The massacre of Druze children on the Golan, Israel mourns while world ignores.
By Jonathan Feldstein
In case you missed the news, Saturday afternoon Israel time, Hezbollah fired a rocket from one of its bases in southern Lebanon at Israel’s Golan Heights region, a region heavily populated by Druze residents. Tragically it hit a soccer pitch killing 12 kids and injuring many others.
In doing so, the Iranian-backed Islamist terror group committed many crimes over and above the wanton murder. As Prime Minister Netanyahu so poignantly articulated in his address to the US Congress last week:
“This is not a clash of civilizations. It’s a clash between barbarism and civilization.”
The main differences in this latest attack on the Golan were the number of casualties, and the fact that they were Druze, not Jews.
Sight of Slaughter. The football pitch in Golan Druze village of Majdal Shams where kids were playing and then struck by missile fired by Hezbollah from Lebanon.
Over nearly 10 months, in addition to Hamas firing thousands of missiles and drones from Gaza, slaughtering 1200, raping and sexually mutilating many, and kidnapping more than 250 people to Gaza, Hezbollah in Lebanon has also fired thousands of rockets, missiles and drones at Israel, killing and wounding scores. Both are demonic. But Saturday’s attack was the largest number of casualties at any one time, from any one incident.
All of Israel is enraged.
Honoring Druze Fallen. A tree is planted in Ahihud Forest on July 2, 2024 in memory of fallen Druze soldier, Maj. Jamal Abbas, a company commander in the Paratroopers Brigade who was killed on Nov. 18, 2023 in the Gaza Strip. (Photo: Giorgia Valente/The Media Line)
Despite the magnitude of this massacre, cutting short Netanyahu’s US trip, many around the world may not have heard about it because with Arabs killing Druze rather than Jews killing Arabs, mainstream media was less interested. The facts complicated the preferred media narrative of blaming Jews!
The distance of the weapon fired at Israeli territory was so short that the 12 dead children, and dozens of others injured, did not have the time to get to one of the portable bomb shelters placed along the site of the soccer field where they were enjoying a quiet Saturday afternoon during their summer vacation.
Druze are an Arabic speaking minority. Their religion is somewhat secretive. While it is derived from Islam, they do not consider themselves Muslim, revering the biblical figure Jethro (Moses’ father-in-law) as their prophet. As such, they are often discriminated against within the Arab/Islamic world and have a tradition of being loyal to the countries where they reside.
In Israel, they are loyal citizens, serving in the IDF, achieving senior ranks militarily and throughout Israeli society, often in numbers that are disproportionately high to their small percent of the population. Many Druze have fallen in the line of duty. Israeli Druze consider themselves to be cousins of the Jewish people, partly with their reverence for Jethro, the father-in-law of Moses.
Grieving Together. IDF Chief of Staff, Lt. Gen. Herzi Halevi (center), at the soccer field in Majdal Shams, meeting with Druze community leader Sheikh Mowafaq Tarif (2nd left), local council representatives, and senior IDF officers.
Most Druze in the Golan find themselves in a complex situation not being Israeli citizens (their choice) but rather permanent residents following the Six Day War in 1967, when Israel took control of the Golan from Syria. Since Israel applied full Israeli sovereignty over the Golan, now fully recognized by the US, many Druze remain fearful to take Israeli citizenship lest they be accused of endorsing Israeli sovereignty and being seen as “traitors” in Syria to which this Golan community, historically, was once loyal to.
But make no mistake about it, the Golan Druze never want the Golan returned to Syria and as ties to Syria fade with time, are increasingly turning to Israel for citizenship. Israel views them as integrally part of the country, and their well-being and defense is no less important than for all the rest of the nearly 10 million Israelis. The massacre at the Golan Druze village of Majdal Shams was a shock to ALL Israelis.
Terror from Lebanon. A youth from the Druze community weeps over a makeshift memorial at the football pitch for the 12 children and teens killed in a rocket strike on a soccer field, in the village of Majdal Shams, in the Golan Heights, Monday, July 29, 2024. (Photo: AP Photo/Leo Correa)
While loyal to their respective countries and their governments, Druze are also fiercely tribal. Like Jews, when Druze anywhere suffer, Druze everywhere care. Of course, we have seen that clearly among the Israeli Druze since Saturday’s massacre, publicly advocating for the well-being of all Druze. But now, we are also seeing support from Syrian and Lebanese Druze who are publicly and unequivocally calling out Hezbollah, their supporters and, by implication, their own countries which have allowed this Iranian-backed Islamic extremists to gain strength and threaten them.
Hezbollah is armed and funded by Iran’s Islamic regime. Like Iran, Hezbollah does not distinguish between children or adults, soldiers or civilians, Jews, Moslems, Christians or Druze. On Saturday, Hezbollah terrorists brutally attacked and murdered a dozen Druze children and wounded dozens more, children whose only crime was going out to play soccer. Hezbollah knew full well they were firing their weapons at the second most populated city in the Golan. The carnage was no accident. It’s laughable that they and their Islamist defenders have gone out of their way not only to deny responsibility, but blame Israel.
Comrades-in-Arms. Family and friends of Cpt. Wassem Mahmoud attend his funeral service in the Druze village of Beit Jann, on June 16, 2024. Mahmoud was killed in battle in the southern Gaza Strip. (Photo: David Cohen/Flash90)
The expectation of an Israeli response against Hezbollah was overwhelming, but with the concern that it might escalate the situation with Hezbollah and even Iran. Israelis and Druze in Lebanon are understandably nervous.
Events following have only affirmed the concerns and nervousness as the region braces for an escalation of unpredictable proportion.
From Yesterday to Tomorrow. Concerned back then, Druze men look out over the border between Israel and Syria near Majdal Shams in the Golan Heights on February 14, 2014. What will the future bring? (Photo: AP/Oded Balilty)
People of conscience can send prayers and condolences that will be printed and delivered to the families. Just as the Druze in Israel are loyal, an essential part of the diverse Israeli mosaic, Israel’s friends around the world can show their love and support today for the grieving families now, and no matter what comes next by way of the war that may escalate tomorrow.
*Feature picture: Burying Children. Mourners attend the funeral in Majdal Shams of Druze children killed by a Hezbollah rocket fired from Lebanon, July 28, 2024. (Photo by Ayal Margolin/Flash90)
About the writer:
Jonathan Feldstein - President of the US based non-profit Genesis123 Foundation whose mission is to build bridges between Jews and Christians – is a freelance writer whose articles appear in The Jerusalem Post, Times of Israel, Townhall, NorthJersey.com, Algemeiner Jornal, The Jewish Press, major Christian websites and more.
While the mission of Lay of the Land (LotL) is to provide a wide and diverse perspective of affairs in Israel, the Middle East and the Jewish world, the opinions, beliefs and viewpoints expressed by its various writers are not necessarily ones of the owners and management of LOTL but of the writers themselves. LotL endeavours to the best of its ability to credit the use of all known photographs to the photographer and/or owner of such photographs (0&EO).
When the missiles began to rain down, a 22-year-old paramedic at kibbutz Be’eri chose to save others before herself.
By Forest Rain Marcia
Words are tools that describe and create reality. Powerful yet only representations, a reflection, not the experience itself. There is a gap between the two which usually goes unnoticed. But when the experience is profound the gap becomes sharp and painful. The words fall, broken and twisted into the chasm that they cannot bridge.
What words could encompass the whirlwind of evil that swept through this little building, snatching lives away and laughing the whole time?
The dental clinic in Be’eri was designated as a gathering place in an emergency. It was not equipped for the disaster that hit the community on October 7th. Who could imagine a full-scale invasion of monsters armed to the teeth and eager to rape and burn families alive?
It was here that the Children of Light fought the Children of Darkness.
Killed while treating the wounded. 22-year-old Magen David Adom paramedic Amit Man was killed when Hamas terrorists stormed Be’eri’s clinic. (Courtesy of MDA)
What words have enough truth in them, enough depth, to describe what happened in this little clinic? What words have enough light in them to describe Amit Man, beautiful and beloved, dedicated to life, choosing others above herself when the missiles began? She could have left the kibbutz. She could have stayed in the safe room. Instead, she took her paramedic’s bag and ran to the clinic. What words are enough to describe Dr. Daniel Levi, Amit, and a nurse battling for seven hours to treat the injured and save lives? What words are powerful enough to honor the two members of the kibbutz’s emergency response team who stood guard, fighting off the monsters so that the healers could treat the injured?
Seven hours, an eternity in hell.
Throughout the battle Amit, just 22 years old, kept her composure and constantly updated the Magen David Adom (MDA) headquarters about the condition of the wounded, pleading for evacuation. When the medical supplies ran out, she caressed the heads of the injured, gave them water, and encouraged them. Two of the survivors recounted that the assistance she provided saved their lives.
Around 2:00 PM the brave men battling to protect the clinic ran out of ammunition.
Amit managed to send a message to her family: “I don’t think I will get out of here. Please stay strong if something happens to me.”
“They’re here.”
Three little words. So much, unspeakable horror.
