A LOVE LETTER TO THE PEOPLE OF MY COUNTRY

These past 7 months have demonstrated that Israelis are extraordinary in so many ways.

By Rolene Marks

It has been over 7 months of agony. It feels like years. I do not remember life before 7 October – I do not think most people do either. There is 7/10 – and life before that, which is blurred and fuzzy. We are not the same people who went to sleep on 6 October. We never will be again. How could we be?

This year, the national holidays in Israel have a distinctly different tone. They are sacred days, filled with sorrow – and dread. Yom Hashoa (Holocaust Memorial Day) in the shadow of 7/10 was extremely poignant and difficult. The images of our brothers and sisters burnt to ash or herded onto the back of trucks and taken away as well as the raw, unbridled hatred that fueled the attack was reminiscent of the experiences of our ancestors – and family.

On 7 October, Hamas intended to terrorise. And they did. The trauma we have is so deep; it is at a cellular level. They came into the one safe haven of the Jewish people, our collective home and into our individual homes as families, and raped, mutilated, tortured, burnt, murdered and kidnapped. We thought it could never happen again – but it did.  We are so deep in our collective trauma that we have not even begun to emerge into post trauma but no sooner had the news broken, Israelis began to flex our well-toned resilience muscle. War and trauma are not new to Israelis or the Jewish people, but this time it was different. The level of depravity was beyond our comprehension – and many of us feel that we have been transported back in time, to the pogroms and persecution of our grandparents and great-grandparents.

We are now approaching two Days of Awe – Yom Hazikaron, Memorial Day for fallen soldiers and victims of terror – and Yom Ha’atzmaut, Independence Day. The two days take place one after the other so that we never forget the price we paid for what we have – a Jewish state. This year it is all the more emotional and heightened as we are fighting a war for our very survival – while antisemitism soars to astronomical levels.

Hamas made no distinction between any of us – left or right, religious or secular, Muslim, Christian, Jew, and foreign national – everyone was a target. Our answer to that, despite our differences, is to come together as a nation and focus on what is most important – supporting our bereaved families and families of hostages, demanding the immediate return of our hostages, ensuring the world does not forget what happened on 7/10 and standing behind our army.

In our grief, we each adopted a personal mission. Through our pain, we have each found a purpose and this article is my personal love letter to every single one of my exceptional fellow citizens and women. On 7 October, we experienced the worst of humanity. On 8 October, the best of Israel and the Jewish people trudged through their pain, shock and grief and rose to meet the challenges.

These Days of Awe, I want to express my profound love for my fellow citizens.

To the men, women and canines on air, sea, land, tunnels and airwaves, who are fighting not just for our survival, but for our very existence, there are not enough words to thank you. You are the best of us. You are our husbands and wives, sons and daughters, lovers, colleagues, friends and you are not just fighting for us, you are the vanguard in the clash between good and evil. We are proud of you, we stand by you and we know without any doubt that you adhere to the strictest moral and ethical code as you fight a monstrous entity that does not respect the laws of armed conflict, but instead uses their civilians as human shields. You can hold your head up high.

To our warriors, human and canine, who paid the ultimate price for our safety, your names will go down in the annals of our history, and we will honour you eternally. We will wrap our arms around your families. May your memories forever be blessed.

The 7th of October was the darkest day in Israel’s history, but it was also a day that ordinary people became superheroes. There were parents who drove down south to rescue their children in the carnage, risking their lives and saving many. Noam Tibon, a retired IDF General, and his wife got into their car and headed straight to Nahal Oz to help rescue his son and his family, trapped in their safe room.  Tibon and his wife would not only rescue injured soldiers, shepherding them to safety, but Noam engaged in combat with terrorists before managing to free his family. Civilians like Yusuf Marhat, a Bedouin bus driver who transported revelers to the Nova festival and then drove towards the carnage to rescue as many as possible. He saved many lives that dark day. Aner Shapira was amongst a group of people hiding in a shelter when Hamas opened fire on them and threw grenades in. Video footage shows Shapira throwing at least 7 grenades out before he was eventually killed. His best friend Hersch Goldberg Polin was taken as a hostage and remains in captivity. These are just a few of the many who drew superhuman strength to save as many lives as they could.

To every first responder who ran into the danger, we salute you. It was the call centre operators who took those first calls from terrified kibbutz residents. I keep thinking of the operator who took the distressed call of Avigail Idan’s siblings, who saw their parents murdered and did not know where their baby sister was. The siblings hid in a cupboard where their mother Smadar had safely hidden them before she was murdered. The operator told them to hide there “till the good people come”. Images of Jewish children hiding in cupboards from killers takes us back to that darkest time in our history. The remarkable first responders from Magen David Adom, firefighters, United Hatzalah, Zaka, IDF soldiers, doctors, nurses, police and all who ran into the gates of hell went above and beyond the call of duty. They were nothing less than magnificent.

The attacks of October 7 left many orphans. Statistics estimate 119 children who lost either one or more parents. Breastfeeding mothers rushed to donate their breast milk so that our smallest and most vulnerable treasures would receive sustenance. This is love in a profound time of sorrow.

The Beautiful Israel.  Young kids making sandwiches for soldiers who may be their fathers or mothers defending their country in the north and the south.

To the volunteers, near and far, who are diligently picking fruit and vegetables, thank you! You are helping to feed a country who faces the real threat of a lack of food security. Many of the agricultural workers who came from Thailand, Nepal and other countries returned to their countries in the wake of 7/10, leaving farms without labourers. Israelis sprang into action, making sure cows were milked, fruit, vegetable picked, and that the farms that form the country’s food belt have continued to function. Volunteers have been streaming in around from around the world to help – including a team of cowboys from the USA.  It has been an incredible show of love and solidarity.

Stepping up to the Plate. Braving warm smiles on faces traumatized by national tragedy, Israelis preparing food for their soldiers.

To my colleagues who are journalists or are in the field of public diplomacy – we are tasked with bearing witness, recording history and testimony and sharing it with the world. It has been at times, an agonizing task. We have had to see the images and footage from the atrocities that are unfathomable in their cruelty. We have had to see them again and again in order to ensure the story is told, the atrocities not denied or forgotten. It takes a massive toll. We will continue to speak.

To the lawyers who are defending Israel in the international courts against libelous accusations of genocide – some heroes really do wear capes. In this case, robes. You are our legal heroes in your robes, presenting Israel’s case with alacrity, dignity and forensic detail, compiling case after case that easily disproves the accusation of genocide. You have had to pore over the evidence of a true genocide, the atrocities of 7 October, in all of its savage imagery. This is unbearable but proves without a doubt who the perpetrators are – Hamas.  

To my sisters, the Zionesses roaring on behalf of our mothers, sisters and daughters who no longer have a voice, who were raped and tortured and then violated again by feminists and women’s organisations who not only denied the violence they endured, but built a wall of silence. We, the women of Israel, will tear down that wall by speaking up. We will not be silenced.


Country United. As they say an army marches on its stomach, it didn’t take long for Israel’s restaurants to get into the kitchen to feed their heroes. Within days of the war began following the massacre of October 7, even Israel’s top restaurants rallied to provide food for the soldiers.

Someone once said that an army marches on its stomach. The IDF must be the most well-fed army in in the world. Israelis and volunteers from abroad have been packing food parcels, donating, hosting barbeques on the border and ensuring that the army that defends its nation, eats well. Restaurant owners have koshered their restaurants to ensure that all food meets religious requirement and no soldiers is excluded from enjoying a delicious meal.  Druze women and restaurant owners have closed their restaurants to the public and are catering solely to soldiers. When they open to the public again, we will support them in our masses.


