armistice with Italy liberated the Rab concentration camp, is seen here marching in September 1943.

The Rab Island Brigade was structured into five battalions. The first four were mainly Slovenian, while the fifth consisted of 250 Jews, generally adolescents, together with a medical unit of around 35 Jewish nurses, some of whom would later be assigned to other battalions. The unit was commanded by David Deča Kabiljo, a reserve officer, assisted by Edvard Ehrlich, the political commissar, who would later be killed in combat.

Yet the joy of liberation was mixed with deep apprehension: German soldiers could land on the island at any moment to retake control. It was necessary to leave as quickly as possible. It was decided to leave behind 204 Jewish detainees who were in too poor a physical condition to be transported. Tragically, they would later be deported to Auschwitz when German troops regained possession of the island.

On 17 September 1943, after a short crossing, the brigade landed at Novi Vinodol, a port on the mainland coast, where it joined the partisans of the People’s Liberation Army. A long march then began northward toward territories controlled by the N.O.V.’s 7th Banija Division. For sixteen days, the fighters advanced through the mountains and dense forests of inland Croatia, passing through areas sometimes held by the Chetniks, with whom relations could be tense. The battalion’s men were then incorporated into the 7th Partisan Division, which had just suffered heavy losses against the Germans. They received accelerated military training and were deployed in the regions of Banija, Kordun, and Lika — three inland Croatian areas that were theaters of particularly intense operations, where the partisans had to fight both Wehrmacht troops and Ustaše forces, who did not hesitate to execute prisoners. More than one hundred members of the Jewish battalion fell in combat between the autumn of 1943 and the end of the war in May 1945.

Ustaše militants pose with victims during the war. The fascist Croatian nationalist group murdered tens of thousands of Serbs, Jews and Roma. The United States Holocaust Memorial Museum estimates the Ustaše killed between 77,000 and 99,000 people, including up to 20,000 Jews, at Jasenovac, a death camp the group ran itself. (Courtesy: Memorijalni Muzej Jasenovac)

After peace returned, Tito’s Communist regime, from the moment it seized power, granted a place of honor in its official pantheon to the struggle of the partisans, Jewish and non-Jewish alike. Among the Jewish fighters, seven received the supreme distinction of National Hero — posthumously, with only two exceptions: Moša Pijade and General Voja Todorović, later appointed commander of the state’s land forces. In 1948, the year the State of Israel was created, the Communist authorities officially declared themselves hostile to Zionism, but Tito remained one of the few Eastern Bloc leaders to allow Jews to leave his country freely and emigrate to their new homeland.

Today, a memorial erected on the island of Rab commemorates the Jewish brigade, and each year gatherings known as Beyachad (“together” in Hebrew) bring together its descendants in remembrance. The memorial also serves as a reminder of the existence of the Italian concentration camps, for those inclined to forget. At the Shoah Memorial Museum in Paris, one may admire a striking photograph of the Jewish battalion of Rab Island cheerfully marching toward its future battles.

The battalion’s epic was also celebrated in song. In 1944, a young fighter, Shalom “Shani” Altarac, descended from a family of cantors from Sarajevo, composed in the Croatian forests of Kordun and Banija a Judeo-Spanish parody of the ritual songs of the Haggadah (the liturgical text recounting the liberation of the Jews under Pharaoh), which he called the Partisan Haggadah. The text reinterpreted the Exodus story to match communist ideology, viewing the insurrection of slaves against Pharaoh as a parallel to the proletariat uprising against capitalist and Axis oppressors. It famously begins with the line, “This is the bread of affliction that the Jewish partisans ate in the Croatian forests…”

Rather than being a one-time wartime artifact, Sarajevo’s Jewish community continued to recite this humorous parody at the very end of their community seders for decades after the war.



About the writer:

Michel Levine is a historian of Human Rights and the author of a work dedicated to the major cases of the League of Human Rights (Unclassified Cases. Unpublished Archives of the League of Human Rights, Paris, Fayard, 1973).
Further publications include a historical investigation on the repression of Algerian demonstrations in Paris in October 1961 (The October Ratonnades. A Collective Murder in Paris in 1961, Paris, Ramsay, 1985; reissue Jean- Claude Gawsewitch Publisher, 2001.)