In her last call to her family Amit can be heard screaming “Shachar” the name of one of the men trying to protect her. Did she scream because she had already been shot in the leg or was it because she was watching his life run out of his body and she couldn’t help?
When Amit was found they saw she had been shot in the leg, managed to apply a tourniquet to herself, but was shot again and died.
Moving Messages. Messages on the bullet-pocked wall to those murdered at Kibbutz Be’eri’s medical clinic.
There are no words profound enough to convey what it is like to stand in the place where evil swept through, snatching lives away and laughing.
The walls, riddled with bullet holes, are silent yet accusatory. Here the Children of Light shone in all their glory. Here their sacrifice, love, dedication, honor, and dignity were not enough to stop the evil, ravenous and hellbent on stamping out life.
People whose loved ones were ripped from them here wrote on the walls, words doomed to fail in conveying the depths of their emotions.
The flatness of the words knocked the breath from my lungs. I saw words that attempted to infuse dignity and respect in a place where dignity was stolen. I saw words that attempted to express love and honor. And then one little word jumped out at me: “Mom”.
Amit Man’s sister Haviva and mother wrote these words on the wall, in between the bullet holes:
In memory of Amit Man, our little sister, the beloved of our hearts who was murdered while saving lives, together with Dr. Daniel Levi, Shachar Tzemach, and Eitan Hadad.
We love you forever and ever.
Mom ! Haviva
As time passes and others forget, we are left to pick up the debris left by the storm.
October 7th isn’t over.
A song for Amit – Nothing will hurt me
About the writer:
Forest Rain is an American-born Israeli who lives in northern Israel. She’s a branding expert and storyteller. Her passion is giving voice to the stories of Israel illuminating its profound events, cherished values, and exemplary role models that transcend borders, casting Israel as an eternal wellspring of inspiration and strength for a global audience.
Forest Rain made Aliyah at the age of thirteen. After her IDF service, she co-developed and co-directed a project to aid victims of terrorism and war. These activities gave her extensive first-hand experience with the emotional and psychological processes of civilians, soldiers, and their families, wounded and/or bereaved and traumatized by terrorism and war (grief, guilt, PTSD, etc). Throughout the years, she has continued to voice the stories, pain, and strength of traumatized Israelis to motivate others to provide support and counter the hate that threatens Jews in Israel, around the world, and Western civilization itself through the understanding that what begins with the Jews never ends with Jews.
While the mission of Lay of the Land (LotL) is to provide a wide and diverse perspective of affairs in Israel, the Middle East and the Jewish world, the opinions, beliefs and viewpoints expressed by its various writers are not necessarily ones of the owners and management of LOTL but of the writers themselves. LotL endeavours to the best of its ability to credit the use of all known photographs to the photographer and/or owner of such photographs (0&EO).
Warning: This article contains information that is not for sensitive readers
I have covered a lot during since 7 October. I have been down to the south, walked the killing fields of Kfar Aza, Nahal Oz, the Nova site and more. I have looked into the eyes of the families of hostages as they have pleaded for us to keep telling the stories of their loved ones to remind the world to fight for their release. I have interviewed lawyers and first responders who gathered the evidence to speak for our women and men who have been and continue to be sexually violated by Hamas. I have seen more footage and photography of the atrocities committed by Hamas than the human soul can bear – but this week I saw the evidence of another side of this evil.
Targeting Civilians. Orders from Hamas found in Sderot instructing their unleashed killers to raid “restaurants, bakeries, taxi stations.”
As journalists, we are the recorders of history, the witnesses that often speak for those who cannot, the storytellers of events and the pursuers of truth. Since 7 October, it has been at times an excruciating job but one that is almost sacred. In the face of growing denial, we have a duty to remind the world of what happened that Black Sabbath.
I was invited with a very small group of journalists to view evidence that the IDF Intelligence had captured in Israel and Gaza at the Israel Intelligence Commemoration Centre (IICC) on 7 October and throughout Operation Iron Swords. It is a chilling testament to the depths of evil and the meticulous planning that resulted in the worst massacre of Jews since the Holocaust and foreign nationals. There is no end to the depths to the depravity they carried out – and what their intentions were.
The evidence includes examples from the arsenal of weapons used by Hamas terrorists such as Bangalore’s to breach fences and walls, RPG’s, AK-47’s bayonets, thermobaric bombs, grenades, IED’s (Improvised Explosive Devices) and much more as well as headbands, identity documents, backpacks and personal effects belonging to various terror factions. Guides and manuals found on terrorists, included ISIS instructions on how to create toxic gas weapons. Two of the motorcycles that were among those used by the terrorists are also on display. Hamas breached Israel at 30 different points and entered in 150 pick-up trucks and 350 motorcycles. Their intention was to get as far as Tel Aviv and Jerusalem.
‘Exports’ from Gaza. Some of the weapons from Gaza used by terrorists on their murderous spree in southern Israel.
Kidnapping kits taken from the backpacks of terrorists are testimony to how meticulously planned the invasion was. The plan was to kidnap as many civilians and take them to Gaza. The kidnapping kits include tourniquets, syringes and drugs to take hostages and Tasers. Hostages had more value alive than dead but we know now how many corpses were ‘kidnapped’ as well.
The most chilling part of the exhibition is the collection of documentation and the evidence of incitement. Operational orders found included the instructions:
“Know that this enemy of yours is an incurable disease, except for head decapitation and uprooting hearts and livers”
A translation document explains how to say Hebrew phrases such as “women here“, “children here“, “take off your pants” and “take off your clothes“.
Mapped for Massacre. Detailed map of Kibbutz Be’eri where 102 Israeli civilians were brutally murdered including Vivian Silver, a Canadian-Israeli peace activist and women’s rights activist.
Other documents include detailed layout of a training area, designed to look like a kibbutz and plans for where to kidnap civilians. A map of Kibbutz Be’eri with neighborhoods clearly marked was also found. The map was found on one of the Hamas terrorists and had been torn up as he tried to destroy it before it was discovered. The map shows the areas of entry into the kibbutz, after Hamas gathered intelligence from Gazan workers from the kibbutz who entered Israel with work permits. The area that was purposely targeted were the houses to the south side of the kibbutz where families with young children lived.
Evidence from Gaza including copies of “Mein Kampf” translated into Arabic and documents proving employment at UNRWA as well as photographs and identity documents of Ashraf Mahd el Madhoun, and Islamic Jihad operative, posing with his family. He was an employee of UNRWA. Hamas would regularly have property ownership relationships with UNRWA and there is a collection of signed contracts as well as certificates of course completion.
Killer’s Literature. Examples of incite to murder literature including Hitler’s Mein Kampf in Arabic found by the IDF.
We hear a lot about the incitement in the Palestinian Territories, but when you are confronted with the evidence of it, it is a punch to the solar plexus. One of the most popular books found in your average Gazan home, displaying the level of indoctrinated from the cradle to the grave is a book for children about killing Jews with their car. There are also books about the “history of the Jews” where the worst antisemitic tropes are presented as fact. There are numerous books of collections of religious decrees or Fatwas that share religious justification to commit the unspeakable atrocities that were committed on 7 October.
UN complicity in Mass Murder. As confirmed by the ID card, this Islamic Jihad terrorist was also an UNRWA worker.
As journalists who have covered the atrocities and seen the footage, photos, and are familiar with the methods used by Hamas and other terror organizations, hearing medical and forensic explanations was as horrific as it was in the days and weeks that followed the invasion. I will spare you the details but I saw the evidence that feminist organisations, college students, social-justice “warriors” and so many deny. I saw the horror that Hamas carried out will glee and have sworn to commit again and again and again.
Translations to Terrorise. To assist Hamas abductors of Israeli hostages, they were found to carry Arabic-Hebrew lists of relevant words and phrases to assist in their monstrous activities.
The IICC will open a permanent exhibition of the evidence on 7 October 2024. The exhibition will be open to the public. Speaking to “Major T” who guided us through the evidence, he told us, “People can see that 7 October was very well planned for many years,” he continues. “It is important for people to see what happened because there is so much denial,” he says.
Evil exists. I know, because I saw the evidence with my own eyes.
While the mission of Lay of the Land (LotL) is to provide a wide and diverse perspective of affairs in Israel, the Middle East and the Jewish world, the opinions, beliefs and viewpoints expressed by its various writers are not necessarily ones of the owners and management of LOTL but of the writers themselves. LotL endeavours to the best of its ability to credit the use of all known photographs to the photographer and/or owner of such photographs (0&EO).
The fire burning in Yemeni port is Israel’s message delivered loud and clear.
By Jonathan Feldstein
In the pre-dawn hours Friday, Israel time, central Tel Aviv was attacked by an explosive drone fired by the Houthis, an Iranian proxy terrorist group in Yemen. Due to what the IDF says was human error, the drone was identified but not shot down by air defenses, nor were air raid sirens activated. This is what you need to know.
THE DISTANCE
The drone has been identified as an Iranian-made Samad-3, modified to have an extended range as Tel Aviv is some 1800 kilometers, more than 1100 miles, from Yemen. It reportedly flew at a low altitude for several hours via the Red Sea and over Egyptian territory, before striking Israel from the west over the Mediterranean Sea.