What’s Cooking? In wartime Israel, everyone does their part – even if that means cooking dinner in a parking garage. Seen here at the Keshet school in Jerusalem’s Katamon neighborhood, are student volunteers in their school’s parking garage, which also is functioning as a makeshift kitchen feeding as many as 300 people per day.(Photo by Neil Weinberg)
 

To the hostages – our brothers and sisters held in torturous conditions, and those who have been released – no amount of words do justice to explain your courage and your dignity.  Former hostages who have bravely shared about their horrific experience have done so with the greatest dignity and continue to fight for the 132 that remain captive. The stories are shattering – torture, starvation, systematic sexual abuse and more accounts that speak of unfathomable trauma. We will not stop until every single one of you is back.

The people who have vowed to rebuild their devastated communities and kibbutzim, you are the beacon of hope, of resilience. You remind us of what we have, what we cherish and what our commitment is.


Seniors in the ‘Service’. Volunteers sort donated resources for Israelis displaced by the October 7 attacks and Israel-Hamas war. (Photo: Foni Mesika)

Young people who have risen to the challenge. You are more than our greatest hope, you have more than proven our future is radiantly bright – you light the way. You have shown up in our darkest moment in the most magnificent way and while we look around the world at the chaos on campuses and in marches, alarmed at how the young and more often than not, gullible have been radicalized, we do not fear for the future of Israel. You are our future. You are the generation that will go down in the annals of history as one of our greatest. I believe that.

To you who has gone above and beyond and who I may not have mentioned, thank you. To every single one of us, navigating our own trauma and pain, but showing up, every single day, there is no greater love than the love we have for each other.

Every single one of us. Am Yisrael Chai!







THE ISRAEL BRIEF- 06-09 May 2024

The Israel Brief – 06 May 2024 Yom Hashoa. Evacuation of Rafah. Al Jazeera shuttered. Situation in the north.



The Israel Brief – 07 May 2024 Was there a ceasefire? Protest at Auschwitz. Shin Bet chief in Malmo. 13 Federal judges refuse to hire protestors. 



The Israel Brief – 08 May 2024 Rafah update. Hostage deal update. Hostage confirmed murdered. Biden condemns antisemitism. 



The Israel Brief – 09 May 2024 Betrayal from an ally? KAN complains after Eden booed. Noa Marciano z”l. Hostage talks continue. 






THE HOPE AND HOPELESSNESS OF HOLOCAUST MEMORIAL DAY

The 2-minute siren is always shocking; this year it felt worse being 7 months since the Hamas massacre of October 7

By Jonathan Feldstein

I didn’t expect today would be such an emotional roller coaster, nor to take time writing about it.  For decades, Israel and the Jewish people have observed Yom HaShoah (Holocaust Memorial Day), in solemn remembrance of the six million Jews murdered during the Holocaust. In recent years it’s become much more common for Christians to join these commemorations, either with Jewish communities where they live, on their own, or by through Israel’s nationwide observance.

In no year since the Holocaust have the Jewish people felt so hopeless and, in many cases, standing alone. In no year since the Holocaust has Israel been at war with an existential enemy rooted in extremist Islam, while observing this solemn day.  In no year since the Holocaust have the Jewish people felt so physically threatened around the world, and on campuses of what used to be elite academic institutions that have now become incubators of Jew-hatred.

Holocaust Memorial Day in Israel is marked by dozens of public ceremonies broadcast nationally.  There are thousands of memorial events in schools, community centers, synagogues, and private homes. TV and radio programming pivots almost entirely about the stories of Holocaust survivors.  At 10:00 am, a siren is sounded for two minutes, all over the country. People stop what they are doing, even get out of cars and buses, standing in silent attention and prayer. This is what it looks and sounds like in the Judean mountains south of Jerusalem. In cities it’s even more vivid.

The day is not over and yet it’s been an emotional roller coaster. I know that dozens of my relatives were murdered, some of whose pictures we have and stories we know. It’s personal. Never in their abruptly shortened lives could they have imagined that several decades since they were shot or gassed that their relatives would be living in the reborn State of Israel, where Jewish sovereignty has been restored after nearly 2000 years of exile.

It was surreal that while watching the emotional story of one of Israel’s retired Supreme Court justices recounting his survival, he was interrupted by the Breaking News of three soldiers who were killed when terrorists in Gaza, attacked the main “Kerem Shalom” crossing into Gaza through which hundreds of truckloads of humanitarian supplies enter Gaza daily. The soldiers killed were guarding the crossing and the humanitarian convoys so Gazans could have food, medical supplies, and more. A fourth soldier succumbed to his wounds the next day.

It is true that six million Jews were murdered in the Holocaust because the world was largely indifferent, and we did not have a state or army to protect ourselves. It’s still true that evil Islamic terrorists want to ‘complete the job of the Nazis’ and kill the rest of us. Today however we have an army to defend ourselves, but the price is high.

Sights and Sounds of Sorrow. Israeli President Isaac Herzog captured the complex emotions of his people when addressing the opening ceremony for Holocaust Martyrs’ and Heroes’ Remembrance Day, when he said: “….Throughout the decades that have passed since the Holocaust, we assured time after time: “Never again”, and we swore that the Jewish people would never again stand defenseless and unprotected. And yet, despite all that, the horrors of the Holocaust shook us all during the October massacres, echoing in all our hearts.” (Photo: GPO/Kobi Gideon)

The world doesn’t seem to care so much about dead Jews whether gassed in Poland, incinerated in Israel, or guarding humanitarian supplies, as long as we keep sending humanitarian aid to the Gazans no matter the cost, or how it emboldens our enemies. Dead Jews are only breaking news in Israel where they are our sons, daughters, mothers, fathers, neighbors, co-workers, and teachers.

Even if we’re sitting anticipating it, the two-minute siren is always piercing. Shocking. Most years, I have stood silently, thinking of my great grandparents and their children, grandchildren, and extended families and entire communities which were purged and where today not a living Jew remains. I try to imagine how helpless they were, younger then than I am now, and unable to protect their family. I try to imagine myself in their shoes. The very thought is painful.

No, we’re not helpless. We have a State and an army, and we do have allies, if not always reliable countries that stand with us morally and unconditionally. We at least have tens of millions of Christians across the globe who do. Despite the recent horrors, grief, trauma, and more, we remain resilient. Unlike our enemies who want to destroy us, we are still building the country whose 76th year of independence we will celebrate next week.

Down but not Out. Israel took a blow on October 7 but the people behind it are taking a bigger blow. Israel’s “People’s Army”, which is both a reflection of the society and the glue that binds the people together will ensure there will never be another Holocaust.

A friend attended one of the Holocaust Memorial Day official state ceremonies and shared how she did so with trepidation. She was afraid it would just add to the trauma compounded since October 7. But instead reported that she left encouraged, strengthened. One of the survivors who spoke said “Don’t despair, never give up hope.” One survivor went on to serve in the IDF, then was captured and taken prisoner by the Syrians. Yet there he was, surviving a genocide and captivity by an Arab enemy.

Honestly, it’s easy to get lost in the loss, in the grief, in the trauma, praying for hostages to be released, and for the war to end and our enemies defeated. But even on a day like today, we have abundant reasons for hope, for believing in a better tomorrow.



About the writer:

Jonathan Feldstein ­­­­- President of the US based non-profit Genesis123 Foundation whose mission is to build bridges between Jews and Christians – is a freelance writer whose articles appear in The Jerusalem Post, Times of Israel, Townhall, NorthJersey.com, Algemeiner Jornal, The Jewish Press, major Christian websites and more.





WHO GUARDS THE GUARDIAN?