WORD HAS IT

Orwell at the UN General Assembly (UNGA 81) – Decoding the anti-Israel Diplomatic Bias.

By Yoram Blumstein

In the aftermath of October 7th, an alarming new reality has gripped global Jewry: a wave of antisemitism and anti-Israel animus. This has been fueled by the overlapping efforts of states, non-state actors, and multilateral organisations (the UN, the International Court of Justice, the International Criminal Court, and other agencies). The 81st Session of UNGA bore testimony to the lies, manipulation of political language and distortion of truth for pure emotional intimidation, as leader after leader took to the UN rostrum to accuse Israel of “genocide”, “war crimes”, “mass starvation”, and creating conditions resembling a “concentration camp.” George Orwell, one of the greatest writers of the twentieth century, would have characterised the speeches of world leaders or their representatives (especially those of Brazil, Ireland, Spain, Turkey, Iran, Jordan, Qatar, France, Malaysia, the Palestinian Authority,and South Africa) as corrupt language designed to obscure their real intentions using metaphors and imagery about Israel’s purported “genocidal” conduct in Gaza. Orwell’s written masterpieces (like Nineteen Eighty-Four) were prescient. In his 1946 essay, ‘Politics and the English Language’, Orwell aptly stated:
 “Political language…is designed to make lies sound truthful and murder respectable, and to give an appearance of solidity to pure wind.”

War of Words. George Orwell recognized that political power is sustained not just through physical force, but through the deliberate corruption of words, a stratagem in the armory of Israel’s multifarious enemies.

This article applies an Orwellian diagnostic approach to dissect the diplomatic rhetoric which was nonchalantly employed by anti-Israel delegates at UNGA 81, where calumnies about the only Jewish state were employed as political weapons to manipulate public perception, while distorting the facts and the objective reality in Judea and Samaria (the West Bank), as well as Gaza. Such mendacities, especially if spewed from the rostrum of the world’s premier international organisation, against the Jewish state carry enormous weight in the court of public opinion and have real-world impact on the Israeli government and Jews.  In using Orwellian tools, this article seeks to decode the speech of the main state sponsor of Hamas/Muslim Brotherhood terrorism and genocidaire-in-chief, Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan. While other world leaders used similar anti-Israel canards, the singular honour must go to Erdoğan (who stands as one of Israel’s most vocal critics) since his speech was laden with political lies, devoid of legality, and nothing more than pretentious diction.  By deconstructing Erdoğan’s speech as pre-packaged lies, the article will extract specific speech acts used by the Turkish president in his invective against the State of Israel and juxtapose them with real-world facts grounded in legality and empirical observation.

Master of Malevolence.  Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan has a long history of severe verbal attacks against Israel, frequently labeling the country a “terrorist state” and comparing its leadership to the Nazi regime. (Photo: Adem ALTAN / AFP via Getty Images)

DECYPHERING TURKEY’S LIES ABOUT ISRAEL

Instead of using the general debate to promote international peace and security initiatives (especially in the Middle East), Erdoğan devoted a large portion of his speech to spreading lies about Israel and promoting a clear domestic and international agenda.  In Orwellian terminology, Erdoğan’s speech was littered with metaphors, imagery, political theatrics, selective moral outrage, and terminology, while obscuring the truth to fill political bandwidth. Yet, the Turkish leader is guilty of the very baseless charges he levels against Israel and thus deflects self-scrutiny.

“Gaza is the most inhuman concentration camp of our time…” and “the world’s largest graveyard for children…”

This was a high-octane and emotionally charged statement by Erdoğan. As such, it was designed for maximum impact. It is palpable that references to “concentration camp” and “graveyard” are insensitive and invoke historical analogies with the Holocaust, when the National Socialist German Workers’ Party (commonly known as the Nazi Party) killed more than six million Jews through gassing, summary execution and starvation. This is historical inversion and an affront to the Jewish people, the remaining Holocaust survivors and their families. Turkey is clearly creating a simplified good-versus-evil dichotomy, while purposefully ignoring geopolitical complexities and concealing Erdoğan’s hideous policies against the Kurds in northern Syria and Iraq.