Hitting Houthis. Israel strikes Houthis 1,800km or 1,118 miles away in Yemen after drone hits Tel Aviv.
THE VICTIMS
A 50-year-old man was found dead in his apartment, apparently killed by shrapnel. Several were injured.
From Yemen with Hate. Yevgeny Ferder was killed in an explosive Houthi drone attack from Yemen on Tel Aviv in the early hours of July 19, 2024. (Courtesy)
THE WEAPON
In order to reach Tel Aviv through this indirect route over Egypt, it is believed that the Houthis modified the Iranian-made Samad-3 drone, decreasing the size of the explosive from 18 kilos to 10 kilos, and adding extra fuel. As much as the Houthis are an Iranian backed proxy terrorist organization, their use of Iranian weapons and its implications are under close scrutiny by Israel, by the west, and by the Iranian regime. How Israel is able to detect and respond to such attacks is something that all learn from.
Houthi’s Supplier. An Iranian Shahed-129 drone is displayed at a rally in Tehran, Iran. (Photo: AP/Ebrahim Noroozi)
THE TARGET
The drone approached Israel from the west. Albeit flying low, it may have been meant to appear harmless, along the flight pattern of many approaching commercial aircraft. It struck central Tel Aviv near to where the US Embassy Branch Office is located, but it is unclear whether that was the target. The day before, the US reportedly destroyed other drones, however the IDF reported that these are separate incidents. The Houthis have declared that this is a “new phase” in their attacks against Israel.
Targeting Tel Aviv. People in Tel Aviv look at building hit by a Houthi drone in a deadly June 18 attack from Yemen on July 19, 2024. (Photo: Jamal Awad/Flash90)
WHO ARE THE HOUTHIS
The Iran-backed Houthis took over southern Yemen and its capital, Sanaa, from its Sunni government in 2014. They control large parts of the country and remain in conflict with the Saudi-backed Yemeni government. Along with Hamas, Hezbollah, and other Iranian-backed terror groups, they are part of the “axis of resistance” against Israel. Since November 2023, they have fired hundreds of drones and missiles at Israel, and attacked ships along the southern tip of the Arabian Peninsula, and Red Sea, disrupting global shipping even through Egypt’s Suez Canal.
Heated Houthis. Fired-up Houthi supporters screaming venom against Israel in Sanaa, Yemen July 5, 2024. (Photo: REUTERS/KHALED ABDULLAH)
ISRAEL’S RESPONSE
Due to the attack, the Israeli cabinet ministers gathered in an emergency session on Saturday, Shabbat (the Sabbath). Typically, public business and government activities do not take place on the Sabbath, indicating that this was a seen as a serious military situation that required an immediate response, and that further Israeli restraint was not an option.
IDF Spokesman Daniel Hagari noted this was a particularly complicated mission, using F-15’s, F-35’s, and other aircraft including refueling planes to carry out ten airstrikes against Houthi military targets around Yemen’s Hodeidah port, used to transport Iranian weapons.
Other than the immediacy of the response, Israel’s targeting of military facilities 1,800 kilometers (1,100 miles) away, is a signal to Iran. Tehran is also about 1800 kilometers from Israel. Some might consider this a test run for an Israeli attack on Iranian nuclear and other military facilities. In addition to the distance, Israel’s response indicated that it has significant intelligence capabilities, also a warning to Iran, Hezbollah and others.
Rapid Reply. In response to Houthi’s drone attack on Tel Aviv, Israeli fighter jets attack the Yemeni port of Hodeidah leaving it ablaze as oil tanks burn. (Photo AP)
After the Israeli response, Defense Minister Yoav Gallant said:
“The fire that is currently burning in Hodeidah, is seen across the Middle East and the significance is clear. The Houthis attacked us over 200 times. The first time that they harmed an Israeli citizen, we struck them. And we will do this in any place where it may be required.”
WHAT’S NEXT
Despite Israel’s attack, the IDF issued no new civilian security instructions indicating a higher state of alert. Prime MinisterNetanyahu is still planning to embark on his trip to the United States to meet President Biden, and address a joint session of Congress.
After the attack near the US Embassy office, Netanyahu is expected to double down on highlighting the Islamic regime’s increasing efforts to destroy Israel, their terrorist tentacles throughout the Middle East, and apparently accelerating their nuclear weapons drive. Secretary of State Blinken said Iran could be just “one to two weeks away” from having enough nuclear material for a bomb.
Three months after Iran’s own unprecedented missile and drone attack, Netanyahu’s message is all the more relevant. Saturday night he said:
“Anyone who wishes to see a stable and safe Middle East needs to stand against Iran’s axis of evil, and support Israel’s fight against Iran and its proxies – in Yemen, in Gaza, in Lebanon, everywhere.”
Israel informed the US and other regional governments in advance of its strike against the Houthi targets. While it does not seem that any immediate threats of escalation from the Houthis or others are on the horizon, there is the potential that the direct retaliation against the Houthis could trigger still further response from Yemen or other Iranian proxies, especially if Netanyahu is out of the country on an important visit to Washington.
ARAB ALLIES
In addition to notifying Washington in advance, there are indications that Arab countries were also informed. The Saudis, who are also in conflict with and have been attacked by the Houthis, could possibly have assisted by allowing the use of their airspace. While the Saudis and the Egyptians – whose airspace was both breached – could not directly or indirectly to be seen supporting Israel’s attack, it is not unreasonable to speculate they at least they were silently celebrating.
CURRENT EVENTS OR PROPHESY?
“So said the Lord:
For three sins of Edom, yea for four, I will not return them: For pursuing their brother with a sword, and they destroyed their mercy and grasped forever their anger and kept their fury forever. And I will send fire into Teman (Yemen), and it shall consume the palaces of Bozrah.”
(Amos 1:11-12)
Israel strikes Houthi targets in Yemen
About the writer:
Jonathan Feldstein - President of the US based non-profit Genesis123 Foundation whose mission is to build bridges between Jews and Christians – is a freelance writer whose articles appear in The Jerusalem Post, Times of Israel, Townhall, NorthJersey.com, Algemeiner Jornal, The Jewish Press, major Christian websites and more.
While the mission of Lay of the Land (LotL) is to provide a wide and diverse perspective of affairs in Israel, the Middle East and the Jewish world, the opinions, beliefs and viewpoints expressed by its various writers are not necessarily ones of the owners and management of LOTL but of the writers themselves. LotL endeavours to the best of its ability to credit the use of all known photographs to the photographer and/or owner of such photographs (0&EO).
With modern war increasingly urban, the ICC ruling against Israel has in fact criminalized the very act of war itself in its current manifestation.
By Major (Ret)John Spencer
In May, the International Criminal Court announced applications for warrants for the arrests of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his defense minister, Yoav Gallant. “Today we once again underline that international law and the laws of armed conflict apply to all,” the court’s chief prosecutor, Karim Khan said in a statement. “No foot soldier, no commander, no civilian leader — no one — can act with impunity.” The charges follow a U.S. Department of State report that was similarly critical of Israel for not doing enough to prevent the loss of civilian lives.
Ignoring Evidence. The ICC’s chief prosecutor, Karim Khan. While the ICC accuses Israel of “starvation of civilians as a method of warfare,” and “intentionally directing attacks against a civilian population,” the writer asserts that these accusations ignore mountains of evidence to the contrary “which I saw firsthand.”
As someone who has visited the frontlines in this war, and who has written about, visited, and engaged in various urban battles over the past two decades as a U.S. Army officer and researcher, even as I applaud the court’s attempt to hold those guilty of war crimes accountable, I believe the ICC’s decision is wrong about Israel. Worse, the ruling could perversely have the opposite effect intended:
by holding all states to such a high standard when it comes to avoiding civilian harm, governments may feel hamstrung to respond to attacks in the future, even in self-defense. That could have a chilling effect on countries that adhere to international legal norms while providing a bonanza for rogue states like Russia or non-state actors like Hamas that ignore these norms.
The war in Gaza is unlike almost any other I’ve seen. The terrain, the density of tunnels under population centers, the nature of the enemy, and the presence of hostages all combine to make this war an exceptionally fraught one for Israel to fight bloodlessly. What I saw in Gaza convinced me that Israel has taken the necessary steps to avoid civilian casualties, even as it has come under unwavering criticism for its handling of the war. As the Israeli Defense Forces now conducts a constrained ground operation into Rafah, the last Hamas holdout in southern Gaza and where the remaining Israeli hostages are believed to be held, the Israeli government continues to announce temporary evacuations of southeastern Rafah instructing civilians to move out of harm’s way.
The Front Line Up-Close. The writer (left) embedded with Israeli troops in Gaza.