The discredited UN resolution “Zionism is Racism” has by way of mutating antisemitism, morphed into “Zionism is Colonialism”.

By Lawrence Nowosenetz

Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?

(Juvenal)

This age-old political question was posed by a Roman poet in the first to second century – “Who guards the guardians?” The promotional spin on the Guardian web site says:

  “Millions turn to the Guardian every day for fearless independent journalism”.

Clearly that does not apply to the opinion columns of the Guardian which should be billed as:

 “Millions of benighted misinformed ignoramuses turn to the Guardian for ideologically driven misleading bigoted opinion masquerading as legitimate journalism”.

We need only look at the opinion piece published by the Guardian (Wed 24 April 2024) entitled “We Need an Exodus from Zionism” by Naomi Klein to wonder at the mendacity and sophistry of the self-described ecofeminist.  Certainly, she lacks credentials at the very least in Jewish history, international law and rigorous journalism to back her outrageous claims.  Let’s look at some of them.

Be on ‘Guard’. Naomi Klein’s anti-Israel credentials as a journalist for the Guardian are self-evident with such lines like “We need an exodus from Zionism,” and “This Passover, we don’t need or want the false idol of Zionism. We want freedom from the project that commits genocide in our name.”

“This Passover, we don’t need or want the false idol of Zionism. We want freedom from the project that commits genocide in our name”.

A false idol?  Modern political Zionism has its roots in Jewish religion and history. In one fell swoop, the writer, presumably Jewish, has trashed a basic tenet of Judaism – the spiritual centrality of Zion. The Amidah, the standing prayer recited three times a day, is recited facing Jerusalem (Zion). She has the effrontery to say:

 “Zionism is a false idol that has betrayed every Jewish value, including the value we place on questioning…”.

The real question is what kind of Judaism does she profess?  A disembowelled distorted and twisted Zionless version? Judaism in the world according to Ms Klein has been something akin to being hijacked by Zionism. George Orwell could not have produced a more laughable parody. Jewish and Zionist thought has always been subject to rigorous debate and dissent.  Jews are highly self-critical and within Zionist ranks there have always been diverse opinions, Religious Zionists, socialists, and many other shades of opinion. An intoxicated mindless herd mentality is anathema to Jewish tradition.        

She goes on to say:

They are enraptured by it. Drunk on it. Profaned by it

Hyperbolic and melodramatic in equal measure to its falsity and absurdity. Any detached observer needs only to stand on the streets of major Western cities or on the campuses of the top US universities to notice the violent, aggressive and threatening pro-Palestinian protestors abusing all basic standards of civility and peacefulness. We are witnessing the most uncontrolled pubic disorder and chaos by anti-Israel protestors where the law enforcement authorities shave been mostly impotent to contain them. The pro-Israel supporters have been law abiding peaceful and respectful of others. If anyone is – in Naomi Klein’s words – “enraptured”, “drunk” or “profaned”, it is the disruptive, screaming and aggressive Hamas fans and the supporters of Palestine chanting murderous slogans such as “Death to Israel”, “Death to the Jews”, “Intifada now” and engaging in other inciteful and hateful conduct.  This of course falls outside the radar of this self-righteous peddler of Zionist hatred and libel.  

Calculating Columnist. With no care for Israel to be in a position to have the means to protect itself, Guardian’s US columnist, Naomi Klein calls for the US to stop arming Israel at a demonstration in Brooklyn, New York, on 23 April.  (Photo: Kena Betancur/AFP/Getty Images)

She describes Zionism as “a project”. This is a gross trivialisation of the historic national and spiritual modern liberation movement of the Jewish people. A quest to achieve statehood and sovereignty.  A profound historic movement which enjoys the support of many non-Jews and of course is backed by international law which affirms the right of national self-determination. Describing Zionism as a project can only be intended by the writer to demean and belittle what is recognised by international law a fully-fledged and long awaited right.     

Risible too, is her claim of genocide, particularly fashionable with reference to the current war in Gaza. In a recent clarification by Joan O’Donoghue, President of the International Court of Justice (ICJ) when it made its Provisional Measures Order in the case brought by South Africa against Israel alleging genocide, she confirmed that the ICJ did NOT decide that a plausible case of genocide had been made. The meaning of the ruling is widely misunderstood. It relates rather to the jurisdiction of the court to hear the case and make an interim or procedural directive that “the Palestinians had a plausible right to be protected from genocide” and that “South Africa had a right to present that in the court.” Such a finding is not definitive or of a final nature and the ultimate determination of the issue of the existence of genocide will only be made at the final hearing of the ICJ at some undetermined future date.

The refined legal reasoning of the ICJ is far more authoritative that the ill-informed, emotive opinions of Ms Klein.  She omits to mention at all the sober and objective assessments of the conduct of the IDF in Gaza by qualified military experts Col Richard Kemp (UK) or Major John Spencer (USA). They   consider that the IDF has taken unsurpassed measures in urban warfare to avoid random and unnecessary civilian deaths. These include warning civilians of aerial attacks and urging them to evacuate to places of safety. The IDF has surpassed the standards of other armies in the world and have achieved a historically low ratio of civilian casualties to armed belligerent deaths.  Hamas claims 33 000 deaths in Gaza of which Israel has accounted for 13 000 of them being combatants. In percentage terms 1.52 % of Gazans have been killed while the civilian component is 0,92%. The civilian to combatant death ratio in Gaza is 1.54: 1.  These figures are far lower than killings in other urban conflicts.

In known genocides historically, the percentage of deaths in relation to the population are as follows:

Armenian genocide in World War 1 – 80%

The Jewish people in World War II – 67%

The Tutsis in Rwanda in 1994 – 85%

(Source: The Jerusalem Post 26 April 2024 – The Death of Genocide by Eugene Korn)

There is simply no basis for an inference from the number of civilian deaths caused by the IDF bombing in Gaza that a systematic programme of ethnic cleansing is being conducted.  Mass killing does not automatically constitute genocide.   

It escapes Ms Klein that the claimed high number of children killed raises the question why no provision was made to protect civilians from the bombing of buildings in Gaza. This war is far from the first in which Gaza has faced aerial bombardment. Hamas as the governing authority in Gaza should surely have foreseen this and provided shelter or places safety for civilians. There certainly was no shortage of underground shelter in the maze of tunnels built by Hamas. Ms Klein and others of her ilk give Hamas a free pass despite the shocking disregard for the safety of the children of Gaza.  Some (not all) Gazans support Hamas and must take responsibility for the harm which has befallen their children. Children may be innocent but their parents are not. How many Gazans protested the atrocities committed by Hamas on 7 October 2023?    Not many it seems.        

While it is no simple matter making a finding of genocide, it is far easier to demonise and accuse Israel of all kinds of atrocities, including child killings. It is simply absurd to accuse Israel for the deliberate killing of children.  How do military commanders know which buildings to bomb for the express purpose of killing children?  It takes a really determined hater of Israel to justify such implausible claims!   

The significant requirement of intent to commit mass destruction of life in Gaza is overlooked. A crucial requirement for proving genocide is the criminal intent or mens rea as lawyers call it. The South African case in the ICJ attempted to show genocidal intent by quoting emotive rhetoric of leaders in Israel shortly after the 7 October Hamas atrocities.  Even these enraged statements fall far short of any official plan or policy of ethnic cleansing in Gaza.  The government and its military policy are very clear which has always been to conduct war against Hamas, destroy it and rescue the hostages all within the internationally recognised right of self-defence.      

Nor do the known genocides and atrocities of recent times in places like Syrian, Myanmar, Yemen and Sudan seem to merit the concern of Ms Klein. Rape, starvation and deaths in far greater numbers are happening there. Could it be that the perpetrators are not Zionists and thus falls outside her purview as a questioning Jew?  