How would Orwell relate to the above? Erdoğan is known for his double standards. He portrays himself as the leader of the Muslim world. Yet, he has:

– committed genocide against the Kurds in northern Syria and Iraq, as he will not countenance the creation of a Kurdish corridor or crescent (straddling northern Syria, Turkey, northern Iraq, and western Iran)

– armed and sponsored the former leader of the now-disbanded terrorist outfit Hayat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS) and now president of Syria, Ahmed Hussein al-Sharaa (formerly known by his nom de guerre, Abu Mohammad al-Julani), as a proxy against the Syrian Kurds

– supports Islamist movements in Libya and Sudan, and

– hosts Hamas leaders.

Hence, Erdoğan lacks the moral authority to lecture Israel on morality, and he should be treated as a diabolical, homicidal creature. The Turkish president’s specific utterance was not based on facts, but on weaponising language for political gain. The truth speaks for itself. Gaza is not a “concentration camp” or “graveyard” for children. It is an active combat zone; Hamas terrorists are doing the fighting, and Israel has taken extraordinary steps to minimise civilian casualties. In fact, the Israeli Defense Forces’ (IDF) Coordinator for the Government Activities in the Territories (COGAT) has assisted Israeli, regional and international aid agencies with the erection of temporary tents. At the same time, what government, bent on confining people to a “concentration camp”, would coordinate with international agencies to launch a polio vaccination campaign, if the intention is to kill them? By using and inverting the Holocaust analogy of “concentration camps”, Israel did not put policies and resources in place to confine Gazans to a specific location to eventually kill Palestinians. Conversely, this is exactly what Adolf Hitler and his henchmen did against Jews in major concentration camps in Germany, Poland, Austria, France, Estonia, Latvia, and the Czech Republic. They intended to exterminate all Jews as part of Hitler’s “Final Solution”, which was carried out by Adolf Eichmann, Heinrich Himmler and Reinhard Heydrich.  It is inaccurate to portray Israel as having created a “graveyard for children”, as the IDF has taken reasonable measures, in line with international humanitarian law, to protect children in Gaza. The faux sultan, Erdoğan, willfully neglected to inform the General Assembly that Hamas used hospitals, schools and public facilities in Gaza as shields and weapons storage facilities in its terrorist campaign against the IDF and Gazans. Tragically, children died in the war, yet Turkey, which, along with Qatar, has enabled Hamas to build its own open-air prison, from which it launched its murderous campaign against Jews and Israelis on October 7th. Erdogan also omitted the fact that COGAT continues to coordinate with Israeli humanitarian agencies to distribute vital baby formula to Gazans, as Hamas has intercepted aid supplies. The double standard is clear: There is no condemnation that Hamas started the war against Israel and should bear responsibility for all fatalities in Gaza. Israel was under attack and responded in self-defense. Check your facts, Erdoğan!  

“Insatiable genocidal mindset…” and “state terrorism”

Erdoğan’s arsenal of egregious statements against Israel includes references to the Israeli government as inherently “genocidal” and engaging in “state terrorism.” He further asserted that:

 “There is no war in Gaza; there are no two sides. This is an invasion, a massacre, a genocide, a policy of mass destruction.”