Israel has gone above and beyond what is traditionally required of armies. In Gaza, they faced 40,000 enemy defenders in dense urban terrain featuring some 400 miles of deep buried military tunnels at a depth of 15 to over 200 feet deep purposely built under civilian and protected sites. The defenders were equipped with over 15,000 rockets and a full array of small arms, mortars, and improvised explosive devices. The enemy had defenses that took at least fifteen years to prepare and fortify. Hamas held over 200 hostages, disguised themselves as civilians, and used ordinary Gazans as human shields to manipulate external actors, especially the United States, to stop Israel from escalating and instead to push for a ceasefire. Largely because of Egypt, there was almost no possibility for the 2.2. million civilians in Gaza to completely flee the war zone by land.
The laws of war are clear. Militaries must distinguish between unarmed civilians and combatants as well as between civilian-use objects (hospitals, schools, etc.) and military targets (ammo dumps, bases, etc.). But militaries must also take constant care to “spare civilian populations, civilians, and civilian objects to include all feasible precautions to avoid andminimize incidental loss of civilian life, injury to civilian life, injury to civilians and damage to civilian objects.”
There is no place harder on earth to uphold these principles than in a densely packed city, especially against a combatant who wears no uniform, or who attempts to blend in with civilians.
Historically, the main approach militaries take to preventing civilian casualties in this kind of terrain has been to evacuate city centers before the main battle begins. Only during the last two decades of counterinsurgency and counterterrorism wars have some countries like the United States, developed concepts pertaining to “civilian harm mitigation.” These best practices were developed by different commanders and units against insurgents and terrorists in Afghanistan, Iraq, and Syria and then collected in a policy and adopted officially in a Department of Defense instruction in December 2023. Many of these concepts and practices have never been attempted in unconventional warfare where the military objective is to overthrow a ruling power and destroy its military.
Israel has obviously made mistakes – all militaries do. Aid and food convoys came under attack earlier this spring, mostly a result of faulty intelligence in a split moment decision. The ICC has accused Israel of “starvation of civilians as a method of warfare,” and “intentionally directing attacks against a civilian population.” This kind of accusation ignores mountains of evidence to the contrary which I saw firsthand.
To its credit, Israel has implemented almost all the civilian harm mitigation practices required of urban warfare and legal norms spelled out by international humanitarian law (IHL), as well as created a few new ones no military has ever tried. For example, the IDF provided ample time for civilians to evacuate Gaza’s major cities. At the beginning of the war, Israel waited several weeks after civilians had been cleared before beginning its full ground invasion in Gaza. To prevent accidental targeting, the IDF provided safe routes for civilians to use and a humanitarian zone for them to flee to.
Protecting Civilians. Citizens in Gaza reading leaflets dropped by Israel in a leafleting campaign telling them to leave an area to avoid harm from an Israeli planned attack. (Photograph: Anadolu agency/Getty Images)
Despite reports of the IDF conducting operations near the routes and safe zone, they positioned IDF soldiers along the route or halted operation near the routes to protect civilians. At the same time, there is video documentation of Hamas preventing civilians from using the routes, attacking civilians on the routes by shooting at them, and emplacing rocket launchers next to the routes and zones to draw Israeli fire.
Historically, the most common tactic to evacuate cities smoothly has been dropping flyers and social media posts. The IDF did both, but also utilized other methods to notify, locate, encourage civilians to temporarily evacuate main combat areas. As of January 2024, Israel had dropped more than 7.2 million flyers, but also made over 79,000 direct phones calls, sent over 13.7 million text messages, and left over 15 million pre-recorded voicemails to notify civilians that they should leave combat areas. The IDF flew drones with speakers into Hamas-held territories and dropped large speakers by parachute that broadcasted for civilians where to evacuate and go when they hit the ground. No military has ever deployed all these other direct electronic measures to reach civilians.
The IDF also conducted what are called “roof knocks” ahead of many air strikes – a procedure where the IDF call everyone in a building, provide time for them to evacuate, and if necessary, drop small munitions on the roof to signal immediate evacuation of the building. No other army in the world does this.
The IDF fields legal officers at the brigade and division level to approve legitimate targets and provide guidance to avoid civilian casualties and violations of IHL. As far back as November, they’ve conducted daily pauses of combat operations for several hours to allow civilians to pass through friendly lines during the battles.
As the war progressed, Israel learned the operational tactics of Hamas, which was bent on increasing civilian harm to win over global and regional sympathies. As such, the IDF evolved and adapted different civilian harm mitigations approaches. By December, the IDF had begun handing out their military maps to Gazans. These maps were used to communicate directly to civilians not only to make evacuations more orderly, but also to notify civilians where the IDF would be operating on a day-to-day basis. This information of course was useful for Hamas and increased the risk to IDF soldiers.
Or consider the IDF’s creation of a Civilian Harm Mitigation Cell (commanded by a one star general) during the war. The cell developed a new methodology to track civilian presence in real time. Using cell phone presence, satellite, drone footage, and street-by-street battle damage assessment, this methodology can determine the percentage of residents remaining in areas of Gaza. The new awareness and real-time mapping software enabled the IDF to take additional precautions and limit operations in densely populated areas, no doubt reducing civilian casualties.
Similarly, other restrictions the IDF has imposed includes altering their rules of engagements and release authority for strikes, including the implementation of standard military controls measures such as “no fire areas” on protected buildings and sensitive sites. Conducting an operation, entering, or even returning fire in some locations require the Chief of the General Staff of the IDF approval.
The IDF conducted large “call out” operations where the IDF encircle a location, such as the Al-Nasser Hospital, but also entire neighborhoods (tens of thousands of people) in Khan Yunis that are encircled and then told to evacuate through IDF positions. If anything, these operations increase the risk to the IDF. Then, large facial recognition assets are used to identify Hamas members trying to blend in with the evacuating civilians who are then detained.
Rather than argue that the IDF did not do all the above measures, pundits either cherry pick from the practices, or like the Department of State report acknowledges, make assumptions without access to needed information. They also interpret the effects of IDF operations, irrelevant of the context of each action, to say it does not matter because the IDF measures have been ineffective based on their own kabuki dance of statistics they can cite. Many of these groups also cite a standard of civilian harm mitigation measures, like the new Department of Defense policy, that no military has yet followed especially in a conventional war. Regardless of the facts, critics frame the fighting by comparing the war in Gaza to single battles, in a counterinsurgency or counterterrorist campaign, that do not have nearly the same military challenges.
Again, to its credit, the IDF managed to successfully evacuate over 850,000 civilians out of 1 million people (85 to 90%) in Northern Gaza before the heaviest fighting began and now in Rafah there are reports of temporary evacuation to a high degree of percentage. These percentages are consistent with urban warfare history that show that no matter the effort, about 10 percent of populations stay.
The majority of the criticism and condemnation of Israel’s actions in Gaza focuses on the combatant to civilian ratio in the war. But even that metric does not show that the IDF have not been effective in reducing civilian harm given the context of the size, disposition (i.e. tunnels under civilian areas), and tactics of Hamas.
The Hamas-run Gaza Health Ministry estimate of over 36,000 civilian deaths does not acknowledge a single Hamas fighter death. It also does not distinguish if a civilian died due to the misfiring – estimated between 10% to 20% — of the more than 13,000 rockets fired by Hamas or other terrorists that have landed inside Gaza. Nor does the figure account for the killing of civilians by Hamas or any deaths by natural causes. Literally, this figure just counts every death in Gaza since October 7th.
Israel now publicly estimates it has killed around 15,000 Hamas operatives. Common sense would subtract the IDF estimate of Hamas fighters from the Hamas Gaza Health Ministry total deaths in Gaza to get 21,000 civilian deaths according to Hamas. That would be a 1 to 1.5 or 1.6 ratio. But even the Gaza Health Ministry recently announced they had incomplete data for over 11,000 and cannot provide the names of more than 10,000 of their reported 38,000 deaths. This acknowledgement was followed weeks later by the United Nation acknowledging over 10,000 names were unverifiable and of those names accounted for, the number of women and children was less than 50% previously reported by the Gaza Health Ministry.
So, combined with Hamas’ historic practice of exaggerating casualty figures, the combatant-to-civilian death ratio is more likely one to one, which would be historically low for high intensity urban warfare.
Consider the 2016-2017 Battle of Mosul, the biggest urban battle since the Second World War. The U.S.-led Iraqi Security Force operation led to the death of 9,000 to 11,000 civilians in order to take out 3,000 to 5,000 ISIS combatants in the city. That is a 1 to 2.5 combatant to civilian death ratio. Perhaps the 1945 Battle of Manila is a more apt comparison, given its variables similar to Gaza, like high number of defenders, tunnels, and hostages. During that American operation, 100,000 civilians were killed to defeat 17,000 Japanese defenders. That is a one to six combatant-to-civilian ratio. Or take the 1950 Second Battle of Seoul, another battle with similar variables to the war in Gaza, when American forces likely killed tens of thousands to destroy the 8,000 North Korean enemy defenders and recapture the city. There is no record of how many civilians died in the city battle out of the estimated 2 million-plus civilians who perished in the war.
So, applying all the numbers available, the IDF’s 1-to-1.5 if not one-to-one combatant-to-civilian ratio would be considered more humane than almost any other battle, past or modern, in urban warfare with even remotely similar conditions. Before the war in Gaza, the United Nations and many other international organizations regularly stated that civilians accounted for ninety percent of the casualties of modern urban wars.