She says that the story of Passover itself has turned –

“…into brutalist weapons of colonial land theft, roadmaps for ethnic cleansing and genocide”.

The crude use of the term “brutalist” betrays her ignorance. Brutalism is more commonly used to describe a style of architecture rather than a form of political oppression. But that is a minor concern. Her effortless leap of logic from the liberation of the Israelites from slavery in Egypt to Zionist crimes against humanity is breathtaking in its disingenuity and falsehood.    Colonial land theft and ethnic cleansing are the stock-in-trade of the anti-Israel and BDS groups. The discredited UN resolution “Zionism is Racism” which was revoked in 1991 by the General Assembly in 1991 has morphed into “Zionism is Colonialism”.    

Peddling False Platitudes. While Zionists came to a country with which they had a long-standing connection and history to re-achieve self-determination, Naomi Klein presents Israel as a settler-colonialist entity and Zionists as land-grabbers as reflected in such slogan signs (above) seen at most pro-Palestinian/anti-Israel rallies.

Contrary to Zionism being colonial, it the opposite. The story of Passover is the inspiration for the re-establishment and creation of the Jewish state: The reconstitution of the Jewish people in their historic home. Zionists fought colonialism from Roman times to the British Mandatory era. What a perversion of history to label Zionism as colonial.  An indigenous people cannot be a coloniser. Clearly Ms Klein has no difficulty with this inherent contradiction.      

Zionism’s version of liberation” she claims ‘required the mass expulsion of Palestinians from their homes and ancestral lands in the Nakba”.  

A conspiracy theory with no historical justification.  No part of Zionism is based on ethnic cleansing and the Declaration of Independence of the State of Israel is a clear manifesto of the recognition of rights for all inhabitants who dwell within Israel.  This can be contrasted with the Hamas Charter and recent utterances which indeed live up to Ms Klein’s claim of ethnic cleansing but in reverse:  Islamic annihilation of the Jews in Israel. This egregious and uncontested truth seems to not diminish the anti-Zionist fervour of Ms Klein.  Ethnic cleansing of the Jews was the aspiration of the Palestinians and Israel’s neighbouring Arab states long before the existence of Hamas.  The Palestinians (i.e. Arab residents of present Israel) began attacking Jews immediately after the United Nations Partition Resolution was announced in 1947. Some (not all) supported the Arab armies’ invasion of Israel after the Declaration of Independence of Israel in 1948. It was declared to be a war of annihilation of the Jewish State – a totally illegal and unjust war in international law. It would behove Ms Klein to face the inconvenient truth that ethnic cleansing is still the calling card of Hamas and its supporters which includes a large part of the Palestinian population.

A Call for Genocide of Jews. Has Naomi Klein ever read the Hamas Charter? A Palestinian member of Hamas holds an Arabic copy of its charter highlighting the sentence that reads “When our enemies usurp some Islamic lands, Jihad becomes a duty binding on all Muslims. In order to face the usurping of Palestine by the Jews, we have no escape from raising the banner of Jihad.” (Photo by Abid Katib/Getty Images)

There was never a Zionist liberation ideology or master plan to drive out the Palestinians en masse.  In the 1948 War of Independence, Palestinians were either driven from their homes or fled as their towns were conquered by Israel. Those that stayed have never been subjected to any form of mass eviction.   Something that seems to escape the defective narrative of Ms Klein. It bears mentioning that when the Eastern Jews had to flee the Arab and Moslem lands in the wake of the 1948 war, no special United Nations refugee agency was created to assist them as UNRWA did and still does, 75 years later for the Palestinians.    

How does Ms Klein arrive at such contrived hogwash as:

Zionism is a false idol that equates Jewish freedom with cluster bombs that kill and maim Palestinian children”.

What a bizarre juxtaposition of Zionism and cluster bombs! There is no evidence at all of cluster bombs being used by the IDF to kill and main Palestinian children. Cluster bombs were used by the IDF in Lebanon in 1982 and 2006 but since the 2008 international treaty signed in Oslo which banned the use of cluster munitions, Israel has complied. Equating Zionism with the false use of illegal weapons on Palestinian children is reckless and dishonest journalism.  

Another howler of Ms Klein is her:

Our Judaism cannot be contained by an ethnostate, for our Judaism is internationalist by nature.” 

Wrong on all counts. Judaism is both particularistic and universalistic.  Laws such as kosher observance by way of example are particularistic as being unique to Jews and no other religion or nation. However, the moral laws of Judaism such as the idea of freedom, kindness, basic criminal law, equality of man, charity and more are universal.  Judaism is internationalist in the sense that prayer and religious observance may be performed anywhere in the world. However, that does not detract from the spiritual centrality of Zion; the ideal of national redemption in the land Israel as promised by G-d to our forefathers.

The Jewish people today is a nation rather than an ethnic group.    Modern Israel consists of Jews of many ethnicities as well of course other nationalities and religions.  If Israel is an ethnostate, so too does the entire Arab Moslem Middle East and, parts of North Africa consist of ethnostates. Indeed, the Palestinian Constitution provides that it is a state for Arab Palestinians and Islam is the official religion.

The Guardian is in dire need of quality control for the material it accepts for its opinion columns. The platitude that everyone is entitled to their own opinion is indeed true but misses the point. Readers should not have to be “guarded” against by having shallow, ill-informed, irrational, bigoted and malevolent opinions fostered on them by honourable newspapers such as the Guardian. We expect better from the Guardian.

Hence, I ask:

Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?


                               

About the writer:

Now retired, Pretoria-born human rights and labour lawyer, Lawrence Nowosenetz practiced at the Pretoria and Johannesburg Bar. Recipient of a Fulbright Scholarship, Nowosenetz completed an internship in the USA and served as a part-time Senior Commissioner at the Commission for Conciliation Mediation and Arbitration (CCMA) as well as a panellist at Tokiso Dispute Settlement – the largest private dispute resolution provider in South Africa. He has also served as an Acting Judge of the Hight Court, South Africa.  






While the mission of Lay of the Land (LotL) is to provide a wide and diverse perspective of affairs in Israel, the Middle East and the Jewish world, the opinions, beliefs and viewpoints expressed by its various writers are not necessarily ones of the owners and management of LOTL but of the writers themselves.  LotL endeavours to the best of its ability to credit the use of all known photographs to the photographer and/or owner of such photographs (0&EO).

    

BENEATH THE VENEER

October 7 exposes the ‘true colours’ of people’s hate against Jews worldwide

By David E. Kaplan

True Colours. After six months of restoration work removing layers of varnish and grime at the Louvre Museum in Paris, “La Liberté guidant le peuple, 1830” by Eugene Delacroix is available to be viewed in all its true colours. (Photo: Sarah Meyssonnier/Reuters)

Charcterised by a bold bare-chested woman leading French revolutionaries, the six months painstakingly restored Delacroix revealed last week its – true colours.

Watching this report on a TV news channel while exercising on my stationary bike, the metaphor was not lost on me. If the ‘true colours’ of La Liberté guidant le peuple was finally revealed following the removal of decades of varnish and grime, then the rest of the news of mass protests revealed the ‘true colours’ of people’s feelings towards Jews.

What vanished this varnish was Oct. 7!