Israel never committed genocide and only acted in self-defense. The IDF launched “Operation Swords of Iron” to rescue the hostages and target those responsible for the October 7th massacre. This was a legitimate response, in line with the law of armed conflict. Regrettably, Erdoğan seems to be inspired by South Africa’s genocide case against Israel. The threshold to prove genocide is exceedingly high, as it is often referred to as the “crime of crimes.” The 1948 Genocide Convention defines genocide as “the specific intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a protected national, ethnic, racial, or religious group as such.” The accuser or the plaintiff must prove specific intent (dolus specialis) and the mental element (mens rea). Therefore, it is not enough to demonstrate massive civilian casualties, widespread destruction, or severe human suffering. In fact, Hamas is responsible for the implosion of Gaza, as it launched an unjustified attack on Israel. Erdoğan and his ally, the avaricious African National Congress (ANC), rely excessively on individual statements by a few senior Israeli politicians to prove “genocidal intent.” Israel’s legal team cogently argued that individual Israeli politicians’ statements were taken out of context and expressed in anger at the surprise October 7th attacks (the deadliest in Israel’s history since the Holocaust). The ICJ requires proof that political statements translated into official government policy that directed IDF commanders and soldiers to carry out “genocidal actions” in Gaza. This is a no-brainer since Israel did not display intent to kill and displace Palestinians. It is a figment of Erdoğan and South Africa’s imagination. The IDF’s actions were aimed at targeting Hamas’ terrorist infrastructure and leadership, and it put measures in place to ensure the safety of civilians in Gaza.  

In Orwellian terms, Erdoğan has failed to separate rhetoric from facts. As a matter of fact, Erdoğan should be hauled before the ICC and ICJ for war crimes and genocide committed against the Kurds, as his campaign was intentional and specific. He unleashed the full might of the Turkish army, intelligence and its proxies in northern Syria and Iraq to exterminate the Kurds, who rightfully deserve a state of their own. The Turkish government does not distinguish between Kurdish fighters (who have been instrumental in the defeat of the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria – ISIS) and civilians. Additionally, Erdoğan has exported his brand of Islamist fundamentalism to radical Islamists in Libya, Sudan and part of the Horn of Africa with political and material support, which continues to undermine regional stability and the peacemaking efforts of the African Union, Gulf countries and the international community.

BUILDING A RESILIENT, OFFENSIVE AND DEFENSIVE ECOSYSTEM IN DEFENSE OF ISRAEL

As lies and propaganda against Israel and the Jewish people will continue unabated, it is important to reclaim the narrative battlespace. By its own admission, the Israeli government has done a terrible job in promoting Israel’s international image since October 7th. In his address to UNGA 81, Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu correctly pointed out that Israel is fighting a battle on the eighth front: the battle for the truth.  Erdoğan and those of his ilk are the chief purveyors of false claims of genocide. The Turkish leader’s anti-Israel missive is nothing more than bullshit. In an entertaining little book, ‘On Bullshit’ (2005), Harry G. Frankfurt remarked that, “A person who undertakes bullshit his way through has much more freedom. His focus is panoramic rather than particular. He does not limit himself to inserting a certain falsehood at a specific point, and thus he is not constrained by the truths surrounding that point or intersecting it. He is prepared, so far as required, to fake the context as well.”

Rousing Rhetoric. Erdoğan speaks of the “ murderous ideology called Zionism” and said that “the genocide network has turned Gaza into the world’s largest cemetery for children.”

As Israel is central to Jewish identity, it behoves Jews to act as citizen-diplomats for the State of Israel and disabuse the liars of maligning the only Jewish state. The South African Jewish community, although Lilliputian in size (52 300, according to a recent study by the Kaplan Center for Jewish Studies at the University of Cape Town) compared to other diaspora communities, is the most Zionist in orientation, as evidenced by the indefatigable spirit of the leadership and volunteers of the South African Jewish Board of Deputies (SAJBD) and Zionist Federation (SAZF), which continue to engage with the Department of International Relations and Cooperation (DIRCO) and the South African Presidency whenever unwarranted policies and statements are made against Israel. This is active citizen diplomacy, as South African Jews accept constructive criticism of Israel, but not when it pivots towards antisemitism, extremism and lies. The South African Jewish community, of which I am a proud member, has built an effective ecosystem in defense of Israel. Other diaspora communities should take a page from the South African Jewish community’s commendable pro-Israel efforts.



About the writer:

Editor’s Note: Yoram Blumstein is a nom de plume the author uses to protect their identity because of previous security threats.