The truth is that no one knows how many civilians have died in Gaza, especially not Hamas. There has never been a war or battle fought in urban settings where an organization could track the civilian deaths on a day-to-day basis and down to the single digit. It is impossible. The fog of urban war is thicker than any other battleground. A year after the 2016-2017 Battle of Mosul, the Iraqi government did not know how many civilians had died there, with estimates ranging from 11,000 to 40,000.
The IDF also already reduced an already low combatant-to-civilian casualty ratio in the war. Even the New York Times stated that the IDF had reduced the daily civilian death toll in Gaza by more than half by December and by almost two-thirds from its peak by January. By the time the IDF reached the city of Khan Yunis in February, the civilian deaths caused by IDF actions in the war was very low in comparison to the heaviest fighting in Northern Gaza.
Another heavily leveled accusation, one the ICC continues is that Israel has conducted “large-scale bombing that has caused and continues to cause so many civilian deaths, injuries, and suffering in Gaza.” This is likely related to the misplaced coverage of Israel’s use of 2,000-pound bombs. Many have tried to argue the 2000-pound bomb, which is commonly deployed against enemy forces in bunkers and tunnels, has rarely been used in urban areas. This is not only false, but the claim is always waged without mentioning what Israel has used the bombs against, Hamas in their 400-miles of deep buried tunnels. The United States military dropped over 5,000 two-thousand-pound bombs in the 2003 invasion of Iraq in just one month (March 19 to April 18, 2003) to include in Baghdad, a city of over 5 million residents at the time. They dropped 4 x 2,000-pound bombs on just one building trying to kill Saddam Hussein and his sons in Baghdad. In the short 42 days of the First Gulf War (January 17 to February 27, 1991), the U.S. military dropped 11,179 Mk84 (2,000 pound) bombs as well as 4,616 other 2,000 pound bombs on military targets in urban areas across Iraq.
All war is hell, but when a nation is forced into combat there are laws of armed conflict and recently developed civilian harm-mitigation measures that seek to reduce that hell for civilians caught in the crossfire. Because of the constraints of modern war – which is increasingly urban, hybrid, and fought among civilian areas – the ICC ruling against Israel has in fact criminalized the very act of war itself in its current manifestation. The result is that any government or military, even one provoked or attacked without justification, will feel hamstrung to respond proportionately. The court ruling makes a mockery out of Article 51, which allows countries to act in self-defense.
Award Winning Writer. The writer was winner of the 2023 Gold Medal Award, Best Military History Memoir, Military Writers Society of America.
No doubt Israel, just as the United States did in Iraq and Afghanistan, has made mistakes and thousands of innocent lives have been lost. Yet the IDF has also employed nearly all the best practices used by other militaries as well as implemented many none have ever tried. The question becomes, if any country takes all these precautions and is still considered beyond the pale of modern war, can any country that tries to adhere to international humanitarian legal norms fight wars at all, particularly ones in urban settings, even to defend themselves?
The answer sent from The Hague is a voluminous no, even against an adversary that takes almost no care in protecting its people or adhering to international norms, in fact deploying a human sacrifice strategy of trying to get as many of its own population killed. Ironically, by singling out the Israeli leadership for war crimes, the court may have reduced the deterrent effect other states seek by fielding large armies and deploying expensive weapons. The result could be a blank check to rogue actors like Hamas as well as rogue states like Russia, Iran, or North Korea. The IDF should be commended for its efforts to reduce civilian harm, not charged in an international court alongside Hamas leaders – particularly when compared to measures Hamas has taken to increase civilian suffering in Gaza.
About the writer:
John Spencer is chair of urban warfare studies at the Modern War Institute (MWI) at West Point, codirector of MWI’s Urban Warfare Project and host of the “Urban Warfare Project Podcast.” He served for 25 years as an infantry soldier, which included two combat tours in Iraq. He is the author of the book “Connected Soldiers: Life, Leadership, and Social Connection in Modern War” and co-author of “Understanding Urban Warfare.” The views expressed in this commentary are his own.
While the mission of Lay of the Land (LotL) is to provide a wide and diverse perspective of affairs in Israel, the Middle East and the Jewish world, the opinions, beliefs and viewpoints expressed by its various writers are not necessarily ones of the owners and management of LOTL but of the writers themselves. LotL endeavours to the best of its ability to credit the use of all known photographs to the photographer and/or owner of such photographs (0&EO).
There could well be with Israel’s women hostages subject to rape and now passing the 9-month mark of captivity!
By Jonathan Feldstein
Sunday July 7 is not just another day. It is 275 days since the inhuman Hamas invasion and massacre in Israel, slaughtering 1200 and taking more than 250 hostages to Gaza. 120 are still in captivity in Gaza’s network of terror tunnels. Some may be held captive in the private homes of Hamas terrorist operatives, as were the four rescued in a bold IDF operation on June 8.
Through forensic and other evidence, Israel has declared that a few dozen of the 120 hostages are already dead. The actual number of hostages still alive is unknown because Hamas has never even presented a list of those who it holds in captivity, from one year old Kfir Bibas to hostages in their 70s and 80s. Not all of the 120 hostages are Israeli, or Jewish, including Bedouin Israeli Arabs, and citizens of many other countries.
With an all-out assault on Hamas, targeting the terrorists and their leaders, their military infrastructure, weapons, and weapons manufacturing abilities, along with the imperative to locate and rescue all the remaining hostages, many of whom are dead already, how is it possible that there might be more hostages?
120 hostages – Bring them home NOW!!!
The answer is because July 7 is also nine months since the 250 people were kidnapped.
Among the 120 hostages still in captivity, 12 are women. How many are alive is unknown, as it is unknown how many may in the last trimester of a pregnancy as a result of rape by their terrorist captors.
During the assault and massacre on October 7, numerous cases of rape, gang rape, and sexual mutilation took place and have been abundantly documented, many in sickening detail that underscores the deliberate and demonic attack. The confession of father and son terrorists to gang raping the same woman before the father killed her is just one of the disgusting displays of this.
Hamas Rapists. Hamas terrorists, father Radi (right) and son Abdallah (left), admit during the investigation raping before murdering women on Oct. 7. The father described how he raped a crying woman at gunpoint, and the son described how his father murdered the woman “after we finished raping her.” The father admitted to raping multiple women. (Photo: Shin Bet)
Hamas Rapists. Hamas terrorists, father Radi (right) and son Abdallah (left), admit during the investigation raping before murdering women on Oct. 7. The father described how he raped a crying woman at gunpoint, and the son described how his father murdered the woman “after we finished raping her.” The father admitted to raping multiple women. (Photo: Shin Bet)
In addition to many of the 1200 people massacred on October 7 raped and sexually mutilated, some murdered while they were rape. There has also been wide testimony and documentation of the sexual assault of some of the women hostages. Among the videos released that were filmed and documented by the terrorists themselves, there are incidents of terrorists commenting, “Here are the girls who can get pregnant.”
Hard Truth Revealed. Appearing in front of her destroyed home at the Kibbutz Kfar Aza, released hostage Amit Soussana became the first Israeli woman to speak publicly about enduring sexual assault and other forms of violence during her 55 days in captivity following the Hamas-led attack on Israel on October 7. (Photo: Alexandre Meneghini/Reuters/File)
Despite the evidence that has been documented ad nauseum, literally, there are many who deny these truths, resting on the purported Islamic principle that raping women is not allowed. It seems that terrorist sympathizers are prepared to deny the truth in defense of the terrorists, rather than admitting that what the terrorists did is not only inhuman but against Islam.
Among the most recent and public of these is notorious former Pink Floyd bassist, the unrepentant and delusional antisemite, Roger Waters. Far from being intelligent or an expert on anything other than Jew-hatred, Waters simply denies that such atrocities took place, lying that there is no evidence.
‘Dark Side’ of Roger Waters. Appearing on ‘Piers Morgan Uncensored’, Roger Waters claimed ‘no evidence’ of Oct. 7 of Hamas rapes, refused to condemn terror onslaught, defended telling Israelis to ‘go back to Eastern Europe or the US or wherever you came from’ and urged Israeli radio not to play his songs.
While rape and sexual violence is not new and often used in war and genocide, Hamas has followed the lead of its Islamic ideological twin, ISIS, whose misogynist ideology actually allows publishing rules for raping women. This has led many October 7 deniers to defend Islam in general, and Hamas’ atrocities in specific, saying that rapes could not happen and did not happen because it is against Islam. This is nothing more than a theological shell game.
A recent Jerusalem Post article discusses the medical, ethical, and psychological consequences of hostages raped by the terrorists highlighting in chilling detail, ISIS’s permissive “rape laws”. These Islamic rape laws prohibit the rape of pregnant women, noting the ISIS Islamic imperative to prevent women captives who have “legitimately” been turned into sex slaves from becoming pregnant. One contradiction to impregnating female captives, per the inhuman Islamic ideology of ISIS and its ideological twin, Hamas, is that impregnating a woman “essentially converts her and her children to Islam, and she should be grateful for this throughout her life.”