Beneath the veneer of accumulated guilt in the wake of the Shoah was suddenly ripped away by the Stormtroopers from Gaza. Suddenly, there were no longer any constraints. If it was unfashionable to be antisemitic in the post Holocaust years, Hamas brought it back into fashion. From across Europe to the elitist Ivy League campuses in the USA, antisemitism is once again in vogue.  Jews are uncomfortable or feeling “unsafe” on campuses; families in California are removing mezuzahs (encased scrolls) from their front doors, and Jews are ridiculed and violently threatened in public. It is no safer in Canada. In Edmonton, South African friends of my brother who have been living there for over 40 years reveal:

 “Our rabbi is leaving; he is emigrating to Israel and Jews are removing their mezuzahs from their front doors.”

From one end of Europe to the Other. A demonstration in Rome – antisemitism is spiking across Europe after Hamas’ October 7 massacre, worrying Jews from London to Geneva and Berlin. (AP Photo/Andrew Medichini, File)
 

We should not be surprised from the country, whose response by a high-level Canadian government official when asked how many Jews should be accepted into the country during the time of the Nazi persecution was:

 “None is too many

As recent as 2019, the Edmonton Journal ran a cartoon of a hacker in a wallet with a black beard and a large nose reminiscent of antisemitic caricatures of Jews.

With antisemitic hate crimes in Canada rising by 182 % between 2015 and 2022 according to the Integrated Terrorism Assessment Centre, Hamas can be credited to a massive jump since its attack on Israel on Oct 7, 2023.

The situation in the US is much worse. Writing in The Jerusalem Post, Howard Blast from New Haven, Connecticut, USA reveals on a recent visit for his yearly health checkup being asked by his doctor’s non-Jewish partner:

 “Don’t you usually wear a small hat on your head?”

Quickly realizing she was referring to the knitted kippah she was accustomed to seeing him wear, he replied:

You have a good memory. I usually wear a yarmulka on my head. To tell you the truth, these days, I really don’t feel safe. I now wear a baseball cap.

Now Howard’s kippah remains in his pocket, out of sight only to be worn when it is “safe”.

A Cover Up. After wearing a kippah for decades, Howard Blass from Connecticut has decided in the wake of October 7 to not walk outside in America wearing a kippah. ‘FOR NOW, I only wear a baseball hat.”

Today, it is no longer “safe” for Jews in countries from Belgium to the US, Brazil to South Africa, and Italy to Australia according to a recently released report on global antisemitism for 2023 by researchers at Tel Aviv University (TAU) and Anti-Defamation League (ADL). This too should come as no surprise. However, if the report cautions “concern” for the “future of Jewish life around the world” based on what transpired in 2023, then what has subsequently befallen Jews in 2024, the current level of “concern” might soon be reset to “panic”.

And no Jew is spared; celebrity status offers little protection. While Amy Schumer was busy this March during a shoot in Brooklyn of her latest movie ‘Kinda Pregnant’, in which she plays a woman who pretends to be pregnant to get attention, she does receive “attention” but not the type in the movie script. A passerby interrupted one of the scenes and yelled at her:

Fuck you, Amy Schumer! You’re a Zionist You love genocide!

Not only are Jews celebrities being accosted but also non-Jewish actors and for failing to publicly criticise Israel. Last month, actor Alec Baldwin was aggressively confronted at a New York coffee shop by an anti-Israel protester who repeatedly demanded that he say “Free Palestine.” Alec would have none of it but the protestor persisted.

Alec can you please say ‘Free Palestine’ one time? Free Palestine, Alec, just one time, and I’ll leave you alone. I’ll leave you alone, I swear.”

Her conduct then morphed into the ugly with:

 “Fuck Israel, fuck Zionism,” please say it.”

Baldwin finally knocked the camera out of her hand.

The level of hate against Jews is now so intense that no place is sacrosanct – even Auschwitz!

Earlier this month, a video was posted on X showing footage of a Palestinian man visiting the Auschwitz-Birkenau Holocaust Memorial Museum, where he called on Jews to return to the site of the extermination camp, a place he claimed is “where they belong.” Footage of the man can be seen walking through the Auschwitz memorial, calling to free Palestine.  

Life Changing. American Melissa Franklin always decorated her home for Hanukkah – proudly hanging a Star of David on her porch and placing her family’s menorah in the front window. No more. Franklin said the surge in antisemitism has made her feel uncomfortable making any public display of her Jewish identity or support for Israel.

From these ghettos from which the Zionists came, I say Allah have mercy on all the Palestinians and our martyrs. Free Palestine.” Such was this Palestinian’s message from Auschwitz!

Make no mistake, his calling from the world’s worst extermination site in history, would find resonance with many of the protestors in the US. This was born out when the news broke three weeks ago that Iran had launched 300 missiles targeting Israeli civilians, crowds at anti-Israel rallies across North America erupted into cheers and celebration. The veneer was removed and the “true colours” of many of the protestors were chillingly revealed.

Prof. Uriya Shavit, who heads the Center for the Study of Contemporary European Jewry and the Irwin Cotler Institute, warns that while “The year is not 1938, not even 1933,” if current trends continue:

“… the curtain will descend on the ability to lead Jewish lives in the West – to wear a Star of David, attend synagogues and community centers, send kids to Jewish schools, frequent a Jewish club on campus, or speak Hebrew. We are concerned that the curtain will descend on Jewish life in the West.” 

Sound Familiar? Reminiscent of Holocaust identification, Stars of David are seen graffitied onto French homes in this TV broadcast screenshot.(photo credit: Screenshot BFMTV)

WAR AND REMBERENCE

All this came into focus when watching last night the Yom HaShoah (Holocaust Remembrance Day) ceremony at Yad Vashem. Lighting one of the six candles commemorating the 6 million Jews murdered, a survivor of the Holocaust recalls how he finally made his way to Palestine only to be captured by the British and interned in Cyprus before finally making it to the newly declared state of Israel. There “I immediately joined the new Israeli army and I was given a number – a number I was proud of; not the Auschwitz number I had tattooed on my arm but a military number of belonging to the IDF.”

These are the NUMBERS that will assure “Never Again”.

What has befallen Israel and Jews across the world, we are reminded of the need for not only an Israel but a strong Israel.  

Trepidation at Trafalgar. The fallout from Oct.7 ripples through Europe, shaking a continent all too familiar with deadly anti-Jewish hatred. The fear is captured by this Jew holding up a placard saying ‘End Jew Hatred’ during a rally at Trafalgar Square, London, on October 22, 2023. (AP Photo/Frank Augstein, File)

While I would not normally subscribe to the philosophy of Niccolo Machiavelli, Hamas has made me make an exception. While the world criticizes Israel for the way it is prosecuting the war in Gaza, I say since October 7 and my understanding of a world that has little love of Israel:

It is better to be feared than to be loved.”





IT IS TIME FOR JEWS TO DIVEST

Jewish donors have given generously to universities – perhaps it is time to rethink that.

By Rolene Marks

The title of this article grabbed your attention, didn’t it? Some of you may have thought I was meaning divest from Israel. Perish the thought! Phtew phtew! The threat of divestment has been held like a sword of Damocles over Israel and companies that invest in Israeli interests in anyway. A whole movement has sprung up around it and nowhere has this been more evident in its true intentions than what we are witnessing on campuses across the USA. Not to be alarmist, but what starts in the US often spreads across the world.

College Chaos. Posts promoting the “Popular University for Gaza” initiative posted on social media by National Students for Justice in Palestine (SJP)

Looking at images of the matching tents and how well organized and planned these protests and “encampments” are, one has to wonder, who is sponsoring them? How many of these protesters are even students? A large percentage of protesters are also faculty, which proves the point that many of us have been warning about for years. The university education systems has been financed and infiltrated by bad agents, seeking to spread their ideology to future policy makers.

Watch and read more about it here:

https://isgap.org/follow-the-money/https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zazcVU_rNyQ

For decades, many of us in the public diplomacy space have been warning that university campuses, especially the elite, Ivy League have become hotbeds of intimidation, harassment and at times, violence. The annual festival of hate known as Israel Apartheid Week, which makes its way across global campuses every March, has rendered campuses “no go” zones for Jews for over a decade. Universities did little if anything to protect Jewish students, hiding once again behind free speech. Jewish faculty who are Zionist have also been threatened and intimidated by anti-Israel students. This has exacerbated since the war between Israel and Hamas, which followed the invasion by Hamas terrorists, resulting in the murder, torture, rape, burning and kidnapping of civilians. In the last few weeks, this has spiraled into a serious of protests and encampments on universities across the United States.

It is not just students engaged in protests on campus. Faculty members are also supporting or participating in these protests.

Free speech is sacrosanct. Free speech is imperative in a democracy and the rights of anyone to exercise that freedom must be protected, no matter how obnoxious it is or how much we disagree with it. A line has been crossed. Protesters have not been criticizing Israeli policies or how the country is prosecuting its war against terror organisation, Hamas, following the atrocities of 7/10.

Together with Terrorists. Flags bearing the logos of the US-designated terror groups Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP) and Hezbollah are seen at the encampment protests at California State Polytechnic University, Humboldt (left) and Princeton University (right).

Protesters and their supporters are trying to hide behind free speech but the bile spewing from the mouths of the mob has crossed the line way into hate speech territory.

Hamas’s useful idiots on campus, employing rhetoric straight out of the Hamas Charter or Goebbels book of propaganda, have included comments and actions such as:

  • Chants of “We are Hamas” and “bomb Tel Aviv
  • October 7th will happen to American Jewish students 10,000 times over

 “American Jews are Al-Qassam’s (Hamas military wing) next target

  • Jewish student stabbed in the eye.
  • Israeli Arab activist, Yosef Hadad beaten up.
  • Chants of “There is only one solution, Intifada, revolution
  • Chants of “Ya Hamas, give them hell
  • Liquid thrown at Jewish students to prevent them from getting to their dormitories.
  • Human chain created to block one Jewish student from reaching her dormitory.
  • Jews told to “go back to Europe!”; “Goodbye Nazis go back to Poland!”
  • University Rabbi asking students to go home, as they are not safe on campus.
  • School canceled and classes moved to zoom to protect Jewish students.
  • Israeli flag burned.
  • Chants of “Ya, Hamas we love you, we love your rockets too
  • Students encouraged to become martyrs for Palestine.
  • Jewish Israeli Professor, Shai Davidai barred from campus because the university cannot ensure his safety.
  • Chants of “NYPD, KKK, OIF (Occupying Israeli Forces) they are all the same
  • Calls to “globalize the Intifada”. Many will remember the intifada’s of 1987 and 2001 that resulted in a significant increase in terror attacks on Israeli citizens. In the early 2000’s, suicide bombings on buses and in restaurants and more were the grotesque signatures of terror.
  • Khymani James, leader of the protests saying, “Zionists must die”. Likening Zionists to white supremacists and Nazis he claimed they are “all the same people”, adding: “The existence of them and the projects they have built, i.e. Israel, it’s all antithetical to peace. It’s all antithetical to peace. And so, yes, I feel very comfortable, very comfortable, calling for those people to die.” James also said, “I don’t fight to injure or for there to be a winner or a loser, I fight to kill.” James has been suspended from campus.

Israeli satire show “Eretz Nehederet” pretty much nailed it in the early weeks of the war with this biting satire:

All this and more is being screeched while parading and setting up encampments outside of buildings that bear the names of notable Jewish philanthropists. Jews have poured money into universities, hospitals and other institutions in order to largely benefit those less fortunate or to give back

Most students could not tell you which river or which sea they are chanting about. When future leaders use TikTok as a news source, takes their geopolitical analysis from a Hadid sister or wears that watermelon t-shirt promising a free Palestine at the expense of sovereign Israel, we can see that not only has the education system failed them – but we are seeing the collapse of western society in real time. The Ivy League universities are now looked upon as “poisoned ivies”.

‘Sign’ of the Times. Signs displayed at the Yale University encampment honor PFLP-affiliated Walid Daqqa (left) and Leila Khaled (right).
A Violent Sign. In front of supporters for Israel, a masked woman (possibly, like many others, a “hero” that is afraid to be identified) holds up a threatening Al-Qassam sign at a Columbia University protest on April 20, 2024. It is unknown whether she is affiliated with Columbia University. Al-Qassam is the armed wing of Hamas. (Photo: ABC News)

The problem that these protesters have is that Israel is demonstrating the audacity of self-defence against an enemy they are shilling for – but many have absolutely no idea just how brutal and oppressive those they are supporting are. When asked about the atrocities of 7/10 or how they feel about Jewish students fearing for their safety, the usual default response is “that is a false narrative”. Sigh.

It is clear that universities, many who receive vast amounts of cash from countries like Qatar, and whose faculty and students are being increasingly radicalized, have failed to educate the next generation. Students are ignorant of the facts and are virtually incapable of critical thinking.

If universities cannot and will not protect Jewish students and ensure their safety – perhaps it is time for generous Jewish donors to divest from them.

One has to wonder, if any other minority group were treated like this, what would the universities do? We all know the answer. They would not tolerate any of this. It is different for Jews – and that is rank antisemitism.

Many are asking: What “the day after” looks like for Gaza?

I think the other discussion we need to have is what does the day after look like for Jewish communities, Jewish students and faculty. How do Jewish students go back to classes, knowing that some of their professors engaged in protests that called for their extermination? How will they feel safe amongst their peers again?

Terror Takeover. Graphics circulated by student groups advertising the encampments at New York University (left) and The New School (right) utilize inverted red triangle imagery, which signifies support for VIOLENT Palestinian resistance against Israel. The symbol first appeared in propaganda videos promoted by the al-Qassam brigades, the military wing of Hamas.

Students attend classes with names of generous Jewish donors emblazoned on their buildings. If these universities are NOT going to protect Jewish students and faculty, perhaps it is time for donors to divest – and contribute to universities that WILL protect their human rights.





Lay of the Land Weekly Newsletter- 05 May 2024

Unveiling the contours and contrasts of an ever-changing Middle East landscape Reliable reportage and insightful commentary on the Middle East by seasoned journalists from the region and beyond

Home

Like this content? Please share and tweet it to your friends and followers.

To subscribe via email please send a mail noting your request to: layotland@gmail.com 
Please visit/ join/follow our social media platforms:

Facebook page: http://www.facebook.com/LotLSite/

X (Twitter): Lay Of The Land – @layoftheland5

Also available on YouTube @The Israel Brief  – Simply click on the red subscribe button to receive alerts when a new report is posted.



What’s happening in Israel today? See from every Monday – Thursday LOTL’s The Israel Brief broadcasts and on our Facebook page and YouTube by seasoned TV & radio broadcaster, Rolene Marks familiar to Chai FM listeners in South Africa and millions of American listeners to the News/Talk/Sports radio station WINA, broadcasting out of Virginia, USA.

THE ISRAEL BRIEF- 22 April – 02 May 2024
(Click on the blue title)



Lay of the Land’s photo of the week

Heading into the Lion’s Den. Amidst intense animosity and threats, Eden Golan, wearing a hostage pin, jets off to Sweden to represent Israel at the 2024 Eurovision at Malmö, known for its hostile reception to Jews.
Watch Israel’s entry ‘Hurricane’: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lJYn09tuPw4




Articles

Please note there is a facility to comment beneath each article should you wish to express an opinion on the subject addressed.