More than a theory from which the likes of Roger Waters and other October 7 deniers can claim no evidence, there are official ISIS leaflets which overtly state that an Islamic fighter (terrorist) can rape a woman he enslaves almost under any condition, even if she is a child, but must ensure she is not pregnant. This explains some of the testimonies of Israeli hostages who have been released or rescued, with former hostages noting their terrorist captors’ interest in their menstrual cycles. According to the JPost article, some survivors reported received birth control pills or morning-after pills while in captivity.
How many of the hostages are alive is unknown, as is how many of those are women. Based on the testimonies of women who have been released or rescued, sexual assault in captivity is not a possibility but a reality.
Now, nine months later, the question is how many of these women are days or hours away from giving birth to babies conceived in captivity by their demonic captors? How many may have given birth early because of the subhuman conditions, lack of pre-natal care, and basic nutrition that they have been subjected to?
Are there new hostages who have been born already, or to be born, in Gazan captivity? Will their Islamic captors take away living babies to raise them as Moslems and/or deny that any babies were ever born to the hostages? Will Hamas realize that the birth of babies to women who have been in captivity will not play well in the media and, if discovered, will be bad PR for the Iranian backed Islamic “resistance?”
Site of Savagery. The site of the Nova music festival where at least 260 Israeli festival-goers were murdered in a massacre during the attack by Hamas on Oct 7. (AP Photo)SavagerySite of The site of the Nova music festival where at least 260 Israeli festival-goers were murdered in a massacre during the attack by Hamas on Oct 7. (AP Photo)
Will we ever know for sure how many of the women were raped and impregnated by the terrorists? Will Hamas make them, and their babies disappear? Will they have any hesitation to murder, dismember, or even incinerate the human evidence, or witnesses to the pregnant women and newborn babies to cover up their crimes that they gleefully filmed and published nine months ago? It is too sick a reality to imagine, much less conversations be had. Please join the Genesis 123 Foundation by signing the petition to compel world bodies to pressure Hamas to release ALL the hostages today.
About the writer:
Jonathan Feldstein - President of the US based non-profit Genesis123 Foundation whose mission is to build bridges between Jews and Christians – is a freelance writer whose articles appear in The Jerusalem Post, Times of Israel, Townhall, NorthJersey.com, Algemeiner Jornal, The Jewish Press, major Christian websites and more.
While the mission of Lay of the Land (LotL) is to provide a wide and diverse perspective of affairs in Israel, the Middle East and the Jewish world, the opinions, beliefs and viewpoints expressed by its various writers are not necessarily ones of the owners and management of LOTL but of the writers themselves. LotL endeavours to the best of its ability to credit the use of all known photographs to the photographer and/or owner of such photographs (0&EO).
It’s not every day that I read headlines at home in Israel and think of classic American folk-rock songs. In fact, it has never happened before. Until recently.
By Jonathan Feldstein
As I was reading a particularly gruesome news item related to the October 7 Hamas attack on Israel and savage massacre of 1200 people, and kidnapping of more than 250 others (of whom 120 remain in captivity), the Crosby, Stills, Nash, and Young (CSNY) song, “Teach Your Children” came to mind. The song reached number 16 in 1970. As much as I never connected an American folk-rock song with headlines in Israel, I probably never thought about the song’s lyrics either. It’s a song about passing on values from one generation to the next, emphasizing the importance of teaching children well, to help them grow into their best selves, to create a better future individually, as a legacy from one generation to the next.
Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young – Teach Your Children
“Teach your Children” echoed as I read the text of an article, “IDF airs interrogation clips of terrorist father and son confessing to rape on Oct. 7.”
Among the thousands of Palestinian Arab terrorists who committed inhuman acts, slaughtering, maiming, torturing, raping and sexually mutilating thousands of Israelis, Ahmad Radi did anything but teach his child well. Breaching Israel’s border in an orgy of hate and destruction, he shamelessly brought his son Abdallah to participate in the murderous rampage. While more than 1000 Hamas terrorists were killed in Israel on and in the immediate aftermath of the October 7 massacres, the father and son were captured. In separate interrogations, Ahmad and Abdallah confessed to murder and rape. In fact, they raped the same woman before (father) Ahmad executed her.
‘Capture & Slaughter Women’: Interrogation Video of 2 Hamas Terrorists Who Invaded Israel On Oct 7
If Ahmad only had an ear for classic folk rock and not jihadi hate, he maybe would have set a positive example, rather than transmitting to Abdalah the evil genocidal hatred he embodies, and has clearly imbued in his son.
CSNY sang, “You, …Must have a code that you can live by…Teach your children well…And feed them on your dreams.” Clearly Ahmad, thousands of terrorists who participated in the October 7 massacre, and the tens of thousands of Hamas leaders and their brigades, along with hundreds of thousands who support and enable them, have chosen their “code” to live by. Rather than feeding them on the dreams of building and doing something positive, their vision and goals are exclusively to destroy Israel, to slaughter Jews.
The lyrics continue, “The one they pick’s the one you’ll know by.” Basically, CSNY are saying that a father’s legacy lives on through his children. Unfortunately, generations of Palestinian Arabs have transmitted a legacy of geocidal hate, fueled by extremist Islam founded in the Moslem Brotherhood of which Hamas is an ideological child, and funded and supported by the Islamic republic regime in Iran.
Sadly, for most Gazans, this Father’s Day will be marked by living in accordance with an immoral code which they celebrate, and worship, even according to their own internal polls. They surely do not represent the song’s message that the past is the past, and it’s time to move forward. They raise their children from as young as 3-4 to worship jihad, and practice genocidal antisemitism. The inhuman acts of killing and maiming others supplants any aspiration to build a future for themselves, or to pass on good values.
This makes the rhetorical and often hollow question/accusation to Israel about having a plan for the day after to be more than ridiculous because the hatred and evil are so deeply entrenched.
By comparison, in traditional Judaism, a father’s responsibility is to teach their child a profession, and how to swim – things to enable them to live well, make a living, and protect themselves. Not to kill others.
CSNY’s chorus implores parents to move beyond the struggles of the previous generation (the father’s hell that did slowly go by), and the importance of nurturing children’s dreams so they can live fulfilling lives.
Audio Reveals Hamas Terrorist Bragging To Parents On Call: ‘I Killed 10 Jews
The second verse addresses the children, and challenges them to be empathetic towards their elders, recognizing that they may have lived through tough times. It also tells young people to use their energy and idealism to change the world for the better, before it’s too late. Sometimes, that means pivoting away from a parent’s past, and inability to move beyond that. It means that parents have a responsibility to imbue their children with good values, but also that children have the responsibility to choose the correct path, regardless of what they inherit from their parents.
January 3, 2024 Hamas and Islamic Jihad Use Children for Terrorist Activities and Incitement
“Teach Your Children” is a call to action for passing on life lessons, compassion, and hope to future generations. It’s an important Father’s Day anthem. Hamas and their ideological siblings from Hezbollah, the Houthis, westerners hijacking private campuses and public spaces, and the ayatollahs of Iran, do the opposite. They offer no hope for the future, only hate that also dooms them. This Father’s Day, it’s important to reflect on our personal values as parents, rejecting the evil of extremist genocidal Islam, and making sure that we impart that to the next generation, loud and clear.
This horrific story of the father and son,Ahmed and Abdullah, reminds me of another less hopeful classic American folk-rock song, Harry Chapin’s 1974 hit, “Cats in the Cradle.” After a life of neglecting his son by having “lots to do,” the father realizes his neglect has come back to him, singing woefully, “My boy is just like me.”
This is the model by which Hamas and the Islamic terrorists live. It’s up to them, the fathers and mothers, to teach their children well, to have an active presence, to show them right from wrong, and to correct them when they go astray. It’s never a father’s role to teach a child to massacre, rape, sexually mutilate and murder, not for any reason.
Rather than worshiping an evil ideology and a god who they say celebrates that, maybe they would do better with a little 1960s classic folk-rock to change their future.
About the writer:
Jonathan Feldstein - President of the US based non-profit Genesis123 Foundation whose mission is to build bridges between Jews and Christians – is a freelance writer whose articles appear in The Jerusalem Post, Times of Israel, Townhall, NorthJersey.com, Algemeiner Jornal, The Jewish Press, major Christian websites and more.
While the mission of Lay of the Land (LotL) is to provide a wide and diverse perspective of affairs in Israel, the Middle East and the Jewish world, the opinions, beliefs and viewpoints expressed by its various writers are not necessarily ones of the owners and management of LOTL but of the writers themselves. LotL endeavours to the best of its ability to credit the use of all known photographs to the photographer and/or owner of such photographs (0&EO).
What has triggered global outrage at Israel’s response to 7 October?