(1)

THE GENOCIDE NOBODY TALKS ABOUT

Why the silence surrounding Muslim massacres of Christians across Africa and the Middle East?
By Rolene Marks

Home Alone. Without any support from the multitude of animated students at colleges across the USA
and Europe, these Nigerian Christians are left to protest in Nigeria ALONE following 
mass killings by Islamic Groups.

THE GENOCIDE NOBODY TALKS ABOUT
(Click on the blue title)



(2)

JUDGING GENOCIDE

The ICJ’s decision on ‘South Africa v Israel’ clarified
By Emeritus Professor Raymond Wacks

Charade at Court. While genocide requires “a specific intent to annihilate a particular nation or ethnic group”,
the “only nation” at The Hague in fear of annihilation is Israel (‘the accused’), and the only group 
harboring such genocidal intent is Hamas – not even a party to the ICJ proceedings!

JUDGING GENOCIDE
(Click on the blue title)



(3)

I AM BLOCKED FROM VOTING IN SOUTH AFRICA’S NATIONAL ELECTION

If you can vote in Ramallah and not Tel Aviv, is the ruling ANC manipulating who of its nationals abroad can vote?
By Kenneth Moeng Mokgatlhe

“Nope” to Vote. The decision of South Africa to shut down its embassy in Tel Aviv has also effectively
shut down any chance for the writer – a scholarship student as an Israeli university – of voting
in his country’s national elections on May 29.

I AM BLOCKED FROM VOTING IN SOUTH AFRICA’S NATIONAL ELECTION
(Click on the blue title)



(4)

CUNNING CONNIVING CARLSON

Tucker Carlson’s disgraceful pre-Passover modern ‘Blood Libel’ on public television.

Manipulators of Facts. Tucker Carlson (left) falsely accuses Israel of persecuting Christians during
a friendly interview with a Palestinian pastor, Rev. Munther Isaacs (right) while ignoring 
Hamas’ sexual atrocities or murder of Israelis nor any mention of the hostages.

By Jonathan Feldstein

CUNNING CONNIVING CARLSON
(Click on the blue title)



LOTL Cofounders David E. Kaplan (Editor), Rolene Marks and Yair Chelouche

To unsubscribe, please reply to layotland@gmail.com






CUNNING CONNIVING CARLSON

Tucker Carlson’s disgraceful pre-Passover modern ‘Blood Libel’ on public television.

By Jonathan Feldstein

If there was ever a doubt about Tucker Carlson being an antisemite, not anymore.  It’s clear that he’s a card-carrying member of a club that embodies and propagates the oldest hate.

His recent 43-minute diatribe with Rev. Munther Isaac is nothing more than a modern antisemitic blood libel. How appropriate that he aired this hate and lie-filled program just before Passover, around which antisemites have propagated blood libels against Jews for millennia, accusing Jews of murdering Christians to use their blood to bake matza. Tucker didn’t miss a cue, and his lies were as bald as the blood libel itself.

Manipulators of Facts. Tucker Carlson (left) falsely accuses Israel of persecuting Christians during a friendly interview with a Palestinian pastor, Rev. Munther Isaacs (right) while ignoring Hamas’ sexual atrocities or murder of Israelis nor any mention of the hostages.

There are too many lies in Tucker’s hate fest to debunk one by one. (These will be addressed in a follow up article.) What’s clear is that Tucker was in his prime, inviting someone who is not also just a card-carrying lifetime member of the antisemite club, but who has made his career in it. Rev. Isaac hides behind a collar pretending that he’s a theologian, but he’s a nothing more than a Palestinian Arab Christian pedaling in ‘replacement theology’ – a doctrine that the Christian Church has superseded the Jewish people, assuming their role as God’s covenanted people.

Throughout most of the conversation, Tucker sits silently, staring, absorbing Isaac’s lines, and plotting his next ones. It’s almost as if they rehearsed, with Tucker slowly lobbing Isaac a loaded question, and Isaac knocking it out of the park with baseless lies behind every swing. In some instances, Tucker interrupts Isaac to hone down on a point, but never once challenges even Isaac’s most blatant transgressions.

Inviting Isaac for this platform is bad enough. Tucker and his producers should know better. It seems facts don’t matter. The question one is left with is to what degree Tucker is motivated by gross ignorance, or malicious hate. But either way, he goads Isaac repeatedly.

One instance that was glaring, Tucker states that Evangelical leaders care more about the “highly secular” government of Israel than they care about Christians of the Middle East. This of course leads Isaac to excoriate Christian Zionism, based on a (false) belief that Christians must support Israel because the Bible says so, citing theological reasons with which he disagrees why this is the case. As if he’s an authority, Isaac dismisses Jews as descendant from the ancient Israelites selected to be in a covenant with God as the Chosen People. This conveniently leads to the negation of the Jewish people being seeded by God the Land of Israel, hence no rightful Biblical claim.

Propaganda Pastor. Tucker Carlson’s ‘pastor from Bethlehem’, Rev. Munther Isaacs. This high priest of antisemitic Christianity justified the Hamas October 7 attack and is on board of an organization calling Judaism a “dead letter”.

Tucker continues to set up Isaac for his fact-less monologue, saying that the US is “paying for a lot of these military operations” that they claim, target and persecute Christians. Isaac doubles down on Tuckers assertion, drawing conclusions from the most sweeping and baseless generalizations.

By repeatedly delegitimizing Israel as secular, Tucker and Isaac suggest that Israel doesn’t have a right to exist, and that God’s covenant is conditional on whether the Jewish people are secular or religious.  Tucker and Munther manipulate and trample all over the Judeo Biblical narrative and then use it to hold Israel to a different standard. If that’s not antisemitic, I don’t know what is.

One didn’t need to watch the entire grueling program/pogrom to recognize the contrived diabolical drift. At the beginning of the diatribe, it was clear where it was going.  Isaac conflates allegations of human rights abuse and genocide against all Palestinian Arabs in general with the status of Christian Arabs. He lets Tucker (and Tucker’s vulnerable followers) believe that a war against a terrorist organization in a Palestinian culture – that allows, celebrates, and supports terror and kidnapping – is de facto the same as the situation for Palestinian Arab Christians.  Isaac blames Israel and Israel alone for problems facing Christians rather than Israel’s extremist Islamic neighbors.

This is a well-documented lie. Both interviewer and interviewee know only too well that the Christian population of Bethlehem – Rev Munther Isaac’s hometown – used to be 80% before the Palestinian Authority took control in the 1990s, and that today it stands at a paltry 10%. They both also know that true cause for this dramatic drop has nothing to do with Jews – the traditional and convenient scapegoat – but the conduct of Palestinian Arab Muslims.

I’ve experienced this personally.  A few years ago, I decided to buy custom made coffee mugs from a Palestinian Arab Chrisian from Bethlehem. The product is high quality but I also wanted to support Christian business in this once thriving Christian city. Off course, I could not safely enter Bethlehem, so we arranged to meet at an agreed spot outside the city.  Everything was friendly and cordial until I suggested that we take a selfie together.  “Why,” he panicked as his demeanor morphed from warm, to cold, to fearful.

What are you going to do with it?” he asked, clearly terrified.

When I replied that I wanted to share with my Chrisitan friends overseas who would be pleased to know that we were supporting Christian business in Bethlehem, he told me “NO”; he cannot have a photo taken.  “It would be dangerous for me,” he explained, “if it ever got out that he was doing business,” with me – the enemy!

As innocuous as having a joyful photo taken, became for this hard-working Christian Arab from Bethlehem, a life and death issue.