By Rolene Marks
I call this war the “great illuminator”. Since the atrocities of the Hamas attack of 7 October, so much of what had been bubbling under the surface has now come out into the light. Many of us have lost lifelong friends who showed their lack of concern or blamed Israel, the antisemitism that many of us warned for years was fostering a climate of hate, has now been exposed to the world. The United Nations and their relevant “human rights” agencies like UNICEF and the UN Human Rights Council have demonstrated their lack or moral clarity. Do not get me started on the Red Cross and organisations that purport to support women and children.
No sooner had the horrific events happen, which the world watched on 7 October because gleeful Hamas broadcast it for all to see, the denials of the atrocities but also the celebrations began. Israel had not yet responded. So deep is the level of hatred for Jews and the Jewish state that the strange phenomenon of schizophrenic response is immediate. I have a theory why many denied the events that they just celebrated and watched like terror-porn quaffing lunatics. If they admit that they support those that carry out mass rape, burning of families alive, wholesale slaughter and torture and kidnapping, then they too, can be considered a monster. There are those who without apology and compunction, are happy to admit they support it because they see these monstrous actions as “resistance” or “justified”. These people walk amongst us.
There is the absolute outrage at Israel’s response. “The civilian casualties” they cry – while ignoring the empirical proof from many sources that proves that this is a war not only prosecuted with as much precision as possible, but the data gathering on casualty numbers has been proven to not make sense. The source of information to media is Hamas and even UNOCHA halved the numbers of women and children killed. The media earnestly gobbles up Hamas casualty figures while ignoring the glaring facts – and numerous military experts who say that at a veritable 1-1 civilian to combatant ratio, this is the war with the lowest casualty rate in the history of warfare.
So what is the real issue?
I believe it is the audacity of Israel daring to defend itself. Israel has a right to self-defence – in fact an OBLIGATION under international law to defend our citizens.
Over 80 years ago, the world closed its gates to the Jews fleeing the genocide in Europe. Today, most of the world breaks its moral compass by giving a tailwind to the terrorists and their various agents that are attempting to stop our inalienable right to defend ourselves. It is our audacity of self-defence that has the world up in arms – and not the atrocities that started this war we did not want.
The Book ‘People Love Dead Jews’ Is Meant to Make You Uneasy – “I’ve discovered that the uncomfortable moments are usually where the story is,” says author Dara Horn.
Many of us are watching events on campuses and in cities around the world in utter disbelief as many young people or “Gen Z”, fed on a steady diet of anti-West propaganda denounce the countries they were born in and shill for Hamas, Hezbollah and other terror organisations. I feel like we are living in a parallel universe when young people take to Tik-Tok, (where I believe brain cells go to die) to extol the virtues of Osama Bin-Laden. I wish I was joking but I am not. You can almost see the Ayatollah Al Khamenei himself taking a break from calling for the annihilation of the Jewish State on X to rub his hands in glee at how well the minions have drunk the Kool-Aid. Gen Z’ers would rather “glamp” on a nearby campus, masked up and demanding humanitarian aid than defend their countries if needed.
A YouGov survey in the showed:
The US did not fare differently. A Pew survey demonstrated:
I watched the exceptional veterans at the 80th D Day Anniversary commemorations earlier this month. The greatest generation. I marveled at the veterans, the eldest at 107, medals polished, with their dignified comportment. We owe them the gratitude of our freedom and democracy.
I am not shocked at the poll results in the United Kingdom and USA. Many (not all!) Gen Z’ers or the Tik-Tok generation have steadily been radicalized in their schools, universities and through social media. We are watching it in real time. They are taught to feel shame about their countries history and see everything through the prism of colonization, critical race theory and oppressor vs oppressed.
Israeli’s do not fit into any particular box of definitions and this confuses the paradigm. Israelis, no matter their age or background, religious or secular, left or right leaning, are patriotic. We are proud of our flag, we are proud to serve and we are proud of our national identity and history. This is an inconvenient truth for many of our detractors.
When I watched the D-Day commemorations, I wondered who could be remotely comparable to the brave men who stormed the beaches of Normandy on 6 June 1994, some of whom would liberate the death and concentration camps where our families and ancestors were murdered and imprisoned.
This generation of Israelis are worthy. They are the reservists who did not wait to be called up by the IDF to defend Israel in the wake of the Hamas attack who rushed to their bases or caught planes from the four corners of the world to fight. The fight with honour and with pride. While many of their compatriots around the world are looking for the nearest “safe space” on campus – they are busy fighting a brutal enemy that threatens our western values and liberties.
They are the exceptional courage of the survivors of the horrors and the former hostages who at great pain to their physical and mental health continue to share about their experience and advocate for the 120 hostages that remain in captivity.
They are the exceptional forces that rescued four of our hostages over the past weekend. In a mission that was rehearsed for weeks, with complexities that changed second by second, in a manner where daring and bravery ranks up there with the Entebbe mission. Instead of applauding Israel’s daring and bravery – the global media and many others, gobbled up the Hamas propaganda and castigated Israel for “massacring hundreds of Palestinians”. While Palestinian civilians, caught in the crossfire were killed, the number is yet to be confirmed. Can someone place the world back on its axis? Israel lost one of our finest warriors in the mission – Chief Inspector from the YAMAM, Arnon Zamora, of blessed memory. A lion of Judah. Like Yoni Netanyahu before him, Arnon will go down in the annals of Jewish history as one of the true kings of the battlefield. The rescue mission was named “Operation Arnon” in his honour.
Chief Inspector Arnon Zamora z”l.
Israel’s audacity to defend ourselves irks the world – and it is a loud reminder that we are the vanguard in the clash of civilizations and if they do not wake up, they are next. The future, like all the other issues mentioned in the beginning has been illuminated. Perhaps that is why the safest reaction is to criticize?
The lions of Judah neither slumber nor sleep, and the Jewish state, the embodiment of our ancient covenant, will do everything we can to survive. We will continue to fight. Long may we be audacious.
While the mission of Lay of the Land (LotL) is to provide a wide and diverse perspective of affairs in Israel, the Middle East and the Jewish world, the opinions, beliefs and viewpoints expressed by its various writers are not necessarily ones of the owners and management of LOTL but of the writers themselves. LotL endeavours to the best of its ability to credit the use of all known photographs to the photographer and/or owner of such photographs (0&EO).
Through selective reporting, maliciously misframing events and deviously giving disproportionate attention to select viewpoints, the media impacts public understanding and opinion.
By Allan Wolman
Media manipulation is not just a tool for attracting audiences; it is also frequently employed to promote specific editorial agendas and propagate particular viewpoints. This manipulation can be seen in the way some news outlets, like Al Jazeera, are perceived to politicize their content, often aligning with one side of a conflict or issue rather than maintaining impartiality.
For instance, Al Jazeera has been accused of bias in its coverage of Middle Eastern politics. This partisanship can shape public opinion and influence political discourse, both regionally and globally. By highlighting particular narratives, omitting counterarguments, or emphasizing certain events over others, media outlets can steer the public’s perception to align with their own ideological leanings or those of their stakeholders.
Inflaming instead of Reporting. Since the outbreak of the war on October 7, Al Jazeera switched to non-stop live coverage of what it calls “the Israeli aggression on Gaza,” even though it was Hamas that started the carnage by brutally massacring over 1,200 Israelis and kidnapping hundreds.
Such practices are not unique to Al Jazeera; many media organizations around the world have been accused of similar biases. Whether through selective reporting, framing stories in a particular light, or giving disproportionate attention to certain viewpoints, media manipulation can significantly affect public understanding and opinions. This underscores the importance of critical media consumption and the need for audiences to seek diverse sources of information to gain a more balanced perspective on global events.
The subtle use of language in media plays a crucial role in shaping public perception while maintaining an appearance of objectivity. This technique involves carefully selecting words and phrases that carry implicit connotations, which can influence how the audience interprets the information.
The choice between terms like “freedom fighters” and “terrorists” to describe a group involved in conflict can dramatically alter the audience’s perception of that group. Such linguistic choices are strategic, designed to project a particular meaning without overtly revealing the media outlet’s bias.
In the immediate aftermath of the dramatic rescue of four Israeli hostages from captivity in Gaza, Sky, CNN, together with other networks referred to the ‘release’ of the hostages. This subtle play on language misrepresents the situation. The hostages were not released from captivity but were ‘rescued’ in a daring and meticulously planned operation by the IDF.
BBC Bias. In a June 9,2024 interview, BBC’s news anchor, Helena Humphrey (left), asks former IDF spokesman Jonathan Conricus (right) why Israel didn’t warn Gazans before the rescue operation, leading Conricus to wonder “whether she was reading off a teleprompter or actually thought of the question herself.”
During a bizarre interview between BBC news anchor, Helena Humphrey and former IDF spokesman, Jonathan Conricus, Humphrey (with her mind fixated on Hamas’s claim that civilians were killed during the rescue raid that freed the hostages), astoundingly asked:
“Would there have been a warning to those civilians for them to get out on time?”
In framing this question, Humphrey deliberately ignored that the hostages were imprisoned within civilian homes.
The implication here is that the BBC expects – or even demands – that Israeli security forces should inform the enemy in advance of an imminent rescue operation, which would inevitably compromise the mission and potentially endanger the lives of the hostages!