In addition to slandering Israel as “secular”, not once but four times, Tucker literally doesn’t blink as Isaac accuses Israel of “occupation” a whopping six times, and mentions the “Nakba/catastrophe,” “settlements”, “siege”, “genocide”, “war crimes”, “human rights abuse”, “international law”, “collective punishment”, and “apartheid” all to slander Israel. Delegitimizing Israel oozes out of Isaac’s pores, using these to blame Israel for the plight of the Palestinian Arabs. Never once do Tucker-Munther mention Hamas or the actual massacre and kidnapping that took place on October 7. Tucker does not push back once on Isaacs’ barrage of attacks, even hinting that Hamas and the Palestinian Authority MIGHT be just a little responsible.

Carlson’s True Colors. Carlson urged Republicans to cut off military aid to Israel saying, “It would be pretty easy for Republicans in the U.S. Congress to say we support the government of Israel but if you touch a single Christian, harm a single church, prevent any Christian from practicing his religion, you’re done. Not a single dollar will come from the U.S. Congress for you.”

There was no mention of Hamas’ sexual atrocities or murder of Israelis nor any mention of the hostages or Iran’s fiendish influence. What Carlson really seemed to be saying without saying was that “Jews are killing Christians.”  It was a disgrace.

Master at mainstreaming antisemitism, Carlsons’ conduct was nothing more than a shocking antisemitic interview with a Palestinian propaganda pastor.



About the writer:

Jonathan Feldstein ­­­­- President of the US based non-profit Genesis123 Foundation whose mission is to build bridges between Jews and Christians – is a freelance writer whose articles appear in The Jerusalem Post, Times of Israel, Townhall, NorthJersey.com, Algemeiner Jornal, The Jewish Press, major Christian websites and more.





THE ISRAEL BRIEF- 22 April-02 May 2024

The Israel Brief – 22 April 2024 Strike on Iran. UNSC vote vetoed. Chaos at Columbia. Welcoming Pesach. 




The Israel Brief – 24 April 2024  Campus horror. Denial of mass graves. Fury at UN Chief. Pesach seders. 



The Israel Brief – 25 April 2024  Hamas release proof of life video of hostage. Campus update. Hamas to recognize two states? Biden meets Idan. 



The Israel Brief – 30 April 2024 Columbia protests heat up. US cautions ICC. Hostage deal. Google fires more staff.



The Israel Brief – 01 May 2024 Blinken in Israel. Campus update. Netanyahu’s comments about the ICC. German ambassador attacked in the West Bank. 



The Israel Brief – 02 May 2024 Hostage deal update. Colombia severs ties. Lapid in UAE. Saudi Arabia clamps down on anti-Israel hate.







I AM BLOCKED FROM VOTING IN SOUTH AFRICA’S NATIONAL ELECTION

If you can vote in Ramallah and not Tel Aviv, is the ruling ANC manipulating who of its nationals abroad can vote?

By Kenneth Moeng Mokgatlhe

It is so disappointing to me that I won’t be able to execute my national duty to vote for my desired government on 29 May. For the first time since I was eligible to vote in the 2009 general elections, the ANC government will make it impossible for South African citizens in Israel to cast their vote to bring about much-needed change in government. I was told a week ago by Independent Electoral Commission (IEC) officials that I should go to other missions outside Israel to vote, such as Ramallah, Aman or Cairo. Really? That is effectively telling me:

 “You can’t vote!”

The illogical decision to shut down South Africa’s embassy in Tel Aviv is starting to impact negatively on South African citizens studying or working in or touring Israel. I could not reach out to anyone at the IEC when the online registration was giving me problems. Although I am pleased that I finally did manage to register to vote, it worries me that without an embassy, South Africans in Israel might be prevented from taking part in the upcoming elections.

Selective Voters. South Africans queuing up at Trafalgar Square to vote in South Africa’s 2014 election, a right now being denied to prospective voters in Israel.

The IEC and the SA government are duty-bound to ensure that all South African citizens in the diaspora can participate in the upcoming extraordinary elections, which will mark the 30th anniversary of the first historic and inclusive elections in 1994 when a charismatic statesman, Nelson Mandela, led the ANC to its outright victory. I am writing this column from Israel where I’ll be based even during these important elections where I want to help escort the ANC out of our Union Building. Just as people lined up in the long queues to vote for the ANC in 1994, while in Israel I want to do the opposite by adding my name to those voting to uproot the ineptitudes and delinquents from public office.

Following a resolution taken by the ANC at its elective conference in 2017, the SA government decided to downgrade its embassy in Tel Aviv. They have since moved from a downgrade to an entire shutdown of the office. Paradoxically, while the embassy is closed, there remain some cultural and economic ties between the two countries.

Closed for Business. “It’s outrageous that South African citizens arrived at the South African embassy in Ramat Gan to find a notice stuck on the door saying, ‘This office will be closed until further notice’,” says South African Jewish Board of Deputies (SAJBD) National Director Wendy Kahn.

I am a student at one of the universities in Israel where I was awarded a prestigious scholarship. This scholarship makes it possible to send between $200 to $250 to my family back in South Africa. Do we know the importance of remittances? For those who do not have an idea, remittances (money earned from foreign countries and sent to another country) are essential for every economy as it is a critical source of external finance for South Africa. This money plays a meaningful role in combating hunger and poverty, especially in African countries. I am an active economic player, not a burden like many who are dependent on the state for their daily survival.

Most African embassies are operating their embassies to help their citizens on issues that may arise while in Israel. As my country decided to pack their bags and leave us in the cold, it gets lonely when my colleagues from other African countries visit their embassies in Tel Aviv when mine is not there. What I normally do is just join them and learn about the cultural, social and political aspects of other countries because I cannot simply keep on complaining about the ANC’s hostility against Israel.

We are South Africans who went to various countries to look for greener pastures while retaining our full South African citizenship. It was through all the concerted efforts of our forefathers that we achieved suffrage. A right to vote is a pre-requisite of any democracy; we have a right to have a say on who should preside over our polity. It is therefore the responsibility of our government to work together with the IEC to ensure that we become part of the decision-making process.

The Bold and the Beautiful. Back in 2021, Miss South Africa Lalela Mswane, who defied the South African government that pressured her to boycott the contest because it was being held in Israel, told The Jerusalem Post that “If I had not come to Israel to compete in the Miss Universe pageant, I think I would have regretted it for the rest of my life.”

The ANC’s dislike of Israel has led the government to take the most moronic decisions in the past, such as attacking South African artists like Black Coffee (Nkosinathi Maphumulo) who had been booked to play in Israel, while ‘ordering’ Miss SA, Lalela Mswane not to participate in the Beauty Pageant held in Israel in 2021. Orlando Pirates was told it could not play with an Israel-based soccer team last year. David Teeger recently lost his captaincy in the South African Cricket Under 19 side for expressing, as a loyal Jew, his support for Israel.

Defying the Dopes. Despite pressure from BDS South Africa, Orlando Pirates – seen here celebrating winning the 2023 Nedbank Cup – refused in 2023 to heed calls to refrain from playing a friendly game against Israel’s Maccabi Tel Aviv. (Photo: Sydney Mahlangu, BackpagePix)

It is important to stress the importance of voting to all South Africans in the country and all those in the diaspora as it remains our only tool to affect positive change. We have to come to understand that there is no politician or political party that wields power as of right; it is we, the voters, who decide to whom to give this power. We have to elect competent, ethical, and incorruptible political leadership into public office. For all South Africans in the diaspora, especially in conflict-ridden areas like Israel, Sudan, and Ukraine, it should be made possible for everyone to participate in this upcoming historic election. There is a need for all citizens to participate in spearheading political change in our country. 


About the writer:

Kenneth Moeng Mokgatlhe is a political writer and researcher based at Ben Gurion University of the Negev, Israel.