Not only language, but numbers play crucial roles in media manipulation. The United Nations, which is openly critical and hostile towards Israel, recently revised its previous estimates based on information from the Hamas-run Gaza Ministry of Health.
Recent data published by the UN indicates a significant revision in the estimated number of women and children killed during the conflict in Gaza. In reports released on May 6 and 8, the UN seemingly halved its previous estimates. According to Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA), the revised reports show a decrease of almost 47% in the total number of women and children killed during the war. Additionally, the data now indicates that men aged 19-59 made up 40% of the fatalities, contradicting previous claims that 70% were women and children. Notably, there is no mention of Hamas fighters included in the casualties, and important to note that child soldiers are not only found in West Africa; they are found in other conflict zones, including Gaza.
Flawed Figures. While the casualty figures issued by the Hamas-run Gaza Health Ministry are known not only to be unreliable and deliberately false, the global media nevertheless quote them thus deliberately tarnishing Israel’s reputation.
The Washington Institute for Near East Policy released a report in January highlighting major discrepancies in the fatality reports, suggesting potential manipulation. This raises important questions about the reliability of information coming from conflict zones and the methods used to gather and report such data. Despite UN and other reliable sources, the mainstream media continue to quote casualty figures provided by the Hamas Health Authority – a highly questionable information source that they well know but nevertheless quote, deliberately spreading lies to discredit Israel, an age-old practice of antisemitism.
The rapid release of casualty numbers by Hamas authorities, raises questions about their accuracy and reliability. Shortly after the hostage rescue, CNN reported that at least 236 people had been killed and more than 400 injured, “according to hospital officials in Gaza.” The Associated Press published that 210 Palestinians, including children, were killed, “according to a Gaza health official.” It is puzzling how these numbers were gathered within mere hours and how distinctions between men, women, and children were reported with such precision!
At the same time European Union High Representative, Josep Borrell described the hostage operation carried out by Israeli security forces on Saturday morning (8 June) as “appalling”. Borrell referred to the operation as “another massacre of civilians,” noting that the EU “condemns this in the strongest terms.” This rapid condemnation and the reported casualty figures must surely raise questions.
Man with a Fixation. While antisemitism surging across Europe and Ukraine facing collapse under Putin’s aggression, EU foreign policy chief Josep Borrell appears far more focused on one issue – undermining Israel.
SUSPECT SOURSES
Reports from Israel reflect a vastly different casualty count from the rescue operation. This discrepancy exposes the dubious nature of the sources of information presented by different parties involved – a reflection of political agendas, prejudice and naked bias.
So, will the EU’s top diplomat Josep Borrel consider the credibility, context, and potential biases of the reports coming from Hamas authorities given previous discrepancies highlighted by the recent UN report?
Given the Spaniard’s transparent bias against Israel and the Jewish people – remember his diabolical accusation that Israel “uses hunger as a weapon of war” – don’t hold your breath.
About the writer:
Allan Wolman in 1967 joined 1200 young South Africans to volunteer to work on agricultural settlements in Israel during the Six Day War. After spending a year in Israel, he returned to South Africa where he met and married Jocelyn Lipschitz and would run one of the oldest travel agencies in Johannesburg – Rosebank Travel. He would also literally ‘run’ three times in the “Comrades”, one of the most grueling marathons in the world as well as participate in the “Argus” (Cape Town’s famed international annual cycling race) an impressive eight times. Allan and Jocelyn immigrated to Israel in 2019.
While the mission of Lay of the Land (LotL) is to provide a wide and diverse perspective of affairs in Israel, the Middle East and the Jewish world, the opinions, beliefs and viewpoints expressed by its various writers are not necessarily ones of the owners and management of LOTL but of the writers themselves. LotL endeavours to the best of its ability to credit the use of all known photographs to the photographer and/or owner of such photographs (0&EO).
With Israel’s northern settlements reduced to “ghost towns”, how long before daily skirmishes with Hezbollah escalate into a fully-fledged war?
By Rolene Marks
There is hardly a day that goes by without the ubiquitous beeping of incoming rockets or Unmanned Arial Vehicles (UAV) in Israel’s north. Israel’s northern border is under immense threat from Iranian sponsored proxy Hezbollah. While the world focuses attention on Israel’s military operations in Gaza following the atrocities committed by Hamas on 7 October, the north is heating up. Hezbollah started firing anti-tank missiles and rockets on Israeli homesteads and positions in the north on 8 October.
Israel Ablaze. How can evacuated residents of the north return when their cities like Kiryat Shmona (seen here) are under daily attack from Lebanon? ( Photo: AFP/Jalaa Marey)
Israel has long anticipated that should war break out on one front, it will inevitably break out on others as well. Israel is not only fighting Hamas in Gaza and Hezbollah in the north but is also dealing with increased tension in the West Bank, opportunistic Iranian attacks and the transfer of weapons from Syria, the Houthi threat in the Red Sea and rebels in Iraq firing projectiles at the Jewish state.
Hezbollah poses a significantly greater threat than Hamas. The Iranian proxy has unequivocally violated UN Resolution 1701, which clearly calls for Hezbollah to remain north of the Litani River. United Nations Interim Forces in Lebanon (UNIFIL) recently had their mandate extended – and yet have done nothing to rein in Hezbollah aggression.
Hezbollah is Hamas on steroids. Hezbollah’s equivalent of Hamas’s Nukba fighters known as the Radwan forces, are a lot more sophisticated and better trained and Hezbollah’s arsenal of rockets is estimated in excess of 160 000. These rockets, which are significantly more sophisticated than those fired by Hamas, have the entire state of Israel covered. It is a terrifying thought.
City under Smoke. Smoke and fire covers the area following rocket attacks from Lebanon, amid ongoing cross-border hostilities between Hezbollah and Israeli forces, near Kiryat Shmona, Israel, close to its border with Lebanon, June 3, 2024. REUTERS/Ayal Margolin
As the IDF evacuated southern communities in preparation for the military operation into Gaza, so northern communities evacuated as well. Towns and kibbutzim on the border are ghost towns and the impact of this on farms and the regional economy has been massive. Images coming in from Kiryat Shmoneh and Katzrin show massive destruction to property and the northern skyline is bright red and orange from fires. Civilians and soldiers killed from rockets and anti-Tank missiles – are facts the global community and media are silent about.
Lebanese residents in the south of the country have also been evacuated – and there an estimated 91,000 have fled their homes.
Hezbollah have fired thousands of rockets at Israeli positions, causing a massive amount of damage to hundreds of buildings and homes. They have caused widespread destruction on a wine farm and to chicken coops and set of massive fires across thousands of dunams of land. Hezbollah have also fired towards IDF military positions, and Ziv Medical Center in the northern Galilee city of Safed, sustained a direct hit.
Hospital Hit. The entrance to Safed’s Ziv Hospital that serves the residents of Safed, the Upper Galilee and the northern Golan Heights was struck by a rocket fired from southern Lebanon on February 14, 2024.
To date there have been no condemnations from the international community – but diplomatic efforts are underway to try prevent a widespread war from breaking out. Israel’s Defense Minister, Yoav Gallant has repeatedly warned Hezbollah not to test the Jewish state:
“The noses of our fighter jets are pointed north”.
Hezbollah is recognized as a terror organization by several countries and has been described as a “state within a state” having representation in the Lebanese government.
Najib Mikati, Prime Minister of the interim government in Lebanon, said the Lebanese government would continue working for a ceasefire in the Gaza Strip and the return the south Lebanese residents to their towns. He added that he was certain the ceasefire in the Gaza Strip would include the countries of the region and they would have “long-term stability and peace.”
Hezbollah is a proxy of Iran and are unlikely to take directive from the interim government. In response to escalating attacks on Israeli sovereign territory, Israel is striking Hezbollah targets, some as far into Lebanese territory as Baalbek, 265 km from the border.
Death in the North. In the barrage of 11 rockets fired from Lebanon on February 14, 2024, one of which struck Ziv Hospital in Safed, 20-year-old Staff Sgt. Omer Sarah Benjo, an observation soldier with a Combat Intelligence Collection unit, was killed on her base. (Photo : courtesy)
Despite rumoured cautions from Iran for Hezbollah not to enter into a full-scale war with Israel, there is growing concern that Israel will inevitably have to enter the south of Lebanon in order to push Hezbollah north of the Litani River in compliance with UN Resolution 1701. Israel wants quiet on its northern border and for residents to return to their homes. I am sure that Lebanese civilians want the same for their residents of the south. Let us hope Hezbollah want that as well but emboldened by Hamas invasion of Israel on 7 October and their sworn solidarity with their ideological brothers, it seems less likely by the day.
While the mission of Lay of the Land (LotL) is to provide a wide and diverse perspective of affairs in Israel, the Middle East and the Jewish world, the opinions, beliefs and viewpoints expressed by its various writers are not necessarily ones of the owners and management of LOTL but of the writers themselves. LotL endeavours to the best of its ability to credit the use of all known photographs to the photographer and/or owner of such photographs (0&EO).